Diogo Dalot has shown promise at Manchester United, but his time at the club (since joining in 2018) has been punctuated by recurring criticisms and mistakes. Here’s a breakdown:
1. Defensive Vulnerabilities
Positioning Lapses: Dalot has occasionally been caught out of position, leaving gaps for opponents to exploit (e.g., failing to track overlapping runs).
1v1 Defending: His aggressiveness in duels can backfire, with wingers sometimes bypassing him too easily.
Aerial Weakness: Despite his height (6’0”), he’s been inconsistent in aerial duels, a liability against physical wingers.
2. Inconsistent Final-Third Delivery
Erratic Crossing: A frequent criticism—his crosses often lack precision or fail to pick out teammates, wasting promising attacks.
Decision-Making:At times, he holds the ball too long or chooses low-percentage passes/shots instead of simpler options.
3. Injury & Consistency Issues
Fitness Struggles: Early in his United career, injuries disrupted his rhythm (e.g., hip issues in 2019/20).
Form Fluctuations: Post-AC Milan loan (2020/21), he initially impressed under Solskjær but later regressed, leading to fan frustration.
4. Tactical Adaptation
Role Confusion: Under different managers (Mourinho, Solskjær, Ten Hag), he’s shifted between RB, LB, and inverted roles, struggling to master any single system.
Ten Hag’s Demands: While improved under Ten Hag, his lapses in build-up play (e.g., risky passes, losing possession) still surface.
5. High-Profile Mistakes
2022/23 Season:
Manchester Derby (Oct 2022)- Caught out in transitions as City exploited United’s right flank.
Liverpool 7-0 Defeat (Mar 2023): Part of a collective collapse, but his defensive errors stood out.
2023/24: Occasional lapses in big games (e.g., UCL group stages), though he’s grown into a more reliable starter.