Brexited | the worst threads live the longest

Do you think there will be a Deal or No Deal?


  • Total voters
    194
  • Poll closed .
Actually just on this we have had many Catholic Government Ministers over the past 40 or so years who would have advised the monarch.

And we have had Catholics who were Privy Councillors and the Privy Council does advise the monarch in relation to Orders in Council, so I think the 1829 is ignored in practice.
We still haven't had a catholic PM though and people with more knowledge than me about the matter have refused to push the question by converting whilst being PM or applying for the post whilst already being catholic.
 
We still haven't had a catholic PM though and people with more knowledge than me about the matter have refused to push the question by converting whilst being PM or applying for the post whilst already being catholic.

Blair's worry was that he'd be seen as devoutly religious rather than Catholic I think. It's not the kind of profile that the British electorate warm to. I remember him getting upset with a BBC journalist who was needling him about it and was asking him if he prayed with George Bush.
 
yes and no - if she is defeted in the party confidence vote that is corrent...

if however she is defeted in the commons she then has i believe 14 days to win a commons majority or resign - if she resigns again it does not trigger a GE but allows the conservatives to elect a leader who can command a commons majority (which if just appointed by the party and hardline enough for the DUP that shouldnt be a problem)... hence some of the ERG want to take her down in the vote in the commons - I think the vote before is basically to drag it out and make it clear to her she cant win the commons vote so she would be better off leaving on her own terms with as much pride as she can muster
It could be. It would only take a few Tory remainers to abstain and they wouldn't have a majority.
 
surely thats irelavant though... by the time they vote it down there wont be time to run a new peoples vote before we leave on no deal terms
Either the EU wants to work with us or they don't, if they want us to stay then what's the worth in forcing us to leave with no deal?

All this talk of how UK will get concessions, how much the EU need us. Is that leave date is set in stone with no room to maneuver?
 
I know so little about Brexit.. But how likely is it really for a second referendum at this stage? A vote of no confidence gets more and more likely so they will either bring on a leader who will discuss new terms or put it to the people again, is that about right?

I feel like I might have missed 50 steps on the way.
 
I know so little about Brexit.. But how likely is it really for a second referendum at this stage? A vote of no confidence gets more and more likely so they will either bring on a leader who will discuss new terms or put it to the people again, is that about right?

I feel like I might have missed 50 steps on the way.
Still far from likely at this stage. Not even clear she would lose a confidence vote. I think she'd win.
 

I don't think all the people critical of Labour were saying ignore the vote. Personally think he should have been more vocal about the need for a much softer brexit. Meanwhile the entire debate has been hijacked by Tory politics.
 
At the farm?
27c21c335ff9892a0b5fb4e18b39f938.jpg


wasnt it said he fancied a return to front line politics... probably wouldnt happen though
Looking at this photo , he rather fancies episode 1 of Black mirror.
 
Ooh in that case, i could probably be PM too. If I was to campaign i'd take the Trump model. Appeal to the racists, promise the world, attack the media and blame away all attacks on me as fake news, lie thoroughly and repeatedly, all whilst wearing a waistcoat (look how well it did Southgate).

In fact i'd appeal to everyone, i'd say whatever people wanted to hear depending on the audience i was in. If you ask me if i'd bomb Iran, i'd say Yes and twice on a Friday. I'd also say "as long as i can tie you to the bomb". The racists are happy i'll slaughter millions of muslims, the rest of us will realise it's only a joke in poor taste.

Johnson will go that route if he gets a sniff. He's been in close contact with Bannon
 
I hear that BX Brussels are looking for new fans.

There will be a difficult choice to be made alright:

a) Build a wall but no longer being able to follow a Saudi owned United.
b) Leave ourselves exposed to a military controlled by Boris Johnson or Jacob Rees-Mogg.
 
Blair's worry was that he'd be seen as devoutly religious rather than Catholic I think. It's not the kind of profile that the British electorate warm to. I remember him getting upset with a BBC journalist who was needling him about it and was asking him if he prayed with George Bush.
Blair 'prayed' while Dubya, eyes flickering, remained standing.
 
I don't think all the people critical of Labour were saying ignore the vote. Personally think he should have been more vocal about the need for a much softer brexit.
But loudest voices were. We had those eu protests marches and people like Alastair Campbell talking about how awful lying is in politics. Recent polling showed labour have barely been effected by Brexit in terms of it's voting base. Whatever the problems are with Labour position it is at the moment the correct one.

Meanwhile the entire debate has been hijacked by Tory politics.
Good yet the vermin tear themselves a part.

