Brexited | the worst threads live the longest

Do you think there will be a Deal or No Deal?


  • Total voters
    194
  • Poll closed .
Just saw the pound, €1.098/£1 and $1.223/£1.

Johnson's started well.
I think it's going to drop at least as far as 1.15 USD to the pound before this is done.

Wouldn't be surprised to see the EUR overtake the pound either.

I'm glad I don't have any money in the UK right now.
 
Just saw the pound, €1.098/£1 and $1.223/£1.

Johnson's started well.

At least he is making millions for his monied friends. The FTSE100 has shot up in the first few days since he became our latest PM.
Of course it is a direct result of the pound dropping in value but if you are an investor, happy days.
 
Raab out in full force this morning it seems. The man is yet to learn a single thing during this whole ordeal. A complete conman and fraud.

Exactly the characteristics you need to be a politician these days. He will go far.
 
At least he is making millions for his monied friends. The FTSE100 has shot up in the first few days since he became our latest PM.
Of course it is a direct result of the pound dropping in value but if you are an investor, happy days.


Do you know any good FTSE blue chip funds to invest in?
 
So is the plan to crash out of Europe, lose an election to Labour who then fail miserably to pick up the pieces thus allowing the Tories another long period of government in which to really feck with poor people, destroy the NHS and enrich themselves?

Because that's how the repubs tend to operate here in the US.

Can you honestly see Labour winning a GE with the fool Corbyn as their leader.
Because I certainly cannot.
 
Do you know any good FTSE blue chip funds to invest in?

By far the simplest and cheapest by the way is to put a sum of money in a Tracker. One that directly tracks the FTSE100. The Fund charges will be minimal.
However, as with most investments the key is to buy low/sell high.
Having said that, if the pound continues to fall the FTSE will continue to rise.
EDIT. Should have mentioned that you can invest in such a tracker online or through your bank.
 
People's vote seized the opportunity

nVdvmaa.jpg
 
What does Ireland do about the backstop now? Yes it's disgraceful how the UK is risking breaking the GFA and Ireland have the right to insist on the backstop and the EU will, honourably, stand by them to the end, let's just agree the UK is 100% in the wrong, I'm not questioning that. As it stands if Ireland tells the EU they will accept the backstop being removed from the Withdrawal Agreement then it is highly likely parliament will vote the deal through and everybody can move on, whilst if they don't it looks like hard brexit and a hard border, or at the very least something unacceptable to many of the Irish.

So, leave aside how horrible the UK is for a moment, and how the UK is solely to blame for it all, what does Ireland do, nothing and accept an imminent hard border, or withdraw the backstop and risk a hard border anyway at some indeterminate time in the future? Officially it's the former, but will Ireland change it's mind?
 
What does Ireland do about the backstop now? Yes it's disgraceful how the UK is risking breaking the GFA and Ireland have the right to insist on the backstop and the EU will, honourably, stand by them to the end, let's just agree the UK is 100% in the wrong, I'm not questioning that. As it stands if Ireland tells the EU they will accept the backstop being removed from the Withdrawal Agreement then it is highly likely parliament will vote the deal through and everybody can move on, whilst if they don't it looks like hard brexit and a hard border, or at the very least something unacceptable to many of the Irish.

So, leave aside how horrible the UK is for a moment, and how the UK is solely to blame for it all, what does Ireland do, nothing and accept an imminent hard border, or withdraw the backstop and risk a hard border anyway at some indeterminate time in the future? Officially it's the former, but will Ireland change it's mind?

The EU knows Johnson does not, and despite how many elections he holds will never have the numbers, for no deal so they will not fold.
 
The EU knows Johnson does not and despite how many elections he holds, will never have the numbers for no deal, they will not fold.
I didn't ask about the EU, I asked specifically about Ireland.

But to answer your point, No Deal is the status quo. The only way to avoid that is for parliament to have the numbers for an alternative, what do you have in mind that hasn't already been rejected?
 
Im not even sure they will finish second?

Exactly. Political parties need to realise that there needs to be a good reason for people to vote for them whereas traditionally people voted along party lines.
To be honest I struggle to think of a good reason to continue to vote Labour.
But I also cannot think of a reason to vote for any other party.
 
I didn't ask about the EU, I asked specifically about Ireland.

But to answer your point, No Deal is the status quo. The only way to avoid that is for parliament to have the numbers for an alternative, what do you have in mind that hasn't already been rejected?

The main alternative is a vote of no confidence, and it actually looks like the numbers might be there.
 
The main alternative is a vote of no confidence, and it actually looks like the numbers might be there.
I didn't ask what would happen in the UK, I asked what Ireland should do.

But to answer your point, yes there could be an election, although there is no guarantee that the EU would give another extension again, and if it didn't my question would still stand. And if the EU did give an extension there is no guarantee that the new UK parliament would be able to come to agreement on anything anyway, article 50 would be just the same with a new deadline, and again my question would still stand.
 
I'm predicting stagflation incoming. Might finally wake up some leave voters but it will be too late.

Our economy will go into recession but the rest of the world won't so prices will get higher and so will interest rates but wage growth etc will stagnate. Gonna be fun.
 
