Brexited | the worst threads live the longest

Do you think there will be a Deal or No Deal?


  • Total voters
    194
  • Poll closed .
It's important to remember that there are solutions to the irish border. They simply don't match with british politicians will.

It will be somebody else's problem when these lot inevitably quit or get voted out in the next year. The likes of Mogg probably won't hesitate to just send the troops in, it's not him who's going to be a victim of potential troubles.
 
What happens if we can't find a workable solution in time?

If the red lines don't change from May and the UK leaves then the backstop is the only possibility other than No deal. even with No deal the Uk are still responsible to respect international law.
There are solutions but none are wanted by the UK.
 
Yes, staying in Europe & stopping this shit.

That's one of them, the other is to have NI in the CU/SM. Now of course the risk is that Scotland will want the same deal but is that really an issue? After all brexiteers are big on self determination.

Also, you have to wonder why Norway and Switzerland two pretty rich countries haven't found that mythical technology that replaces custom checks, they have had decades.
 
If the red lines don't change from May and the UK leaves then the backstop is the only possibility other than No deal. even with No deal the Uk are still responsible to respect international law.
There are solutions but none are wanted by the UK.

Yeah it's a really weird situation, there is no solution to the GFA and leaving the EU simultaneously without fecking something up.
 
Anyone hoping we're going to get a reasonable Brexit is dreaming. My reasons why;

1. It's in the EU's best interests to undermine Brexit. If it is a horrible shitshow, other nations won't want to try it. We're either going to get Mays non-Brexit or we're going to get No-deal Brexit.

2. JC is to weak a leader to take advantage and steer us away from Brexit - it's risky and he won't do it. He'd rather watch the car crash and then try to pounce afterwards hoping people are desperate enough to vote for him to deal with the aftermath.

3. I bet there are scores of multimillionaires who have brexit proofed their businesses and are waiting for a big no-deal brexit crash to happen, so they can pick up companies and property on the cheap. These people all probably fund the Tory party, or are Tory MP's.
 
Anyone hoping we're going to get a reasonable Brexit is dreaming. My reasons why;

1. It's in the EU's best interests to undermine Brexit. If it is a horrible shitshow, other nations won't want to try it. We're either going to get Mays non-Brexit or we're going to get No-deal Brexit.

2. JC is to weak a leader to take advantage and steer us away from Brexit - it's risky and he won't do it. He'd rather watch the car crash and then try to pounce afterwards hoping people are desperate enough to vote for him to deal with the aftermath.

3. I bet there are scores of multimillionaires who have brexit proofed their businesses and are waiting for a big no-deal brexit crash to happen, so they can pick up companies and property on the cheap. These people all probably fund the Tory party, or are Tory MP's.

I have a problem with the first point because after two years the EU hasn't undermined brexit and we still read that nonsense, it was daft then and it's even dafter now.
 
I have a problem with the first point because after two years the EU hasn't undermined brexit and we still read that nonsense, it was daft then and it's even dafter now.

It's what i would do. I can't prove the EU is doing it - and they certainly wouldn't be overt about it if they were, but if i was in charge, i'd make it as difficult as possible.
 
It's what i would do. I can't prove the EU is doing it - and they certainly wouldn't be overt about it if they were, but if i was in charge, i'd make it as difficult as possible.

You wouldn't because you don't need to. And your second sentence makes little sense due to a small fact that british media missed, the moment the UK are out they become competitors, EU nations will simply compete. The narrative of undermining and making it difficult is incredibly dishonest when the reason why the UK wants to leave is to create competitive advantages against the EU.

The facts are frankly simple, the EU didn't undermine brexit and brexit will put the UK on the other side of the table. It's the UK's decision.
 
See answers above, bit busy, so they are short I'm afraid.

As highlighted, not an easy situation to solve.

Grateful for your thoughts on a solution that;

A) Fulfills the referendum of exiting the EU

B) Supports GFA

C) Ensures that the soverignty of the UK and NI is not undermind, such as the enactment of a trade border between parts of the UK

Heres a post from @MikeUpNorth a few pages ago that is a good summary of the UK's options.

Trying to boil the issue down to its most basic terms, is this a fair summary?

