Israel - Palestine Discussion | Post Respectfully | Discuss more, tweet less

Putin also probably doesn't want to burn every bridge with Israel if he can still avoid it. he seemed to very much appreciate the substantial volume of Russian speaking, ex-ussr Israeli's as something of geopolitical worth (and a point of connective pride within his nationalistic outlook), he had a good relationship with Netanyahu in particular, even despite the issues caused by opting to get involved in Syria for Assad. things had only recently turned sour because he's backed himself into a corner with the invasion of Ukraine. Israel didn't care about Crimean annexation and were even relatively slow to fully condemn Russia immediately after the invasion until it became apparent what a military trainwreck it was (and likely significant pressure from the states/ europe).

No Ukraine war and i'm pretty sure he'd be firmly on the Israeli side post-Oct 7th, though likely with some self-serving, fake attempts to appear more humane and eager for ceasefire than the Americans/Germans/Brits.

Good points. I recall there was significant coordination between Israel and Russia during the Syria war, where Netanyahu flew to Moscow to deconflict Israeli airstrikes on Iranian proxy targets with the presence of Russian troops in Syria at the time.
 
Only 6 countries do not recognise the court from what I've read, Israelis one of them. The others are US, China, Russia, Libya, Qatar,
You are mixing two different courts.

ICJ is not ICC

ICJ is an organ/ part if the UN, every member in the UN 193 coubtrues is by default part of the ICJ statue.

This court does not take cases of individuals (like Netanyahu). It solves cases between countries.

The ICC on the other hand is a criminal court, which brings cases against individuals for war crimes or crimes against humanity.

Also, whilst the ICJ is an organ of the United Nations, the ICC is legally independent of the UN, (although it is endorsed by the General Assembly).

US and Israel recognise ICJ by default of membership to the UN.

But they do not recognise the ICC.

Both courts are located in the Hague in the Netherlands but two different buildings.
 


As expected.


Even in the news last night they barely covered the accusations and had more time on the denials.

That's the situation though isn't it, there's a massive fear of being critical of Israeli actions because of the risk against anyone who does. That's a conversation this thread has had for year's and there's always been denial it was the case but recent events have proved the point.

Lobbying works and you don't need some secret world order type power for that to be the case.
 




He kept searching between papers. Unprepared. Blaming someone of shuffling his papers. :lol:
 
Putin also probably doesn't want to burn every bridge with Israel if he can still avoid it. he seemed to very much appreciate the substantial volume of Russian speaking, ex-ussr Israeli's as something of geopolitical worth (and a point of connective pride within his nationalistic outlook), he had a good relationship with Netanyahu in particular, even despite the issues caused by opting to get involved in Syria for Assad. things had only recently turned sour because he's backed himself into a corner with the invasion of Ukraine. Israel didn't care about Crimean annexation and were even relatively slow to fully condemn Russia immediately after the invasion until it became apparent what a military trainwreck it was (and likely significant pressure from the states/ europe).

No Ukraine war and i'm pretty sure he'd be firmly on the Israeli side post-Oct 7th, though likely with some self-serving, fake attempts to appear more humane and eager for ceasefire than the Americans/Germans/Brits.
Very good points, although Israel only condemned Russia for the invasion of Ukraine because the US forced them to do so, not because of the military situation there. However you should not forget that Russia also has long standing strategic and economic relationships with the Arabic world (except Saudia Arabia) and Iran which belong to their biggest clients in terms of military contracts.

It was completely at odds with Israel until the fall of the Soviet Union. The emigration of jewish Russians to Israel in the following years has massively contributed to the improvement of the relationships between the two countries in the long-term, but ever since, both have been alternatively supporting then back stabbing each other on the international scene, depending on the interest of the moment. The relationship between Netanyahu and Putin has never been that cut and dry.

You might be right but I'm personally not 100% sure that Russia's position would've been completely different if the Ukraine invasion didn't happen. They'd still have to manage their Arab partners and Iran, and alienating them in favor of Israel is a costly deal either way.

We'll see how things go.
 
Expecting articles in 1-2 weeks about how the U.S. is being "involuntarily dragged" into another conflict.
 


As expected.

wow

What are they afraid of? free speech. Few months ago I was in an argument with a poster here I do not remember who, It was about the media bias in western countries, I told him even the BBC has an agenda, he was laughing like it was some sort of alien thought. The public in the west are brain washed.
 
It's funny how Piers Morgan kept asking his pro Palestine guests where the "Nelson Mandela" figure is in all of this war (obviously the white-washed version of him), and here we have Nelson Mandela's grandsons in an international trial where they oppose the atrocities that are happening right now.

He really thinks Nelson Mandela was some sort of Kumbaya peace-only bitch. I'm sure he thinks the same of MLK Jr.
 
He is indirectly inciting that the court has no merit, or the court has no value. What an absolute shameless government Germany has.

It is coming from the people whom I believe supported the apartheid in South Africa the longest out of any Western nation. That's without going further into their darker past.
 
It's funny how Piers Morgan kept asking his pro Palestine guests where the "Nelson Mandela" figure is in all of this war (obviously the white-washed version of him), and here we have Nelson Mandela's grandsons in an international trial where they oppose the atrocities that are happening right now.

Even more funny considering if Piers was around at the time, he'd have been asking the ANC where their Ghandi figure is, with Mandela on US terror watchlists until the 2000s and the ANC using violence once they felt non-violence was no longer cutting it.
 
How many generations do you think it will take for their collective shame to dissipate?

Is it shame or political and financial interest? Supporting Israel is a good way to get on the good side of the US.
 
Here's another gem


It's interesting because following this a little bit, I went to the opposite interpretation. South Africa currently have many issues, historically there are still divisions based on race and ethnicity but on that topic they seem to be relatively united in the belief that they are witnessing an apartheid.
 
It's interesting because following this a little bit, I went to the opposite interpretation. South Africa currently have many issues, historically there are still divisions based on race and ethnicity but on that topic they seem to be relatively united in the belief that they are witnessing an apartheid.

The opposite interpretation from what/who? :confused:
 
The opposite interpretation from what/who? :confused:

The idea that on that topic there is a possibility to divide south africans. They currently have many issues but the topic of Israel and Palestine isn't one of them.
 
It's like they enjoy learning the wrong lessons from almost every war they've been engaged in going back to OVB

To be honest given Germany's last 120 years I don't expect them to take a different stance. They can be criticised but countries like the UK don't have that same history that may influence their current leaders so it is even worse we are taking the stance that we are.
 
CNN sent a list of the hospitals identified as damaged or destroyed to the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). In response, the IDF said it “did not conduct any targeted attacks against hospitals in the Gaza Strip,” adding that “Hamas systematically misuses hospitals and medical facilities.”