When ETH first came here I was all for it. Young manager, new systems, hopefully a match for Pep in the long run.
As the first season went along, I thought OK, not too bad given the state of the club and players he inherited, plus we also won a trophy. Didn't expect miracles to happen straight away, but not a bad start and we got CL football the following season.
Second season came along and I was really hopeful, that he would push on, get us playing a new, modern way, could implement his style more and we'd start pushing City a bit more. Wasn't expecting a title win, but was hoping you could see a gradual improvement in our play. Despite injuries which were bloody ridiculous last season, a few months in, it became clear that the style of play he wanted to implement was difficult given the injuries. Never have I known a United squad in my time to be so unlucky with the amount we had. Every now and then, there would be flashes of what I could see he wanted to play, but couldn't. But at the same time, he would often make decisions that truly baffled me, sticking with Rashford when he was awful, swapping Garnacho to the other wing he's not so good on, continuing with Casemiro when it was obvious he couldn't last 20 minutes, not bringing on subs when it was obvious to everyone he should...etc
There was of course, all the goings on of the club sale, which was a distraction.
But despite that we had a great FA Cup run, beating 2 of our biggest rivals to win it. Those odd moments were still in there, we just need to get a solid team together and hopefully it will click. I was also upbeat that a new management system in place, would allow him to push on.
But roll on to this season and within 3 games we're already 6 points behind City and Liverpool. The season is done for any title challenges, we need City to lose 2 games just to catch up and they only lost 3 all season last year.
But what's really made my mind up he has to go are 2 things.
1, he still doesn't have a clue from 2 seasons now, what style of play he's aiming for. He persists with formations that even new managers, like Slot whos been at Liverpool for 5 minutes, have already sussed out how to beat. He leaves gaping holes in midfield and STILL expects Casemiro to play like a 20yr old, when virtually everyone could see he didn't have the legs last season, let alone this.
He persists with a keeper who's simply not good enough, who's not shown any of this 'playing it out from the back' nonsense and can't get low to save any shot on the ground, which is an absolute basic.
He persists with playing Rashford, when it's been obvious for some time that his 'running past defenders' style of play has left him.
He chops and changes the team far too much, often leaving out players, like Amad, for his favourites, which in doing so, filters down the team to messing about with formations.
2. But the final 'light bulb' moment for me, actually came in a two statements he made. One was when asked about Scott McTomminay leaving, he said he didn't want him to leave and the second was yesterday, when he said Ugarte will need some time to bed in, that he's not Harry Potter.
Right there summed him up for me, that he's not got a clue anymore. If he thinks that McTomminay was still the answer (and I've nothing against Mct as a person) after 2 seasons here, then he's deluded and if he can't see after 2 seasons that we've been crying out for a DM like Ugarte, who will get stuck in and plug the holes ETH keeps leaving with his ridiculous formations, then there's no hope whatsoever, that he's turning this around.
Its like hes spitting his dummy out the pram because the management have bought Ugarte and he didn't, but he's going to leave him out for 2 months and carry on with Casemiro, just to despise them.
For me, I'm done with him. He's got to go, when and how I don't care, but he's not going to win us titles, which a club our size and stature, should be aiming for.
I'm no fan of Carragher by any means, but he's spot on when he says Real Madrid and Barcelona wouldn't put up with being 6th, let alone 8th. But under this guy, that's all we're expecting.
As fans, we've forgotten just how big this club is. We're one of the biggest clubs in Europe and on the world stage are we really happy, deep down, accepting this shite every season?
It's time for the management to 'Avra Kedavra' his ass out of Old Trafford.