Regulus Arcturus Black
Full Member
Ooooh I can see some mind games coming into play before the Liverpool game here.
He was on the bench against Reading, so no.Has he not just been away on a mid season break?
Has he not just been away on a mid season break?
He was on the bench against Reading, so no.
Rolling around topless in Snow will do that to you, Zlatan.
It's just not the same with Rooney up top.
Well I think that he is now at 35 as good player as he was ever been. I watched him quite a lot when he played for Juventus because my brother support Juventus and back then we both lived in the same house and as much as I can remember he was not as clinical as he is now (wel he still isn't the most clinical player) and he is much much smarter player then he was back in Juventus days. Overall much better player then he was back then. You could argue that his prime years were at Inter where he played great but I kinda have a feeling that a bad experience from Barca gaved him that push to show how big mistake they did and to try/train even harder.
Yeah agree with this. Although I'm sorta glad he didn't as don't think a winner such as Ibra would even contemplate working with a manager such as David Moyes. And he hated LvG.I agree with you. In his early years he never really "cared" about the amount of goals he should score. The only thing that was important was to make it as spectacular as possible. But in Juventus with the help of Capello he learned that there was room for improvement - take more shots.
He was a great striker at Inter but he was never really a playmaker. But if not including that one could say that he was in his prime as a striker. After his spell in Spain he became a much more intelligent player. Became more aware of how he should move around the field and he became really good at his playmaking abilities. Some people consider his time at Barcelona unsuccessful but in my opinion he became a more "complete" player with basically no "flaws".
In AC Milan he "carried" the team on his shoulders with both goals and assists. Despite playing probably his best season the second year he couldn't win the Scudetto. But it's incredible that the team could finish second place with such a "bad" team.
I feel that he spent too many years in France. I think that Ibra would have loved to come to the PL earlier in his career. He should have only stayed in France for two years and not four. But it's still great to see him in the PL and that he despite the fact that he is "old" still can prove that he's a world class player.
I would love to see him stay at the club for two more seasons and preferably ending his career at the best club in the best league. With Ibra it's at least clear that if he stays - he feels that he can still make an impact.
And when he is ready to no longer put his shirt on then we can hope that Marcus Rashford has learned a lot from the big Z. This is also a reason for why I would prefer it if Ibra stayed two more seasons. The longer he stays, the more he can teach the young players.
You've clearly never seen him play for InterHe was a great striker at Inter but he was never really a playmaker.
Bad team? Ibra, Cassano, Thiago Silva, still good Pato, Boateng, Gattuso...bad? Of course Ibra carried that team, but that was the best team in Italy that season. It's widely considered Allegri's only failure as a manager, and with good reason. They were 7 points clear of juventus with 10 games to go and managed to lose the titleDespite playing probably his best season the second year he couldn't win the Scudetto. But it's incredible that the team could finish second place with such a "bad" team.
You've clearly never seen him play for Inter
Bad team? Ibra, Cassano, Thiago Silva, still good Pato, Boateng, Gattuso...bad? Of course Ibra carried that team, but that was the best team in Italy that season. It's widely considered Allegri's only failure as a manager, and with good reason. They were 7 points clear of juventus with 10 games to go and managed to lose the title
Ibra was always first and foremost a playmaker. Capello, Mancini and Mourinho managed to turn him into a goalscorer, too.
Yeah agree with this. Although I'm sorta glad he didn't as don't think a winner such as Ibra would even contemplate working with a manager such as David Moyes. And he hated LvG.
Italian. Live in Milan. Watched a good 80% of his games in Italy. Several times got to see him liveI've probably seen him play in more games than you, but not sure.
No, you got it backwards. Ibra was a #10 when he moved to juventus. During his time in Italy, he gradually turned into a #9. He's now a hybrid #9/#10. He's always provided plenty of assists, but most importantly, at juve, inter and milan, he was always either the main playmaker(at inter and milan) or the second playmaker(at juve, who's main playmaker was camoranesi)Ibra, before and after Barcelona are two different types of players, if you just consider his playmaking abilities. Before Barca he used to have occasional passes but after his time in Spain he more or less became a "standard" no 10. I'm not saying that he didn't have the ability to make assists, just that it wasn't his priority. He has become a better playmaker the more he's matured - before he used to think about himself and just make beautiful things. Even he says now that he enjoys assists as much as scoring goals, maybe even more.
