All these things are about his quality or off the pitch attitude, which is completely away from what people criticize him for, and what you and most are struggling to get. On his day everyone know he's our best player by a long margin. Problem is he's inconsistent and has several games when he's not in the mood to play which is ridiculous for a player of such profile. Pogba's problem is he can't get himself to play 50 games a season with same level of focus and concentration. On his day he's unplayable, but he struggles to maintain this a whole 12 months straight of 2 games a week, and escalates between 9/10 and 4/10. That's what he's criticized for, which the replay on is, like your post, again talking about how great his quality is and how great a person is, both aren't questioned.
Bring me anyone here who said he's a dogshite footballer, or that he alienate the squad and his teammates, I bet you'll struggle to find more than 1 or 2 posts if any, because these aren't anyone's problem with him. His problem is inconsistency and how he turns for some matches in no mood to play. Of course his stats and youtube videos will be great, because that's not the problem with him, because he's a great player, but he's inconsistent as hell and struggle to keep a consistent 7/10 performance for a whole season. He was the same with Juve too, great but inconsistent.