At the risk of getting distracted by a pointless non-sequiter SNL discussion, if my outside objectivity is useful for anything here, it's in pointing out (or confirming?) how amusingly nostalgic such "in my day" opinions of a near 50 year old show that's produced everyone from Bill Murray to Kristen Wiig via Eddie Murphy, are.
As someone mostly aware of SNL through cultural osmosis, the Blues Brothers/Wayne's World films, and post-Digital Short-era YouTube clips (SNL was bizarrely litigious beforehand. I remember downloading James Brown's Celebrity Hot Tub Party on Limewire in the early 00s like it was contraband!) I actually tend to consider the 2005 cast - that you consider the cut off - as one of the GOATS. I mean, if you look at the
line up for that season, it's pretty much a Who's Who of current TV royalty. And while you could say Norm McDonald or Phil Hartman were a classy aspect of
your preferred era, I could counter with the artistic poison that was Adam Sandler, David Spade and Rob Schnieder.... So...?
Point being. McKinnon is great. As is Baldwin's Trump. But they need a wider roster to adequately deal with the wide ranging madness of the Trump era. Also SNL casts are as subjective as musical tastes. Also also, give more shit to Cecily Strong. And not
just because I feel incredibly attracted to her.