Gaming FM2017 Football Legends - Classic Player Draft - S2 Holiday Updates

Should I allow Managers/Clubs to make transfer every summer or should I lock in the teams drafted fo


  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .
would probably last a bit longer but cant risk it, my favorite player:drool:
Scholes2.jpg
 
Can't they just switch Sacchi's formation to one that suits Platini?
I think onenil offered it, although personally I think it's pointless to edit the manager's wishes, just pick another one. Frustrations about wrong use of your players is also a part of the fun
 
Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@ADJUDICATOR
 
I think onenil offered it, although personally I think it's pointless to edit the manager's wishes, just pick another one. Frustrations about wrong use of your players is also a part of the fun
I agree too, just mentioned in case it was a problem they didn't want. Who knows, some players might flourish under a different regime.
 


Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala 2. T. Henry
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@BeforeKeanetherewasRobson
 
Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1.
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala

:lol: This is going to be such a mess. Nothing wrong with Kubala, but I suspect he is exceptionally highly rated in that database. I was planning to get him R3 or 4 easily.

Christ, I have a truckload of players I'm assuming "safe" late picks and next thing I know they'll go in R2 :annoyed:
 
Yeah. Not sure how strict are the managers with their preferred formation - I would expect them to change it if their star player is a natural #10 that is seriously restricted up front/as a part of a central duo.

Either you got the wrong manager or player then, surely.

I'm actually really struggling with (and somewhat enjoying) the refreshing "zero control" draft dynamic. The manager will end up doing whatever he wants. The game will injure red card and upset loads of players. By the end of the first season we will surely have Di Stéfano pining for Madrid (and vice versa). Too many variables, just feck it really.
 
Just typing it... some of us have jobs and no time to sit staring at walls. :angel:

309301.jpg


Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala 2. T. Henry
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha 2. Xavi
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@mazhar13 @Joga Bonito@JB08
 
Last edited:
Manager - One Time Change and 1 Formation Change allowed
Manager update

I am going to allow a one time change of Manager and a one time change of Primary Tactic.

Neither of these one time changes will ruin the spirit of the draft as a couple managers were little undeveloped when they were added into the game and I have no problem adding an actual important historic formation to a manager where it was left out (and they actually have an open formation slot anyway).

Also like the FM2017 modern, I will allow a one time change of Manager at the start but I cannot allow more than one as I am sure you all understand that would be a lot of busy work for me.

Please submit any Manager changes before the end of R3 of Drafting.


NOTE ON TRANSFERS

The vote is very close here and I still haven't decided. Basically I think I will try some kind of hybrid where I lock in no transfer the first season then do a season of narrative updates then maybe open transfers summer 2 and then lock those in for a season or two.
 
f6470093909f44e17441b06997f90e5d.jpg


Der Bomber himself.

Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala 2. T. Henry
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha 2. Xavi
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini 2. G. Müller
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@2mufc0
 
The ultimate no. 9.....

_5yhnPbv_400x400.jpg


Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala 2. T. Henry
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha 2. Xavi
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini 2. G. Müller
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi 2. M. Van Basten
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@Gio
 
NOTE ON TRANSFERS

The vote is very close here and I still haven't decided. Basically I think I will try some kind of hybrid where I lock in no transfer the first season then do a season of narrative updates then maybe open transfers summer 2 and then lock those in for a season or two.
:(
No transfers in the first season is a good idea, you'll have your original squad perform for 2 seasons, but after that we should grant the AI full freedom — or it will become a borefest.
 
:(
No transfers in the first season is a good idea, you'll have your original squad perform for 2 seasons, but after that we should grant the AI full freedom — or it will become a borefest.

This sounds like a good way to do it.
 
Decision time - dick over anto or go for the right man for the job?
 
SOWING THE SEEDS FOR A MELTDOWN
  • Passed on van Basten expecting injuries => will probably be fit as a fiddle and get the Golden Boot
  • Refuse to pass on Rijkaard too => cue Johan playing him at CB all season
cruyff-van-basten.jpg


Sjor (A. Ferguson) 1. P. Scholes 2. A. Nesta
Adjudicator (B. Robson) 1. L. Kubala 2. T. Henry
BeforeKeaneThereWasRobson (R. Michels) 1. Garrincha 2. Xavi
Mazhar/JB08 (A. Sacchi) 1. M. Platini 2. G. Müller
2mufc0 (J. Mourinho) 1. F. Baresi 2. M. Van Basten
Gio (G. Trapattoni) 1. Matthaus 2. Eusebio
antohan (J. Cruyff) 1. Romario 2. Rijkaard
Ecstatic/Invictus (C. Ancelotti) 1. F. Puskás
Macern (B. Paisley) 1. Ronaldinho
Tuppet (H. Herrera) 1. G. Facchetti
simonhch (Capello) 1. Cristiano Ronaldo
Skizzo/joga (M. Lippi) 1. F. Beckenbauer
P-Nut0712(P. Guardiola) 1. G.Best
Igor Drefljak (LvG) 1. Meazza
NM (B. Guttmann) 1. Ronaldo(Bra)
Pillow/altodevil (B Clough) 1. J. Cruyff
Moby/Raees (M. Busby) 1. L. Messi
Red Tiger (E. Happel) 1. Pelé
Spontaneous (O. Hitzfeld) 1. D. Maradona
harms (Udo Lattek) 1. A. Di Stefano

@Ecstatic @Invictus
 
My options are quickly disappearing!