I thought the second goal was worse. What made him not just come and claim that? Third goal was a ridiculous mistake but the second was really bad decision making
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 29
- Clean sheets
- 7
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 1
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Imran (@Annihilate Now!) are here to discuss Amad saving our blushes in a win against Southampton as well as our now annual loss at home to Brighton. They discuss Amorim's post-match comments, revisit how mid-table we may or may not be, and discuss some transfer news.
He’s one of the worst goalkeepers I have ever watched. He doesn’t do the basics well and always has a mistake in him.
Nah, I reckon if he is aggressive on the second he can, at the very least, punch it.
He's so flat footed and indecisive
He's just not it. He doesn't have great keeper instincts, presence or technique and on top of that he makes frequent howlers. Move him on in the summer and get a new number 1.
Pound for pound one of the top 5 worst keepers I've seen in this league.
I thought that as well. Ridiculous that he didn’t come out to save that.
Had a great start to this season and was probably our player of the year up until November or so. However, there's just no excusing shit like this anymore and how often it happens.
This. Shouldn't start another match ever again based on all the blunders he has had so far.
that's enough. How nice it would be to have someone around like Kovar. We are really fecked. we need to upgrade 6 other positions.
He is the most inconsistent keeper in the league. Not sure that can be disputed
Yep it's simply not sustainable.
Get this waste of fecking space out of this club. He's got as many mistakes as De Gea in his final years without any of the shot-stopping ability.
It’s so obvious within a few matches of watching him too. The only people defending him were using stats to do so, which kinda says it all. I’ll repeat what I’ve said consistently, he has big problems when the ball is low.
He makes errors far too frequently for my liking, you can’t rely on a keeper like that long term.
He’s fecking shite. Do you want to talk about it and discuss how he played well in x game or y game? He’s an absolute calamity, always a mistake in him. Rubbish.
I wouldn't play him again out of principle, he's a clown and should be sold in the summer.
Think it is hard to put into words just how catastrophic Erik Ten Hag's transfer policy was for this club. He has totally ruined our squad with a few of the worst signings in the recent history of the club.
I'm ready to move on now, and echo what others have said about the 2nd goal arguably being worse. That's a cross that every other keeper in the league quite easily claims, and yet he just stares at it.
I'm ready to move on now, and echo what others have said about the 2nd goal arguably being worse. That's a cross that every other keeper in the league quite easily claims, and yet he just stares at it.
Investigate him for match fixing.
He reminds me of David Calamity James at Liverpool. Capable of great saves, but then an unforgivable amount of inexplicable howlers.
He reminds me of David Calamity James at Liverpool. Capable of great saves, but then an unforgivable amount of inexplicable howlers.
His game vs City which made us sign him was just a coincidence. It was him at his peak. But his average level is somewhere between Kuszczak and O'Shea.
Bring back Taibi
His ball playing ability is vastly overrated which is meant to be his biggest asset.
What about that de Gea guy?
Just another EtH's dud. That Pep Guardiola is my idol really left us in the gutter.
I don’t want to pick out a player to criticize, but this is another really bad signing!
I have defended him so much, I am done. Not good enough. Needs replacing.
Hilarious that he has fans
I’ve seen people defend Rashford the last 4 years though so you just have to accept that some people really are clueless,
Should be the end of him now, hopefully we can scrape £20m or something for him in the summer, a complete donkey
I’ve seen people defend Rashford the last 4 years though so you just have to accept that some people really are clueless,
Should be the end of him now, hopefully we can scrape £20m or something for him in the summer, a complete donkey
Onana needs to be dropped, simple as, he costs us so many goals. I would say every other goalie in the Premier league is better than him, and we paid 50m, it's signings such as him which have put us in this ridiculous situation.
Amorin needs to grow a pair and drop him..
Amorin needs to grow a pair and drop him..
Far to many of the players have a clown moment in them.
When Onana has his the chances of getting away with it are very slim.
When Onana has his the chances of getting away with it are very slim.
He will make these mistakes over and over and over and over again.
A complete and utter clown of a keeper. Inspires no confidence whatsoever. People get excited cos he makes saves, most keepers can make saves.
He isn’t commanding, his passing out is over rated and he makes so many unforced errors it’s unreal. Just a total shambles of a goalkeeper.
A complete and utter clown of a keeper. Inspires no confidence whatsoever. People get excited cos he makes saves, most keepers can make saves.
He isn’t commanding, his passing out is over rated and he makes so many unforced errors it’s unreal. Just a total shambles of a goalkeeper.
I've had enough, absolutely shite performance. Don't think he made a single save. Also got lucky his punch of the ball into welbeck at the start of the game didn't end up a goal. Can catch absolutely feck all
Yeah I agree. Let’s not pretend he’s always been shite, he’s had some good performances here and there but you can’t plan around a keeper that makes that many mistakes. Bartez was similar in some ways (though I’d say he was a better keeper). Just isn’t sustainable.
Yeah, Brighton's second was also on him -- perhaps even more so. Like I said this is becoming untenable and he needs real competition for his spot.
Last edited:
Got to some off his line and claim the 2nd imo, but that 3rd goal. It's almost like he's thinking what to do next with the ball rather than focus on catching it first. Sometimes looks like his footwork is cumbersome. I like Onana, and I was hoping early in the season he may turn it around, but my concern is his inconsistency may start to manifest throughout the team. "A great goalkeeper is worth 15 points over the course of a season,” Sir Alex Ferguson once said.
He oscillates too much. Sometimes he’s genuinely very, very good, and other times he does stuff like this. In a weird way if his performances weren’t so volatile I think he’d have less flack
What I would give for a David James level keeper right now.Cost us 2 goals in a very tight game, just not good enough.
Barely had a good 6 months.
I’m embarrassed for all of the posters who felt the need to defend him for the last year and a half. He’s the worst keeper in the league.
A keepers ball playing ability is so overrated in general - there were people on about how many assists a goal playing keeper was going to get us
He's rubbish, I'm done with him.
Listen to Rio Ferdinand's interviews when talking about VDS he didn't speak on Edwins ability but the psychological confidence you get as a defender knowing that there is a highly capable individual behind you between the sticks. And how that same confidence then runs throughout the team.
The only thing Onana is giving the players is anxiety, I don't care how modern, modern football becomes, a goalkeeper should as a priority be judged off their ability to restrict the opposition from scoring. All the nuances like playing out the back and distribution are seconded priorities.
If INEOS have any ambition to not make themselves look clueless like they did with Ashworth and sack yet another manager in place of their own incompetence they put him up for sale in the summer.
Listen to Rio Ferdinand's interviews when talking about VDS he didn't speak on Edwins ability but the psychological confidence you get as a defender knowing that there is a highly capable individual behind you between the sticks. And how that same confidence then runs throughout the team.
The only thing Onana is giving the players is anxiety, I don't care how modern, modern football becomes, a goalkeeper should as a priority be judged off their ability to restrict the opposition from scoring. All the nuances like playing out the back and distribution are seconded priorities.
If INEOS have any ambition to not make themselves look clueless like they did with Ashworth and sack yet another manager in place of their own incompetence they put him up for sale in the summer.