Proactive keeper gives away a pen tonight. Never needed to leave his line. Won't show up on the stats but it cost his team. Stick to the clean sheets Dave. We'll have ya.
1
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 58
- Clean sheets
- 25
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 2
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Imran (@Annihilate Now!) look forward to a new life under Ruben Amorim. What system will we be playing? What players will impress? and how will it all go? We also say goodbye to Ruud Van Nistelrooy and review United's 3-0 win at home against Leicester City.
- Status
Barcelona 2:2 Man Utd
Disastrous for the first Barca goal, but I guess he made 2 camera saves which the commentator moaned extra loud on so we don’t need to replace in the summer
Not to mention a few terrible turnovers from him giving the ball away
Not to mention a few terrible turnovers from him giving the ball away
It's absolutely criminal how even teams like Barcelona take air advantage in our box because of his pasivness. Even when he comes out for high ball he makes a real mess out of the situation. And I won't even talk about his distribution.
Terrible
When even Barca are hoofing it into our 6 yard box knowing De Gea won’t do shit all, you know you’ve got a problem.
He is priority to be replaced, after a ST.
He is priority to be replaced, after a ST.
Definitely an improvement over his usual Camp Nou performances though
No clue what he was even doing during the two goals.
When he doesn’t come off the line the least you would hope for is to cover the angles on the post , that was such a shit goal to concede
Not much he could do for the 2nd, poor for the first.
fecking terrible coward of a keeper. People don't see past highlight saves to understand how crap he is at this point.
Also just exudes nervousness, similar to Maguire, there's never an air of authority in big games with him.
Also just exudes nervousness, similar to Maguire, there's never an air of authority in big games with him.
I'd go with this. He made some decent saves but that first goal was criminal. Ball seemed to be in the air for years and he was just rooted.
He also becomes a poor option for when we try to pass out the back and it can lead to a player dropping deeper meaning opposition can press higher
He saved our arses in the last minute. Could have lost without him.
I can't believe some actually want to replace him. People acting as if this will be easy or something.
He's a great keeper with few unimportant flaws really and one of our most reliable players. Replacing him will be damn hard and it's the least thing we need to do now considering there're more important positions to reinforce in the team.
De Gea can give us many more solid years.
I can't believe some actually want to replace him. People acting as if this will be easy or something.
He's a great keeper with few unimportant flaws really and one of our most reliable players. Replacing him will be damn hard and it's the least thing we need to do now considering there're more important positions to reinforce in the team.
De Gea can give us many more solid years.
Think he should have done better for the goal
Very poor on the first.
I won't go over the same ground again, cos I'm happy with the overall performance from the team.
But I'm baffled you would say unimportant flaws.
And it's not like we're replacing schmeichel, which was a damn hard task. Replacing and upgrading on ddg should not be as difficult as you're making out
He punched 3 or 4 tonight. He done quite well in that regard today.
People who are blaming the goals on him haven't played football themselves. Baffling opinions. He was actually pretty darn good today
Good performance if you’re not stuck in a circle of confirmation bias. Strong punches and some excellent saves.
Used to play as a Keeper but he frustrated me greatly today with all the flaws we know and hate. They get magnified in the big games and it places immense stress on a defence that's not known for doing well on set pieces and crosses.
Getting a better keeper than De Gea won't be really that easy at all and the team doesn't need the dilemma of enduring a new keeper while we need to invest our money in other more important positions.
Mistakes can and will happen with all keepers. But De Gea's issues are about what he can't do as a keeper. And when you're weak at commanding your area and with the ball at your feet, there will always be big question marks surrounding your ability as a keeper.
Ter Stegen got beaten on the near post and that's a mistake and mistakes can happen. But as a goalkeeper with a well rounded skillset he's comfortably better than De Gea.
Erik ten Hag is a proponent of vertical positional play and De Gea is a big weakness in that regard.
Ter Stegen got beaten on the near post and that's a mistake and mistakes can happen. But as a goalkeeper with a well rounded skillset he's comfortably better than De Gea.