Here are three statements from the British wish list:
a) no hard border in Northern Ireland
b) no border in the Irish Sea
c) an independent British trade policy

You can have any two of these, but not all three.

a+b = UK-wide Customs Union (basically the backstop)

a+c = NI remains in EU customs union. The rest of the UK is free to strike trade deals.

b+c = Hard Brexit (leave with no deal)

a+b+c = IMPOSSIBLE
 
See answers above, bit busy, so they are short I'm afraid.

As highlighted, not an easy situation to solve.

Grateful for your thoughts on a solution that;

A) Fulfills the referendum of exiting the EU

B) Supports GFA

C) Ensures that the soverignty of the UK and NI is not undermind, such as the enactment of a trade border between parts of the UK

That is not what sovereignty means.
 
That is not what sovereignty means.

It’s also completely stupid. Northern Ireland is a unique situation, so a bespoke agreement where they stayed in the Customs Union would be both hugely advantageous to NI and a big concession by the EU. Turning it down because of the DUP was ridiculous.
 
It’s also completely stupid. Northern Ireland is a unique situation, so a bespoke agreement where they stayed in the Customs Union would be both hugely advantageous to NI and a big concession by the EU. Turning it down because of the DUP was ridiculous.

It wouldn't be a concession for the EU and it would probably be good for NI. But I don't even care, this has absolutely nothing to do with the sovereignty of the UK, internal borders do not change the sovereign. Several EU members have part of their territories out of the EU's.
 
That's one of them, the other is to have NI in the CU/SM. Now of course the risk is that Scotland will want the same deal but is that really an issue? After all brexiteers are big on self determination.

Also, you have to wonder why Norway and Switzerland two pretty rich countries haven't found that mythical technology that replaces custom checks, they have had decades.
No need. With Ireland there is and need is the mother of invention. So something will be found. The question is when and what to do in the interim.
 
That's a stupid tweet from Tusk. All he's doing there is giving Brexiteer's fuel for their "blame the big bad EU" stance.
 
The feck? :lol: Tusk is not holding back.

Not letting Corbyn off the hook either by the sounds of it.

"People all over the continent, and in Ireland, hoped that the UK would change its mind about Brexit.
But the facts are unmistakeable. At the moment the pro-Brexit stance of the UK prime minister, and the leader of the opposition, rules out this question.

Today there is no political force, and no effective leadership, for remain.

I say this without satisfaction, but you can’t argue with the facts."
 
That's a stupid tweet from Tusk. All he's doing there is giving Brexiteer's fuel for their "blame the big bad EU" stance.
That stance resolutely resisted facts all the way so this is unlikely to change anything.

And let's face it, it's funny.
 
The feck? :lol: Tusk is not holding back.
He's a patronising twat.

Like everything he and his crowd have done has been pre-planned to the last crossed 't' and dotted 'i'.

Greece was a juggernaut careering down the road towards them.

But they were caught with their fingers up their arses and brains in neutral.

This doesn't help.
 
Not letting Corbyn off the hook either by the sounds of it.
This, coupled with what the Lithuanian PM said in Davos, sounds like the EU version of "gerronwithit". The 27 seem to be tired of the UK at this point.
 
No need. With Ireland there is and need is the mother of invention. So something will be found. The question is when and what to do in the interim.

There is always a need to make things easier and cheaper, so I'm not buying the need argument, particularly when you could apply it everywhere.
 
He's a patronising twat.

Like everything he and his crowd have done has been pre-planned to the last crossed 't' and dotted 'i'.

Greece was a juggernaut careering down the road towards them.

But they were caught with their fingers up their arses and brains in neutral.

This doesn't help.
Failing to adequately prepare for and prevent a financial crisis is quite different to actively pushing for something without, y'know, knowing what that thing entails.

I agree it certainly doesn't help. But 1) it's funny and 2) at this point the only helpful thing is that the UK parliament comes up with a realistic option. Until that happens, nothing actually helps.
 
There is always a need to make things easier and cheaper, so I'm not buying the need argument, particularly when you could apply it everywhere.
Maybe not. But such is the way of things. The GFA went to the wire - even overran by a day.
 
