SARS CoV-2 coronavirus / Covid-19 (No tin foil hat silliness please)

So the way death certificates work is that it's split into:
Part 1 - A), B) C) - A seems to be the main thing that kills someone, and then B) and C) are the medical issues that likely lead to 1A.
Part 2 - Other co-morbidities that the patient had but may not have directly contributed to that person's death.

Now when it comes to this topic, the thing I read the most is that "the government" or "the NHS" just puts Cornavirus-19 down on the death certificate even if they never died from it.

I think a good example is today where, once again, I had another woman pass away today. She became COVID positive on the very start of the month, and unfortunately picked up a bacterial pneumonia on top - given her weakened immune system. After 4 days, she passed away today. When it'll come to me doing her death certificate tomorrow, there's scope to say that 1A would be the Hospital-Acquired Pneumonia, and then 1B would be Coronavirus-19. I could quite easily put Coronavirus-19 down as Part A because quite frankly, she was doing so poorly with it in the first place that it's likely she was going to pass away from it sadly. The bacterial infection just seemed to catalyse everything.

Whether I put it as 1A or 1B is actually moot - at the end of the day, from what I see clinically, COVID-19 has killed this lady unfortunately.
Whether I put it as 1A or 1B, I don't think it should raise any controversy whether the government uses it as a figure towards the number of deaths - because it 100% played the major part in the death of this lady.

Now I keep hearing that people put COVID-19 down even if they were asymptomatic with it, or that they had it and had mild symptoms but was hit by a falling seagull from the air so "we have to put COVID down on the death certificate".
Of course the example I've used is preposterous but my point stands.

I've had patients that are asymptomatic from COVID, but have died from a brain bleed - but I have not put down COVID at all down on the death certificate because they aren't linked at all.
I have also never put COVID down on a death certificate "because they've had it at some stage in the last 28 days" and died. I've had a couple of patients die of a bog-standard bacterial pneumonia but had COVID (asymptomatic) almost a month prior - but I have not put COVID down on the death certificate because all the other tests pointed at it being a bacterial cause or an aspiration cause rather than viral COVID pneumonitis.

Long, lengthy post so I do apologise but I just thought I'd share what they bang on about when it comes to death certificates. I didn't want to bring more common presentations because naturally some have lost members of family through non-COVID conditions during the last few months and I think people do forget that. Medicine has continued despite COVID and we still deaths that are fully unrelated to COVID.



Fine, I can't speak for all doctors/hospitals. That is 100% true and maybe I shouldn't put a blanket statement like I said. But I've worked in two hospitals during the COVID pandemic, and from my experience in both, COVID has only ever been put on the death certificate only if it's played a massive contribution towards the death - and the vast, vast, vast majority - COVID is 1A. I am working on the Respiratory COVID ward, so granted we get the sickest COVIDs in the hospital before they are deemed to require intubation in ITU - so naturally I am going to see more deaths that are full barn-door COVID. But I also help the more junior members of the team on the non-COVID Respiratory ward - and work on calls where I see a whole concoction of presentations who may die on admission. In my current hospital, there's guidance for us to say to only put down COVID if its played a role in their deaths. I can safely say that I'm part of the cohort in my hospital who have seen more COVID in the last few months than anyone else in the hospital - which unfortunately means I've done a fair few death certificates so I feel I can hold a fairly valid opinion on this whole death certificates debacle.
Thank you so much for this, really appreciate the time and effort, and you kind of confirmed what I suspected and eloquently described what I was trying to say clumsily.

Thanks again and I hope things get better for you and your work soon.

One thing I’d like to ask, why do people think that doctors are writing Covid 19 on death certificates for people who have say died in a car crash? Is it just rubbish perpetuated by twitter?
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much for this, really appreciate the time and effort, and you kind of confirmed what I suspected and eloquently described what I was trying to say clumsily.

Thanks again and I hope things get better for you and your work soon.

One thing I’d like to ask, why do people think that doctors are writing Covid 19 on death certificates for people who have say died in a car crash? Is it just rubbish perpetuated by twitter?

Answered your own question there.
 
Boris speaking at 5pm.

On the Radio they had a gym owner from Manchester on, saying she's stayed open and people coming in for classes. Hopefully she get's a full £10k fine, and then no further help for her business. Fine those attending £100, and then take their financial support away too imo.

Harder and tougher action is now needed against those who break these rules, because in 2-3 weeks we' re in a for a shit storm

Jesus. Why not just kill them now so they can't ever catch or spread the virus!?
 
Boris speaking at 5pm.