Erik ten Hag is a proponent of vertical positional play and De Gea is a big weakness in that regard.
If you think the goals were on him, you sat on the bench in little league
He could have done better for the 1st. I don't think he could claim it but he needs to shift across quicker and cut out that near post header
Couple of good saves, nothing outstanding but good solid saves. 1 soft goal let in (the first). Surprisingly punched a couple of corners away fair play. Terrible distribution.
Pretty much what we have come to expect from Dave.
Pretty much what we have come to expect from Dave.
Good punches, agreed. But that period from 80 mins to the 92nd min were Barca were assaulting us aerially, he was glued to his line.
It’s a big problem. Our defence drops deeper than it needs to, then it leads to more space towards the edge of the box for opposition players, like where Fati was for his chance. It happens every game without fail.
What planet are you on?
Seriously? Having zero command of his box is an unimportant flaw?
Shite again. A braver goalkeeper does more with the first and his kicking is relentlessly awful.
Saved our asses seriously ? I swear any half decent keeper would make the saves he made today . It’s fine if you think that he doesn’t need to be replaced but let’s not behave like he is doing stuff no one else could do
A good keeper collects the corner for the 1st goal. Could have arguably parried away the header at his near post from his 6 yard box too, since he always sets himself up for a shot to make up for never coming out to collect. A defence having full confidence in their goalkeeper performs much differently, especially in an area opponents currently exploit.
You're probably the sort too used to slow-motion replays and acrobatics when judging a goalkeeper, ignoring the basics such as a Keeper's starting position.
Against Leeds I saw him holding his post again when they had an opportunity at his near post. The same major flaws of his game (command of area, crosses) I typed on this board when he joined have barely been improved.
Wouldn't go overboard being critical of today's performance but the idea that his flaws are unimportant is an absolutely horrendous take.
Having de Gea as your gk is like having to drink your own piss in the desert.
He always bottles it more than usual vs Spanish opposition
Ddg made good saves today.
The more important position is striker we we just don't have one
But after that GK is the most important position to get right. It's the starting point of the spine.
Ddg doesn't just have 'modern' keeper issues, eg getting involved with play.
But the issue comes with commanding the box, which would be leadership or stuff like sweeping and claiming crosses.
Right now ddg isnt outstanding at any aspects. He's a good shot stopper (he's not as good as he was a few years ago). But has weaknesses in other areas and there are keepers out there where we don't need a world class in every aspect keeper, but solid in all instantly becomes an upgrade
His flaws aren't really as important as his critics want to magnify them to be just to get rid of him for their version of "modern keeper". He more than makes up for it with his other qualities.
It's just overplayed and I can see any new keeper getting slaughtered once De Gea is replaced even if he has these "modern keeper abilities" others are dreaming of.
You never know how good what you have in your hands is until it's replaced.
Command of your area isn’t a modern keeper attribute. Lev Yashin was the GOAT at it. Handling and aerial prowess has been important for 100 years as a goalkeeper.
Some Matrix saves. 
Being brave, commanding your area and actually being able to distribute are not modern keepers abilities. They are traditional keeper abilities that he has none of.
He also isn't very comfortable with the ball at his feet under pressure and is an uncomfortable sweeper behind a high line which are very much modern keeper abilities he also dosent have.
His qualities are basically reflexes, agility and positioning but non of them are world class anymore, they were at a time but not anymore.
His handling used to be excellent aswell he would happily catch shots but now he tends to parry alot that he could catch and rarely catches and holds anything.
His qualities no longer outweigh his many flaws. And he is really unsuited to a team that want to be brave and play on the front foot. He has to be replaced ASAP so we can take the next step.
By every quantifiable measure he’s near the bottom of his own league for keepers. Stop getting blinded by a couple cool highlight saves.
Why can’t we take a bloody old fashioned goal kick? My heart is in my mouth every time we try to play out
- Status