Maybe not. But such is the way of things. The GFA went to the wire - even overran by a day.

That's irrelevant, we are talking about inventing a technology not drafting an agreement.

Edit: And Tusk using twitter to vent, is stupid. A little bit of decorum can't hurt.
 
Last edited:
That's irrelevant, we are talking about inventing a technology not drafting an agreement.
And it will be invented. And probably constitute a blueprint for customs all over the world. My point is that pressure generally moves things along.
 
He's a patronising twat.

Like everything he and his crowd have done has been pre-planned to the last crossed 't' and dotted 'i'.

Greece was a juggernaut careering down the road towards them.

But they were caught with their fingers up their arses and brains in neutral.

This doesn't help.
Any plan would have been better than "we'll get everything that we demand before we leave, trust us, the EU will blink first"
 
:lol: This entire thing is just a total shitshow. I'm out, just let us in the North of Ireland have our reunification referendum and we'll be on our way.

 
And it will be invented. And probably constitute a blueprint for customs all over the world. My point is that pressure generally moves things along.

And that's irrelevant to this conversation, this isn't about whether it will be invented in an unknown timeframe. We are talking about it being a thing in the next months and actually working in order to be used at a large scale.
 
:lol: This entire thing is just a total shitshow. I'm out, just let us in the North of Ireland have our reunification referendum and we'll be on our way.



Would it not help matters for NI if all its politicians got back to Stormont and started to govern the place again?

At the moment it seems Britain and the EU are making the decisions (or not!) it is assumed any reunification referendum would surely have to involve and have the consent of both North and South, hence to avoid making the mistake of Brexit there would have to be something more than a binary choice on offer? Or are we way past this stage now?
 
And that's irrelevant to this conversation, this isn't about whether it will be invented in an unknown timeframe. We are talking about it being a thing in the next months and actually working in order to be used at a large scale.
I don't like this any more than you but there is an awful lot of standing on the sidelines and hand-wringing on this thread. All this 'pointing out' to us thick Brits by you, Paul and others is not helping.

We have a parliamentary system in this country that is one of the oldest on the planet and has been the blueprint for countless other democracies.

We had a democratic referendum. Now you can argue until you are blue in the face about whether it should have taken place or what the question should have been or what leave meant.

But by making comments like that Tusk is not just insulting the Brexiters he's laughing at 17.4 million British people. This will be meat and drink to the hard-liners.

Look, this thing will be sorted one way or another. What the fallout will be, nobody knows. I fear the worst. But it will be sorted and the world will move on.
 
I don't like this any more than you but there is an awful lot of standing on the sidelines and hand-wringing on this thread. All this 'pointing out' to us thick Brits by you, Paul and others is not helping.

We have a parliamentary system in this country that is one of the oldest on the planet and has been the blueprint for countless other democracies.

We had a democratic referendum. Now you can argue until you are blue in the face about whether it should have taken place or what the question should have been of what leave meant.

But by making comments like that Tusk is not just insulting the Brexiters he's laughing at 17.4 million British people. This will be meat and drink to the hard-liners.

Look, this thing will be sorted one way or another. What the fallout will be, nobody knows. I fear the worst. But it will be sorted and the world will move on.

So the daily jibes and insults from British Brexit politicians are OK, as soon as someone makes a sarcastic remark the Brexiters get so upset.
He has the patience of a saint dealing with the idiots he's had to deal with for the past two years.
 
I don't like this any more than you but there is an awful lot of standing on the sidelines and hand-wringing on this thread. All this 'pointing out' to us thick Brits by you, Paul and others is not helping.

We have a parliamentary system in this country that is one of the oldest on the planet and has been the blueprint for countless other democracies.

We had a democratic referendum. Now you can argue until you are blue in the face about whether it should have taken place or what the question should have been of what leave meant.

But by making comments like that Tusk is not just insulting the Brexiters he's laughing at 17.4 million British people. This will be meat and drink to the hard-liners.

Look, this thing will be sorted one way or another. What the fallout will be, nobody knows. I fear the worst. But it will be sorted and the world will move on.

It's not the first time that you do this posturing nonsense after making irrelevant posts. None of what you just wrote is even remotely relevant to the post you responded to.