On the Radio they had a gym owner from Manchester on, saying she's stayed open and people coming in for classes. Hopefully she get's a full £10k fine, and then no further help for her business. Fine those attending £100, and then take their financial support away too imo.

Harder and tougher action is now needed against those who break these rules, because in 2-3 weeks we' re in a for a shit storm
If your fit and healthy you'll be ok, so lets close all the gym's and keep McDonald's open. Makes sense doesn't it?
 
I’ve done some work on that test. I’m slightly surprised their sensitivity was as low as 50%. I’ve used it with swabs and sensitivity has been >80%. Maybe it’s the saliva. LAMP does have quite a few drawbacks, but it is quick. Plenty of other rapid tests for them to try. Even good old RTqPCR can be fairly rapid (~45min) if optimised further.

Headline of the article annoys me. It might as well read “operation moonshot is stupid, the tories are wasting money.” The stuff in the article is a routine evaluation that has ruled something out.
 
Thank you so much for this, really appreciate the time and effort, and you kind of confirmed what I suspected and eloquently described what I was trying to say clumsily.

Thanks again and I hope things get better for you and your work soon.

One thing I’d like to ask, why do people think that doctors are writing Covid 19 on death certificates for people who have say died in a car crash? Is it just rubbish perpetuated by twitter?

It's all good!
In terms of the question - I've read a huge amount of shit on social media from people who are, quite frankly, absolute fecking idiots. I can't say for 100000% certain that no one has ever done that, but I'd be astonished if that has ever happened anywhere. It sounds like the classic Covidiot who run the parade of it not being a real thing or that it's being blown well out of proportion etc etc. This sounds like some of that shit.
 
Boris speaking at 5pm.

On the Radio they had a gym owner from Manchester on, saying she's stayed open and people coming in for classes. Hopefully she get's a full £10k fine, and then no further help for her business. Fine those attending £100, and then take their financial support away too imo.

Harder and tougher action is now needed against those who break these rules, because in 2-3 weeks we' re in a for a shit storm

meh, gyms haven’t been a massive problem though. Have you ever visited one?
 
Yes, that literally does make sense as if we closed takeaways we would cripple a massive part of the economy.
So stay at home and eat a takeaway, then when we are back out of lockdown we'll be more unhealthy than when we went in it. Big chain corporation's get richer and the working class gets poorer. Gyms are much cleaner than a supermarket.
 
So stay at home and eat a takeaway, then when then when we are back out of lockdown we'll be more unhealthy than when we went in it. Big chain corporation's get richer and the working class gets poorer.

Surely there are more big chains working in the gym industry than there is in the takeaway industry?
 
actually think 2021 will be worse then 2020, can only see things getting worse, any vaccine is really just going to be a massive gamble as wont have been able to be tested properly.
Vaccine will be fine but it won’t come for a while and when it does, distribution will be difficult. How many people can realistically get it per month, 10 million?

It will be worse because people won’t treat restrictions as seriously with every lockdown that follows. Trend here is that most neglect the danger or don’t think the virus exists at all, it will get worse and worse with each wave for all those except the ones who will either suffer themselves or have someone in their family suffer/die.

Also it appears we are getting quite a few reinfections which puts the immunity argument in question.
 
Headline of the article annoys me. It might as well read “operation moonshot is stupid, the tories are wasting money.” The stuff in the article is a routine evaluation that has ruled something out.

I wonder why such a different?

Easy to assume it is more of the incompetent shot show I guess.
 
Thank you so much for this, really appreciate the time and effort, and you kind of confirmed what I suspected and eloquently described what I was trying to say clumsily.

Thanks again and I hope things get better for you and your work soon.

One thing I’d like to ask, why do people think that doctors are writing Covid 19 on death certificates for people who have say died in a car crash? Is it just rubbish perpetuated by twitter?
I have heard that numerous times here as well and it’s always one of few similar stories. Obviously nonsense. If there was any agenda to put covid in death certificate then the last three weeks we’ve been getting 5k excess deaths per week (7.5k jumping to 12.5k, huge spike) and only less than 1k of them were in covid statistics. If doctors ‘get paid extra money for putting covid in death certificate’ then we have a lot of dumb doctors who haven’t seized a brilliant opportunity to do that with all the extra bodies.
 
@Hernandez - BFA

Out of interest, are you working within the NHS in the UK?

I know somebody very close to me who has been working as a nurse on the front line, in one of the biggest hospitals in the UK, since this kicked off, and without hesitation she tells me it definitely happens.
 