I'm predicting stagflation incoming. Might finally wake up some leave voters but it will be too late.

Our economy will go into recession but the rest of the world won't so prices will get higher and so will interest rates but wage growth etc will stagnate. Gonna be fun.
I agree with you, but not in the near future, as I think Boris will borrow shedloads to create a boom with tax cuts and public spending, the shit will come later. Much as Trump is doing, although he just does the tax cuts.
 
I agree with you, but not in near future, as I think Boris will borrow shedloads to create a boom with tax cuts and public spending, the shit will come later. Much as Trump is doing, although he just does the tax cuts.

Hopefully you are right. Then trump's economy might tank at the same time and things won't be so bad.
 
I didn't ask about the EU, I asked specifically about Ireland.

But to answer your point, No Deal is the status quo. The only way to avoid that is for parliament to have the numbers for an alternative, what do you have in mind that hasn't already been rejected?

Ireland is the EU, throughout they have negotiated as a whole, they're not about to divide now.

Many tories have constantly said they will bring down the government to avoid no deal. It only requires 10 of them and a lot of the ones that would have backed it are out of government now and a few Tiggers have left the party.

Bojo is gearing up for an election and he is trying ti fight off the Brexit party, he's just set up a ministry for veterans the ultimate Brexit (party) backers.
 
I agree with you, but not in the near future, as I think Boris will borrow shedloads to create a boom with tax cuts and public spending, the shit will come later. Much as Trump is doing, although he just does the tax cuts.
I don't think tax cuts and borrowings would offset the flight of capital and the shock in the immediate aftermath.
 
Ireland is the EU, throughout they have negotiated as a whole, they're not about to divide now.

Tories have constantly said they will bring down the government to avoid no deal.
Read my post again, I already said the EU will back Ireland, we know that. Ireland has a parliament of it's own, my question is what should they do?

As for the government being brought down, I'll repeat my reply to Kentonio in case you missed it:

But to answer your point, yes there could be an election, although there is no guarantee that the EU would give another extension again, and if it didn't my question would still stand. And if the EU did give an extension there is no guarantee that the new UK parliament would be able to come to agreement on anything anyway, article 50 would be just the same with a new deadline, and again my question would still stand.

My question was 'What should Ireland do' and your answer seems to be nothing, which is fair enough if they think there is nothing they can do to avoid imminent hard brexit, that would answer the question.
 
But to answer your point, yes there could be an election, although there is no guarantee that the EU would give another extension again, and if it didn't my question would still stand. And if the EU did give an extension there is no guarantee that the new UK parliament would be able to come to agreement on anything anyway, article 50 would be just the same with a new deadline, and again my question would still stand.

If the VoNC leads to a new election and the Tories win then we leave with no deal. If its Labour or Lab/Lib then we have a new referendum. The EU would extend for that, and if the result comes back as still leave then either Labour fudge some deal with the EU in the time remaining on that extension or we leave with no deal.
 
I don't think tax cuts and borrowings would offset the flight of capital and the shock in the immediate aftermath.
Possibly, but profits are profits, and if UK companies forecast big profits from a spending boom, public and private, capital will take advantage of that, and move later when the cycle changes. I could very easily be wrong, but it's not out of the question either.
 
Last edited:
If the VoNC leads to a new election and the Tories win then we leave with no deal. If its Labour or Lab/Lib then we have a new referendum. The EU would extend for that, and if the result comes back as still leave then either Labour fudge some deal with the EU in the time remaining on that extension or we leave with no deal.
Again you've deliberately avoided the question 'What should Ireland do?' for some reason, although I'm guessing you actually think nothing too. Apologies if I'm wrong.

But to answer your point, the Tories winning a general election would not guarantee a no deal at all, there would still be a large number of individual Tory MPs against no deal, and they would still be willing to vote for a deal acceptable to them, ie one with no backstop, so my question for Ireland would still stand, should they help them or not?

I've no idea what Labour would want to do, or more importantly what they might actually achieve with the EU, if they won an election, and I don't believe anyone else does either, so I'm sorry I can't comment on that.
 
Read my post again, I already said the EU will back Ireland, we know that. Ireland has a parliament of it's own, my question is what should they do?

As for the government being brought down, I'll repeat my reply to Kentonio in case you missed it:

But to answer your point, yes there could be an election, although there is no guarantee that the EU would give another extension again, and if it didn't my question would still stand. And if the EU did give an extension there is no guarantee that the new UK parliament would be able to come to agreement on anything anyway, article 50 would be just the same with a new deadline, and again my question would still stand.

My question was 'What should Ireland do' and your answer seems to be nothing, which is fair enough if they think there is nothing they can do to avoid imminent hard brexit, that would answer the question.

My answer was clear, Ireland will continue to maintain the European stance which is one. They negotiate and make decisions at European level not at invidiual parliament level.

There isn't a credible prospect of no deal as far as the current UK parliament is concerned so the EU will not blink.

As far as the extensions are concerned EU will continue to give them in perpetuity because it is in their interest for UK to stay or leave with an agreement.
 
