I know that people who are against lockdowns bang the mental health drum far too often but I think getting gyms/amateur sports back to normal should be a priority. Not because I’m worried about a huge outbreak of clinical depression if they remain closed but they do provide joy to huge swathes of the population.
Taking part in (or watching your kids take part in) sport is a massive part of what makes life bearable for a lot of people. And it leaves a big hole in their routine now they’re gone. Without these weekly dopamine hits everyone is going to get more and more jaded and less willing to stick to the government recommendations. Plus they’re done while sober, so we can generally rely on sensible precautions to be taken, which doesn’t apply to most other ways we might seek out dopamine squirts.
I think the problem with this, as with all of these suggestions, is that the confines of what you're deeming acceptable socialising are dictated largely by your lifestyle (or at least, as much as I understand what your lifestyle is). Whilst I don't have any objection to the idea that standing around on the side of a football pitch is basically safe (as is probably playing the sport itself!) it seems to me that you could make the same argument for basically any outdoor activity.
I think one of the things that I found hardest during the first lockdown, and more so when the restrictions were being unwound, was the sense of unfairness that what was and wasn't allowed was designed around the nuclear family. At the time I was in what lockdown had turned into a long distance relationship, which was diabolically awful and was for the best that covid ended, but I desperately wanted to see her and couldn't whilst other people's lives were returning to some degree of normality, it was that period that I found really tough, and so did almost everyone I know who was single/not living with their partners.
Perhaps I have an over-keen sense of fairness, but it seems to me that the mental health discussion is essentially one of just that. It's easier for everyone to make sacrifices and to pitch in and muddy together when it's felt like
everyone is doing that, but when it feels like you and people who live lives like yours are bearing the brunt of restrictions that's when, I think, people seem to struggle. On a larger scale, I think it's why so many people despaired about Cummings and then stopped following guidelines.
So, I think for me, the answer is really that (as much as we would love to be able to have those touchstones of normality) a more brutal lockdown is paradoxically easier on mental health. Not only should it in theory mean that it should not have to last as long, but by creating a shared experience it at least feels like we're all pulling towards a collective goal – even if that means that activities that are essentially very low risk and basically fine don't take place either.