Think I’ve got it. Realised an hour ago when my dominos tasted bland. Also think my smell has gone faint too.

Isolated since. Test in the morning.
 
@Hernandez - BFA

Out of interest, are you working within the NHS in the UK?

I know somebody very close to me who has been working as a nurse on the front line, in one of the biggest hospitals in the UK, since this kicked off, and without hesitation she tells me it definitely happens.

Nurses aren’t allowed to sign death certs, so I’d take the opinion of someone who actually completes and signs death certs over someone who happens to work in the same place as them.
 
@Hernandez - BFA

Out of interest, are you working within the NHS in the UK?

I know somebody very close to me who has been working as a nurse on the front line, in one of the biggest hospitals in the UK, since this kicked off, and without hesitation she tells me it definitely happens.
I take it you have asked her why the doctors she knows are putting lies on their death certificates, what did she say?
 
Nurses aren’t allowed to sign death certs, so I’d take the opinion of someone who actually completes and signs death certs over someone who happens to work in the same place as them.

And the doctors, with respect for what they do do, aren’t the ones on the very front line caring for these people and seeing them die and have Covid put on their death certificates when they were only ever classed as “query Covid” at worst.
 
Thank you so much for this, really appreciate the time and effort, and you kind of confirmed what I suspected and eloquently described what I was trying to say clumsily.

Thanks again and I hope things get better for you and your work soon.

One thing I’d like to ask, why do people think that doctors are writing Covid 19 on death certificates for people who have say died in a car crash? Is it just rubbish perpetuated by twitter?

Easy paperwork is what I’ve heard. Especially in care homes.
 
I take it you have asked her why the doctors she knows are putting lies on their death certificates, what did she say?

I guess it’s a contentious point, but it’s hardly news.

23 years ago my then father in law had an epileptic fit in his sleep and died, yet alcohol poisoning was put on his death certificate because he’d had a drink that lunch time.
 
And the doctors, with respect for what they do do, aren’t the ones on the very front line caring for these people and seeing them die and have Covid put on their death certificates when they were only ever classed as “query Covid” at worst.

There’s not a doctor working in the NHS who would put covid on a death cert without a postive test confirming the diagnosis so that bit in bold is pure fiction.

Maybe ask your nurse friend why she thinks doctors are lying on legal documents that they could get struck off for falsifying? What’s in it for them?
 
@Hernandez - BFA

Out of interest, are you working within the NHS in the UK?

I know somebody very close to me who has been working as a nurse on the front line, in one of the biggest hospitals in the UK, since this kicked off, and without hesitation she tells me it definitely happens.
So like, no offence but I don’t believe your friend.

Can she or you answer why? For what purpose would doctors falsify certificates to inflate the Covid numbers? If it was a government thing then surely it’s in their best interest to do the opposite?
 
How is it any easier paperwork than giving an alternative cause of death? That literally makes no sense.

Maybe because a Covid death is taken as some kind of given right now and less questions are asked and it’s notched up as another Covid death for the official figures? I honestly don’t know but I will ask for her take on it.

I really don’t know where fact starts and conspiracy theories end these days.
 
Maybe because a Covid death is taken as some kind of given right now and less questions are asked and it’s notched up as another Covid death for the official figures? I honestly don’t know but I will ask for her take on it.

I really don’t know where fact starts and conspiracy theories end these days.
But why would it matter what they died of? Why would it matter to the doctor? I find it very hard to believe they’d risk their entire career just for the ease of writing Covid?

Notched up as another for the figures? Who’s interest is it for that number to keep rising?
 
Maybe because a Covid death is taken as some kind of given right now and less questions are asked and it’s notched up as another Covid death for the official figures? I honestly don’t know but I will ask for her take on it.

I really don’t know where fact starts and conspiracy theories end these days.
Well the facts start with the amount of corona deaths and the conspiracy’s start with your postings.
 
But why would it matter what they died of? Why would it matter to the doctor? I find it very hard to believe they’d risk their entire career just for the ease of writing Covid?

Notched up as another for the figures? Who’s interest is it for that number to keep rising?
I think in the US anyway, the covidots say hospital get more money to deal with the issue if they are struggling more, ie more deaths?

Or something similar
 
I think in the US anyway, the covidots say hospital get more money to deal with the issue if they are struggling more, ie more deaths?

Or something similar

Yep but they lose money so long as there are high Covid case loads as it drastically reduces the number of elective surgeries, one of their prime sources of income.
 
Golf courses shut and Tennis (even outside) banned during lockdown.

