Well as far as rating players goes, I prefer the both the Portugese and French leagues for potential transitions to the Prem over many others because both are very fast and physical. So at minimum he'll understand the importance of athleticism/physicality
Ruben Amorim | United meet Sporting release clause
- Thread starter Raoul
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood), Jamie (@Vault Dweller) and Ed (@That'sHernandez) are here to give their reaction just hours after the news has broke. Where did it all go wrong for ETH? What's next for United? and what were the highlights?
They also react to United's loss away at West Ham, including a breakdown of that ridiculous VAR decision.
Isn't it 3-5-2?
That formation you posted is pretty much what Ten Hag was doing.
Antony?
Does this include European football too ?
Don't entirely disagree but do wonder if it would make our lack of goals even worse
I've thought for a while we'd suit 3 at the back. It would definitely suit Maguire and Martinez. Doubtful whether it would be a long term solution though, I've never been a massive fan.
I don't think they're settled enough for us to know that yet. He swapped and changed the backline so much they haven't bedded in so it's hard to say, but right now they are not a unit and need more bodies in there.
Still not a big fan of systems with 3 center backs, but I hope Amorim succeeds here.
He ticks a lot of boxes and I just hope he manages to stamp an identity with the squad and shows clear progression with time.
He ticks a lot of boxes and I just hope he manages to stamp an identity with the squad and shows clear progression with time.
Why not task him with converting Hojlund into Gyokeres like striker? Let him prove him worth as a coach.
Our wingbacks aren't original full backs, they were wingers. I'm talking about Catamo or Quenda and Nuno Santos who are highly technical creative wingers with ability to get forward, dribble and cross the ball adequately. When we play against stronger opposition sometimes he reverts to original full backs like Esgaio or use CB who can play as full back like Matheus Reis for more defensive cohesion.
One of the excuses for Liverpool not appointing him was for playing with 3 at the back. Not sure what truth is in that.
it should. He's only been there for 5 seasons with 34 games per league season.
No. It's 3421. Inside forwards, as opposed to wingers, although one inside forward tends to be more direct.
Im sure you have been asked 100 times, but what are your thoughts as a Sporting fan? Is Amorim ready? Are you sad to see him go?
I believe you're talking about Esgaio, if so you are correct.
Agreed about his press conferences and referee talk. Let's see how he does in English.
You earned a like.
Yeah I don't like 3 centre backs at all but will back him either way.
His record is enough that he deserves a go.
His record is enough that he deserves a go.
I think we have a Inacio type of CB. We need pace and power. Someone like Diomande (but probably better?).
Interesting. Most teams build up in a 3 + 2 now anyway.
yes all games.
Hojlund is a dud, he can’t stay fit.
If he's in for the Chelsea game I'll be fecking amazed
Only 1 starter came from eredivisie.
We also bought Antony and malacia, both of whom are unlikely to feature much under anybody here
I think he has been the best Sporting manager of my lifetime and I'll be very depressed when he goes.
I'll be happy for United though.
The timing and swiftness of Ten Hag’s exit gave me the impression that we had a clear target. Glad that we seem to be moving with intent. Amorim excites me more than pretty much all the other managers we’ve been linked with
Almiron? He's in the MSL bro!
Such a dumb take. It just as dumb as the England fans saying we must have a forigner this time because an Englishman didn't work last time. Or, we cant have another Dutch manager at MUFC because we had two before and they failed. I think we would take Arne Slot right now if he was offered!
Just because they have a similar background, does that make them identical people or have the same ability?
Judge each candidate on their individual merits.
Go and read up on Amorim and you will find they have very different traits.
Is he ready?
From what I've read about Malacia, it's up in the air whether he's likely to feature much anywhere anymore.
If this does happen then I hope he sticks with the style & tactics that have brought him success. If that means 3 at the back then so be it.
The moment ETH talked about not replicating what he did at Ajax at United you knew he was done.
Edit: Fair play to INEOS if they do get this over the line. It’s exactly the kind of appointment we should be going for.
The moment ETH talked about not replicating what he did at Ajax at United you knew he was done.
Edit: Fair play to INEOS if they do get this over the line. It’s exactly the kind of appointment we should be going for.
No rapist or paedophile lyrics, should go without saying but I know what some of you are like.
Why have footballing people at all when you can get such fantastic insight on the Caf
He's talking about Esgaio, who is our RB and he's probably right. I don't see any other player. Perhaps Adan, our goalkeeper who was great in the first two years and then become De Gea like error prone in his last years.Thanks for the info
The whole player selection part sounds less than ideal though
The Geordies/Saudis are going to be raging if we appoint another one of their employees.
Think so but I'd prefer for him to finish the year and see how he does against City and Arsenal in the CL.
He got exposed against Pep in the first time. But he was young back then and he became more pragmatic after that CL tie. He did well against Arteta and Conte though.
Problem with waiting is that you may lose him.
But he has hair.
This. If he can make a player out of an average Championship striker then let him work his magic on the existing squad before fawning over his previous players.
You aren't getting Gyokeres. You already have Hojlund and Zirkzee there and you have way more pressing needs. If you were to splash money in Sporting player, I'd buy Quenda our 17 year old wonder kid to replace Dalot. He fits Amorim system like a glove.