And that was the point of what Scholes was saying and what my initial post was about
Manuel Ugarte | Romano - he’s signed | Awaiting Club announcement
- Thread starter WeePat
- Start date
- Status
I'm not saying we missed out on 90% of our first choice targets, but I don't think Summer 2023 went exactly as planned.
Not sure we preferred Diogo Costa to Onana, so not going to make any presumptions regarding the GK position, but I think we wanted Kane, ended up with Hojlund (I'm very happy with Hojlund, mind you), wanted Kim Min-jae and Todibo, ended up with no CB, wanted Amadou Onana or Youssouf Fofana, ended up with Amrabat.
Last edited:
Agreed...and with ETH not making these decisions on his own any longer, I hope they prove to be correct!
Which is why I said he was being ignorant.And that was the point of what Scholes was saying and what my initial post was about
Why would we get that profile of player if thats clearly not what the manager wants.
Scholes is incredibly dense/ignorant.
I think what he's clearly saying is that the manager is wrong. He isn't ignorant to what the manager wants, he just disagrees with it.
I think he makes sense, great presser and apparently a great tackler in the middle of the field, but poor at progressive passing, but with Mainoo, De Ligt Mazraoui, Shaw and Martinez around him, all who can pick a lovely pass, he doesn't have to take on that responsibility. Anyway he young so could easily develop that side of his game. You need a defensive screen far more than you need another progressive passer of the ball as you are weak often weak when the oppo team breaks quickly.
He is light years ahead of McTominay at progressive passing (and at passing in general).
Disagreeing with what the manager wants does not make you ignorant. Plenty of pundits, journalists, commentators, people in this forum have disagreed with what the Manager has done over the past couple of years. Does that make them all ignorant?
He is elite in ball retention.
Our problems last season were lack of ball retention and lack of defensive presence in midfield.
Progressing the ball is not an issue, we have brought in four players to help with that already.
My mistake
*below.I don't think it's elite, but we'll see. Elite ball retention for me is Bernardo Silva or Lisandro Martínez.
Also, both Ugarte and Mainoo prefer to progress the ball by carrying it, instead of progressive vertical passes. Ugarte always just looks for the closest teammate to him when passing. If Mainoo had elite passing range, it wouldn't be a problem, but that part of his game hasn't developed to those levels yet, and it may not ever happen. We'll see how ETH tries to solve this, but I can genuinely see a scenario where Collyer develops into a much better Mainoo partner in the next 12 months than Ugarte. He seems to be a better passer than the Uruguayan already and his defensive game looks solid too. He's also trying to be brave and show for the ball more and more in order to become a more complete player.
I'm not sure there's much point in comparing him to McT, they're totally different players, McT for instance is lightyears ahead in shots and goals. McT is much more of a box to box type player and can be very effective in attack, Ugarte's game is pressing, breaking up play and winning the ball, which is much more what you seem to need.
Yes. The manager knows best.
I'm not sure what footage you've seen that proves this claim of yours, but I'd love to see it if you can share it with us. McTominay is a good progressive passer when there is space to be exploited, especially in transitions. With Ugarte's passes, it always looks like to me that he barely has enough power in his feet to hit a long range pass, or even a 20 meter pass forward. The ball just travels so slowly in all the passing footages I've seen from him.
Regarding the bolded part, how does this make sense when most of his passes are medium range passes as opposed to short passes? He is also fairly high up for long passes completed and top for accuracy.
I know Pythagoras in Boots told you this in his Ugarte review video but you also conveniently left out the part where he says that his long passing is actually pretty good and something he is able to do frequently and it can easily be worked on.
Obligation to buy allows us to amortize the contract over a longer period of time.
€60m euros over a 5 year contract = €12m euros a season
€10m euro loan fee + €50m euros over a 5 year contract €10m euros a season
Current PSR rules mean that regardless of the contract length the amortization duration is a max of 5 years. This is a potential work around.
€60m euros over a 5 year contract = €12m euros a season
€10m euro loan fee + €50m euros over a 5 year contract €10m euros a season
Current PSR rules mean that regardless of the contract length the amortization duration is a max of 5 years. This is a potential work around.
I don't normally agree with much of what Scholes says but I didn't see a dramatic change either. It was a bit better but not enough to bring any real optimism.
Scholes was correct when he pointed out the same flaws from last season still existed.
Hopefully we'll get better as the team improve their fitness and a player like Ugarte comes in but those are incremental improvements. We're still going to have plenty of basketball matches this season if we play the way we did against Fulham.
He's not a great passer, please stop.
I had to look that channel up, had no idea who he was.
I've mostly watched all-touches compilations from him and 1v1 duel compilations, but his passing was a weakness for me. Like I've said many times, I hope he will prove me wrong...and I hope it's really something that can be worked on.
Yeah I'm still hoping the style evolves, however don't see it happening until he can find a similar midfield profile to De Jong which hasn't happened yet
Last edited:
His situation is incomparable to Sancho’s.. He didn’t fall out with the manager and get sent out on loan but started for them lots.
What's worrying is the Utd tier 1's haven't come out and corroborated Castles story, however they also haven't denied it either
McT should be lightyears away from this club. Its a shame that the Scottish Zidane seems to struggle to find adequate buyers. I wonder why.
I don't think anyone thinks Casemiro and Mainoo combined are doing a good job defensively
Read back through the thread for plenty of 'if Casemiro only has to play once per week / gets plenty of games off he's fine alongside Mainoo'.
Even if that was true, my reply was to a post claiming Ugarte is a bench player. Those stats reflect that he is arguably the best DM of his type (high-energy, high volume defending, simple passing, not creative) in the game. On his defending alone he'd bench Casemiro instantly - Mainoo/Mount/Bruno can provide plenty of creativity with someone like that doing the work behind them.
I think we are gonna struggle this season to control games, particularly when we need to keep the ball. Casemiro, Mount, Bruno, Ugarte they are all quick releasers of the ball, they get the ball and ping a pass as quickly as they can. That's gonna be problematic.
Our midfield lacks what the spanish call "La Pausa'.
ETH has spent over 200M on our midfield(including Ugarte). If our midfield is still shit after this, its on him.
Last edited:
Sounds very close
that's just another way of saying its almost done.
it'll be waiting for his agent to buy him a pre flight pint next.
it'll be waiting for his agent to buy him a pre flight pint next.
Thank feck we have Mainoo then, in this regard.
Feel like this signing has almost become an embodiment of whether or not our season is going to be successful. It's not for sure, but it feels like there's a lot of expectation riding on it.
He's our saving grace. But its not fair or safe to rely on a 19 year old for the whole season. He's not the finished article either.
We needed more midfielders who are composed and intelligent on the ball, players who dont treat the ball like hot potatoes.
Is it imminent yet?
It's very close to being imminent.
Should stop listening to posters Ugarte dribbles the ball to progress as does Mainoo
The team you play for dictates how long you dwell on the ball too
Fair point, however inability to sell McTominay or Eriksen combined with manager who doesn't value possession enough means it's tricky situation
All our midfielders except Mainoo treat the ball like hot potatoes, playing/giving it away as soon as they get it. Bruno, Casemiro, Mount all of them.
Ugarte has the same style too. Can be problematic, leads to games looking like basketball when we play.
It‘s ok to have a safer passer next to more progressive passers in the team, it is all about balance. Ugarte can play progressive passes, he just doesn‘t excel at it.
I have high hopes for Collyer as well. Anyway, it is not either or, we need two solid options for each position.
- Status