Pathetic!
Meanwhile my mother in law has been told to continue going in to work at the library. That essential part of modern life that people definitely couldn't live without for 4 weeks. We're governed by idiots.
 
Unfortunately though, it definitely is happening and I’d actually be surprised if you really haven’t seen it yourself.

It isn't. I'm working in A&E (locum) and in community (GP practice serving a demographic with high covid incidence)

Deaths in hospital require discussion with a medical examiner first (ME) in bereavement office and in rare instances a coroner
Below is a death certificate example
Death-certificate-blank-600x338.jpg


Part Ia is direct cause with b and c also you work your way back through the other diseases that led to the eventual cause of death

Most commonly in hospital for example during first wave I would write
1a) Acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)
1b) Bilateral pneumonia
1c) COVID-19

Part II is other conditions that were not necessarily in the main causal sequence of death but played a role in hastening death - often Ischaemic Heart Disease.

All of this pertaining to COVID is public knowledge
https://assets.publishing.service.g...l-certificates-of-cause-of-death-covid-19.pdf

Incidentally the Centre of Evidence Based Medicine for the University of Oxford has more details on COVID-19 as cause of death in addition to ONS' interpretation of what's on death certs in terms of their figures
https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/death-certificate-data-covid-19-as-the-underlying-cause-of-death/
 
Maybe because a Covid death is taken as some kind of given right now and less questions are asked and it’s notched up as another Covid death for the official figures? I honestly don’t know but I will ask for her take on it.

I really don’t know where fact starts and conspiracy theories end these days.

You should do that.

One thing I’ve realised from hanging out on message boards full of doctors is that even some of them believe blatantly false conspiracy theories (although never any of the ones who are day to day treating dead/dying covid patients) so would be no surprise at all if nurses are prone to the same.

It’s a terrible fecking shame but Facebook/Twitter bullshit seems to be even more contagious than the virus.
 
Fine, I can't speak for all doctors/hospitals. That is 100% true and maybe I shouldn't put a blanket statement like I said. But I've worked in two hospitals during the COVID pandemic, and from my experience in both, COVID has only ever been put on the death certificate only if it's played a massive contribution towards the death - and the vast, vast, vast majority - COVID is 1A. I am working on the Respiratory COVID ward, so granted we get the sickest COVIDs in the hospital before they are deemed to require intubation in ITU - so naturally I am going to see more deaths that are full barn-door COVID. But I also help the more junior members of the team on the non-COVID Respiratory ward - and work on calls where I see a whole concoction of presentations who may die on admission. In my current hospital, there's guidance for us to say to only put down COVID if its played a role in their deaths. I can safely say that I'm part of the cohort in my hospital who have seen more COVID in the last few months than anyone else in the hospital - which unfortunately means I've done a fair few death certificates so I feel I can hold a fairly valid opinion on this whole death certificates debacle.

Sending you best wishes and resilience, vast vast majority of people I speak to, family members and covid survivors know how much people in respiratory and ITU have done for them. The covidiots don't compare.
 
For me it comes down to the fact that a lot of these people who believe that they are exaggerating deaths or that their favourite sport/leisure activity is completely safe are just refusing to accept reality. The fact that excess deaths (the greatest idea of how many COVID deaths we have had) is ignored and random anecdotal evidence from friends of the family is believed is mental to me. The government and the NHS have absolutely no reason to inflate deaths. Quite the opposite to be honest. But some people just refuse to accept the inconvenience and thus have to twist it to something else.

if you’re losing your livelihood - I get it. It can feel like a death sentence if you’ve got nowhere to go. But quite simply if you don’t believe the death figures because you miss going to the gym or you want a round of golf you’re a knob.
 
For me it comes down to the fact that a lot of these people who believe that they are exaggerating deaths or that their favourite sport/leisure activity is completely safe are just refusing to accept reality. The fact that excess deaths (the greatest idea of how many COVID deaths we have had) is ignored and random anecdotal evidence from friends of the family is believed is mental to me. The government and the NHS have absolutely no reason to inflate deaths. Quite the opposite to be honest. But some people just refuse to accept the inconvenience and thus have to twist it to something else.

if you’re losing your livelihood - I get it. It can feel like a death sentence if you’ve got nowhere to go. But quite simply if you don’t believe the death figures because you miss going to the gym or you want a round of golf you’re a knob.
Well said, and spot on regarding government motivation, what do they gain from inflating numbers? You’re completely right, people are so desperate to go back to their normal lives that they will believe anything, people are just bored of this, and want to justify acting like a jebend.