You don’t rate Arteta, I get it. Time will tell if you’re proven right or not. However, from my perspective, there’s currently much to be positive about. The team is playing consistently with much energy and our players are generally young with much room for further improvement. So, I’m optimistic that we will certainly finish in the top 6 and who knows, maybe even better than that. The club is also looking to strengthen the team.
I have no idea whether Rangnick will turn your current squad into world beaters but based upon their performances to date, I doubt it.
Maguire, Lindelof, AWB, Fred, McTominey and Martial are not good enough. Both Rashford and Greenwood seem to have lost confidence not getting enough playing time up against a 34 and a 36 year old who’ve seen better days.
In terms of where you are, I’d say you’re 2 years behind Arsenal.
I'd say this is a top post in all fairness.
First off, I'd like to say the banter between United and Arsenal fans still exist to this day. Despite the declines, it seems both sets of fans hate each other still
. I love to see it because when we gain a sense of optimism, United fans love to shoot us down and vice versa. Traditional rivalry will never cease to exist.
Now to chip in with my view:
If you see my post history, I was probably the most pessimistic b*stard on here regarding Arsenal and their trajectory. I'm still not the biggest fan of Arteta and I think half the fan base are still on edge about him. Quite rightly so I must say. He is a rookie manager that is practically learning on the job - however he has a swift ability to rectify
most of those mistakes quickly and efficiently. A few good examples include:
- Kicking out Willian (He wanted to bring in some experience but he was out the door a season later)
- Aubameyang (Disciplinary issues)
- The swift integration of youngsters mainly from the academy
- Clearing out the deadwood
- Finally a playing style that we can clearly identify
- Obtaining the right players to suit his philosophy
- Ramsdale (Literally no one wanted him)
One main criticism I have is the fact that Arteta tends to persist with players that are badly out of form, impeding the squad. Dropping Aubameyang is a blessing, but his hand was forced a bit here.
These are off the top of my head. Anyway with these points above combined, Arsenal are finally on a clear upwards trajectory which is great to see after so much mess. People argue about the first two seasons, which I kinda get...however -
United supporters especially demand instant gratification. We cannot say the same about Arsenal. Internally and within the fan base we knew a complete rebuilt was due. Lets take a look at the starting XI Arteta inherited compared to what we have now:
Emery's penultimate premier league game against Leicester (Lost 2:0)
Our last game against Norwich
That is a completely different squad. Within two seasons, we have cleared and sold most of the deadwood (a few more players yet to go), signed new players and integrated youngsters more regularly on top of that. During the transition Arteta was on the edge, but now daylight is starting to emerge from the clouds. Arteta won silverware at Arsenal using different players with a different playing identity. It is clear to see why he didn't rate the squad he inherited.
In reference to the post I quoted, this is exactly what United need to do. I would say TJ Reid is spot on. 2 years behind Arsenal in terms of squad rebuild. I think some are getting confused and think Arsenal are a better team. This is not what he is saying. On paper United are better and should expect top 3 at minimum. Top 4 is still a failure for United in my opinion. Even if you achieve that the point still stands, a rebuild is needed to push on to greater levels and to hopefully win the title again. In order to achieve that you'll have to go through what Arsenal are currently doing. A complete rebuild. That is why you appointed Rangnick right?