You think? I get the impression there’s a shit load of Labour MP’s and voters who very much want to stay in the EU. Despite Jezza’s stance.
There's a rubbish little liberal party that they are free to join or vote for if they really want to stay in.
 
Looks like their only option. Pity really. Labour need everyone on board to have a hope of ousting the Tory wankers.
How is it their only option? It's a democracy so if the party (as a whole) disagrees with its direction then they should do something about it. If Corbyn is doing his own thing while his party want to do something else then they should feck him off...
 
Either the EU wants to work with us or they don't, if they want us to stay then what's the worth in forcing us to leave with no deal?

All this talk of how UK will get concessions, how much the EU need us. Is that leave date is set in stone with no room to maneuver?

No, the leave date can be extended. And the EU has deliberately placed ensuring the security of the single market and the Union above making any 'sensible' deal (relatively anyway).

Labour goal isn't to stay in the EU.

Officially yes. Although it has softened. Look at McDonnell's shifting on the issue since 2016.

You think? I get the impression there’s a shit load of Labour MP’s and voters who very much want to stay in the EU. Despite Jezza’s stance.

Yes. Basically.
 
How is it their only option? It's a democracy so if the party (as a whole) disagrees with its direction then they should do something about it. If Corbyn is doing his own thing while his party want to do something else then they should feck him off...

Well that would be another option. If they haven’t fecked him off by now though...
 
Looks like their only option. Pity really. Labour need everyone on board to have a hope of ousting the Tory wankers.
They are polling at 40% while the lib dems are at 8%. Labour are doing a good job at holding together their voting base(They've increased they polling with younger voters since the last election).
 
But loudest voices were. We had those eu protests marches and people like Alastair Campbell talking about how awful lying is in politics. Recent polling showed labour have barely been effected by Brexit in terms of it's voting base. Whatever the problems are with Labour position it is at the moment the correct one.


Good yet the vermin tear themselves a part.


There's a rubbish little liberal party that they are free to join or vote for if they really want to stay in.

That's an outstanding conclusion to come to given how fecking awfully everyone agrees the Tories are doing.

Labour should be ten to twenty points up on the Tories, their being behind them is a damning indictment on Corbyn not a positive.
 
the referendum should have taken place AFTER the proposed deal was on the table, not before. no one knew what they were actually voting for. this whole thing has been an absolute farce.
 
Either the EU wants to work with us or they don't, if they want us to stay then what's the worth in forcing us to leave with no deal?

They’re not forcing you to do anything. They’ve been trying to strike a deal with you for fecking ages. It’s the Uk’s inability to a) come up with an actual proposal and b) get parliament to agree to this proposal that is making no deal likely.

The clock started ticking when May invoked Article 50 and no deal was always on the cards from that moment. The fact it’s going down to the wire like this is 100% on the Uk government.
 
the referendum should have taken place AFTER the proposed deal was on the table, not before. no one knew what they were actually voting for. this whole thing has been an absolute farce.

You weren't going to have a proposed deal before because unless article 50 was triggered the UK had a legal right to not only attend all meetings but have a say in the decisions.
 
That's an outstanding conclusion to come to given how fecking awfully everyone agrees the Tories are doing.

Labour should be ten to twenty points up on the Tories, their being behind them is a damning indictment on Corbyn not a positive.
Good twitter thread



Also if there's this massive support for remaining why is lib dems polling so shite ? Again saying labour should be x points a head is living in a fantasy land.
 
They are polling at 40% while the lib dems are at 8%. Labour are doing a good job at holding together their voting base(They've increased they polling with younger voters since the last election).

And losing Labour voters/politicians to the Lib Dems because they have a much clearer stance on Brexit will help only one party, the Tories.
 
And losing Labour voters/politicians to the Lib Dems because they have a much clearer stance on Brexit will help only one party, the Tories.
They aren't losing any voters to the lib dems or at least not enough to off set the loses that would come from leave voting labour voters.
 
Also if there's this massive support for remaining why is lib dems polling so shite ? Again saying labour should be x points a head is living in a fantasy land.

On the Lib Dem point surely a big factor is that they haven't been forgiven by the centre-left voters they had for the Coalition, and students haven't forgiven them for tuition fees. That and their record in Government was woeful - they didn't even propose same-sex marriage but left that to Cameron.
 
They’re not forcing you to do anything. They’ve been trying to strike a deal with you for fecking ages. It’s the Uk’s inability to a) come up with an actual proposal and b) get parliament to agree to this proposal that is making no deal likely.

The clock started ticking when May invoked Article 50 and no deal was always on the cards from that moment. The fact it’s going down to the wire like this is 100% on the Uk government.
Yea I know, it was rhetorical. Decent summary tho ;)