My answer was clear, Ireland will continue to maintain the European stance which is one. They negotiate and make decisions at European level not at invidiual parliament level.

There isn't a credible prospect of no deal as far as the current UK parliament is concerned so the EU will not blink.

As far as the extensions are concerned EU will continue to give them in perpetuity because it is in their interest for UK to stay or leave with an agreement.
I still don't accept that Ireland has no parliament or free will of it's own I'm afraid, but no matter, your answer is do nothing different, which is fair enough, and if there is no hard brexit you will be proved correct. Hopefully hard brexit won't affect me too much personally, but I feel for those it will.
 
Again you've deliberately avoided the question 'What should Ireland do?' for some reason, although I'm guessing you actually think nothing too. Apologies if I'm wrong.

I actually wasn't joining in on the Ireland thing at all, but honestly what Ireland should do is stand by their current position and then if the UK leave with no deal then erect the necessary border controls that they have been forced into. Ireland can't allow themselves to be blackmailed by Britain, and they have the weight of the EU behind them. To capitulate now would be foolish and hugely damaging.

But to answer your point, the Tories winning a general election would not guarantee a no deal at all, there would still be a large number of individual Tory MPs against no deal, and they would still be willing to vote for a deal acceptable to them, ie one with no backstop, so my question for Ireland would still stand, should they help them or not?

I've no idea what Labour would want to do, or more importantly what they might actually achieve with the EU, if they won an election, and I don't believe anyone else does either, so I'm sorry I can't comment on that.

A Tory win under this leadership would pretty much guarantee a no deal, because no deal is still the default position. As you said, the numbers aren't there for the May deal, and Boris is insisting he won't renegotiate without the Irish backstop being removed, which the EU won't do. All that is left is no deal.
 
I actually wasn't joining in on the Ireland thing at all, but honestly what Ireland should do is stand by their current position and then if the UK leave with no deal then erect the necessary border controls that they have been forced into. Ireland can't allow themselves to be blackmailed by Britain, and they have the weight of the EU behind them. To capitulate now would be foolish and hugely damaging.
Thanks, a full and realistic answer.
 
A Tory win under this leadership would pretty much guarantee a no deal, because no deal is still the default position. As you said, the numbers aren't there for the May deal, and Boris is insisting he won't renegotiate without the Irish backstop being removed, which the EU won't do. All that is left is no deal.
Yeah, that's the shit I was afraid of, I was hoping for something different!
 
Again you've deliberately avoided the question 'What should Ireland do?' for some reason, although I'm guessing you actually think nothing too. Apologies if I'm wrong.

But to answer your point, the Tories winning a general election would not guarantee a no deal at all, there would still be a large number of individual Tory MPs against no deal, and they would still be willing to vote for a deal acceptable to them, ie one with no backstop, so my question for Ireland would still stand, should they help them or not?

I've no idea what Labour would want to do, or more importantly what they might actually achieve with the EU, if they won an election, and I don't believe anyone else does either, so I'm sorry I can't comment on that.
Ireland will form a border in the Irish sea and also on the land border there will have to be checks that will utterly decimate cross border trade and travel.

They will blame the UK (rightly so) but they will do it because they have to.
 
What does Ireland do about the backstop now? Yes it's disgraceful how the UK is risking breaking the GFA and Ireland have the right to insist on the backstop and the EU will, honourably, stand by them to the end, let's just agree the UK is 100% in the wrong, I'm not questioning that. As it stands if Ireland tells the EU they will accept the backstop being removed from the Withdrawal Agreement then it is highly likely parliament will vote the deal through and everybody can move on, whilst if they don't it looks like hard brexit and a hard border, or at the very least something unacceptable to many of the Irish.

So, leave aside how horrible the UK is for a moment, and how the UK is solely to blame for it all, what does Ireland do, nothing and accept an imminent hard border, or withdraw the backstop and risk a hard border anyway at some indeterminate time in the future? Officially it's the former, but will Ireland change it's mind?
Ireland will demand the backstop remains. Therefore we are heading for GE and likely no deal. Ireland will not be bullied by English politicians, it's now a point of principal. The fact England (and I say this purposely) feel they can bully Ireland is just a symptom of England's empire heritage which has got them into this bloody mess in the first place.
 
Ireland will demand the backstop remains. Therefore we are heading for GE and likely no deal. Ireland will not be bullied by English politicians, it's now a point of principal. The fact England (and I say this purposely) feel they can bully Ireland is just a symptom of England's empire heritage which has got them into this bloody mess in the first place.
Thanks. I think most English people would say they have no interest in the empire whatsoever in 2019 so I don't get 'bullying', but the empire did obviously create the current situation so I understand you feeling that way.
 
Ireland will demand the backstop remains. Therefore we are heading for GE and likely no deal. Ireland will not be bullied by English politicians, it's now a point of principal. The fact England (and I say this purposely) feel they can bully Ireland is just a symptom of England's empire heritage which has got them into this bloody mess in the first place.

Wales voted for Brexit too and now Bojo has landed the Tories are leading the polls there.
 
Last edited: