He was bad in the first half in my opinion. 2nd half he seemed to play more in the holding role after Mainoo went off, but he did do well to create that one golden chance for Hojlund...
39
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 43
- Goals
- 10
- Assists
- 3
- Yellow cards
- 4
- Status
He was fine in a limited fashion, as usual the over dramatic criticism.
Mainoo completed 16 passes, McT 16 and Amrabat 15.
Won a lot of aerials, did his defensive work well but should have done better with a few passes, created our best chance of the game.
Mainoo completed 16 passes, McT 16 and Amrabat 15.
Won a lot of aerials, did his defensive work well but should have done better with a few passes, created our best chance of the game.
He won the ball a fair bit, but in our lineup today he was an attacker and in attack he was a trash bag and the end of our moves
Had a decent first 15, struggled for the rest of the first half and then was ok in the second (great little pass for Hojlund’s chance). He just isn’t good enough to be starting for a top team but did ok today overall.
Good performance work rate wise but technically so poor. Its like watching a CB play midfield.
First half performance was an embarrassment, lacks pretty much every attribute you’d ideally want in that role and gave ball away easily and cheaply. Not as bad in the second half at least but lack of quality when he had time and space was there for all to see.
Should be playing for fecking Cowdenbeath not Manchester United.
If we have three starting players for midfield, then he's the fourth or fifth.
No quality what so ever. He’s been putting in performances like that for 4 years a few goals this season isn’t masking his ability. West Ham level if he’s lucky.
Yeah, he was okay - he didn't stand out for good or bad in comparison with our other midfielders today.
Just play him upfront, it's not like Hojlund's giving us amazing hold up play
Just remember that Liverpool had 34 shots to our 6. Don't let the result influence your analysis of this game, he was fecking shite again
Just lacks any sort of quality but people seem to be fine with saying he was "okay".
Meh. He was okay. I can't really single him out for anything negative.
Thought he gave his all today.
I don't think any player in the PL is as technically limited as him. Schneiderlin was a better footballer. Ok, that might be an exaggeration.
jsut dont get this workrate stuff, most of the time hes jogging and cant cover the space quickly enough, hes just running like a headless chicken without the ball. Any player with a better positioning wins few ball for us in this game, he§s just oo slow to react to anything. Not talking about his on the ball performance which should send him out of the club straight away. So painful that he nicks a couple of goals a season because simply plays too many games and manager thinks he could bring more goals. He should be substitute to Hojlund up top for the last 10-15 minutes and sold in the next transfer window but you know with the people in the club it wont happen and we slowly fall out of top6.
Any decent club and hes off. Will eventually happen anyway and will be a fringe player for a EPL side and end up with the likes of WBA..
His lack of technical ability in tight spaces means he’ll never be a good enough midfielder for the level we want to be at. And a few goals won’t change that.
It’s embarrassing how much better a kid like Mainoo already is on the ball than him. It’s like watching two different sports.
It’s embarrassing how much better a kid like Mainoo already is on the ball than him. It’s like watching two different sports.
He wasn't as bad as previous games, which is the biggest praise I can give him.
Still an awful 'midfielder' on and off the ball.
Still an awful 'midfielder' on and off the ball.
White privilege
He was terrible in the first half. Heavy touches, passes that put his team mates under pressure, always beaten to the ball, easily out fought. Everton have players who are more technically proficient than him who works harder. It's ridiculous how low standards are these days.
A front-foot CM is his best role but we have better. Good as a backup.
People saying he was ok today after that first half, i really dont know what to say. He causes me distress watching us nowadays
How many attacks did he kill in the first half by not been able to control the 5-7 yard pass?
Last edited:
Scott McTominay, Manchester United captain, a low point in a decade of low points.
I like him, appreciate I’m in the minority but I’m glad he’s here and liked his post game interview, he cares which goes a long way. Good on him for getting the armband today.
I reckon the tea lady cares about united aswell but if she can't trap a ball get her head up and make a pass she shouldn't be playing either imo.
ha ha, he’s had some good games this season and scored some important goals. We’d be far worse off this season without him.
At this point i'd genuinely like to see him as a striker as we have nothing to lose. Didn't like his performance in the first half again, not as bad as Amrabat but still not good. Second half he put in a decent shift.
I agree he's scored some good goals I just think in a season we are a far worse team performance wise with him in it starting games we lose all rythymn and I'm not just saying it's him as the root cause there's a few who disrupt it too.
Last edited:
Undefeated with him captaining the side.
I like the lad. But he's very limited technically. Need technicians in midfield especially away from home when we need to hold on to possession and alleviate some pressure. It's not his game.
He's a great man to bring on in the last 10/15 minutes when we're desperately chasing a goal, decent height to have in the box when defending corners and free kicks, but that's about the limit of his attributes to the team.
He's a great man to bring on in the last 10/15 minutes when we're desperately chasing a goal, decent height to have in the box when defending corners and free kicks, but that's about the limit of his attributes to the team.
If ever there was a player that encapsulated United post Ferguson more than McTominay.
Absolutely terrible footballer and gives the illusion that he is a hard worker but really isnt.
Absolutely terrible footballer and gives the illusion that he is a hard worker but really isnt.
He just runs, hops then runs in another direction. Useless.
Might have snatched a win if we had Hannibal playing in his place. Someone who doesn't treat the ball like a hot potato.
Might have snatched a win if we had Hannibal playing in his place. Someone who doesn't treat the ball like a hot potato.
Gave his all and spoke well at the end there.
Dodgeball is his sport
Spoke well
He was awful really. Especially in the first half. Kept giving the ball away.
I thought he did give his all so that’s what I posted. His quality is regularly questioned and rightly so sometimes, but you could see how proud he was to be captain today. Im not sure why you’re laughing at the ”spoke well” comment? He did speak well, so I posted that he spoke well.Spoke well
He was awful really. Especially in the first half. Kept giving the ball away.
Can’t remember him ever touching the ball.
- Status