But Milan did have Ibra. And with Ibra, they were better than juventus. Also more experienced, barring Buffon, Pirlo(and Conte as a player) nobody else had won the serie A title before then(a young chiellini in 2006, but not sure how much that counts)Yep, AC Milan during his second season was a "poor" team. Robinho constantly missed passes from Ibra and Pato was made of glass. Thiago Silva was the only one who was really good. Cassano had his stroke during that period - but he was the only one who "understood" Ibra. Think about the fact that he managed to make a somewhat "limited" player (at least not World class) like Nocerino look like a top player - look at Nocerino's career after Ibra. Juventus with Conte was a better team but AC Milan had the best player in Ibra. Juventus had really good players back then, many of them still playing there now - 2011/12, Buffon, Chiellini, Bonucci, Barzagli, Lichtsteiner, Pirlo, Vidal and Marchisio etc.
But he was. That's how juventus used him, that's how inter used him(they're game-plan boiled down to, press high, and pass it to Ibra), and that's how Milan used himHe was not "foremost a playmaker" as you say it. He has always had great technique and agility despite his size. His favourite player growing up was Ronaldo and he tried to play like him. But he's always been a great target man and from that managed to make assists.
Spain had nothing to do with it. He became a more intelligent player because he matured. That's true of literally every playerThe list can go on, but in my opinion he became a more "intelligent" player after his time in Spain, a part of which his passing shows. By the way, he could have had a lot of assists this season, I especially like his back heel pass to Rooney.
Italian. Live in Milan. Watched a good 80% of his games in Italy. Several times got to see him live
No, you got it backwards. Ibra was a #10 when he moved to juventus. During his time in Italy, he gradually turned into a #9. He's now a hybrid #9/#10. He's always provided plenty of assists, but most importantly, at juve, inter and milan, he was always either the main playmaker(at inter and milan) or the second playmaker(at juve, who's main playmaker was camoranesi)
But Milan did have Ibra. And with Ibra, they were better than juventus. Also more experienced, barring Buffon, Pirlo(and Conte as a player) nobody else had won the serie A title before then(a young chiellini in 2006, but not sure how much that counts)
But he was. That's how juventus used him, that's how inter used him(they're game-plan boiled down to, press high, and pass it to Ibra), and that's how Milan used him
Spain had nothing to do with it. He became a more intelligent player because he matured. That's true of literally every player
Yes, and even there he was a playmaker. He was compared to Van Basten for a reason afterall(a comparison they also made in Italy)You make good points, but I think you forget that he was a no 9 in Ajax (their new van Basten).
I dunno about Sweden. I do know about his time at juventus, inter and milan, and at juve he played as a pure #10, at inter he began his conversion into a #9 but was still very much the hub of the team's play, and at milan it was more of the same. He's a different player nowadays in that he's lost his pace and acceleration, he dribbles considerably less, and he plays a lot more WITH his teammates, whereas before he played FOR his teammates, but in a more individualistic way(think hazard at chelsea for a comparison)He had assists during that period as well but that was "bonus" from his good play at least in my opinion. He was more of a "show-off" during his early years and preferred to make a lot of unnecessary moves instead of passing the ball. Nothing wrong with that, actually quite normal, given he was so young. I've seen him play almost all of his NT-games for Sweden and he became more of a playmaker the latter part of his career and not the beginning. But the last years in the NT he alternated both 9/10 during a game, which is something we can see him do nowadays.
I didn't say he became a better player. Just smarter. Honestly, I think he was at his best in his last season at inter. He's certainly not as good now as he was for milanWell, every player usually don't manage to become better just because they "mature".
oh yes, this I agree with 100%Don't you think that he became a player with a "wider range" after his time in Spain? I see it as his time there gave him the extra fuel (anger) which made him focus even more on the play to prove everyone (Barcelona) wrong.
That's what he's always been. A fantastic #10 who learned to score like a #9. Third best player of the last decade, and imho he's been far closer to cristiano than most people credit him forHe's such an intelligent player, a fantastic leader, incredible hold up and link up play, great playmaking abilities "spiced" with magical goals.
Third best player of the last decade, and imho he's been far closer to cristiano than most people credit him for
Choose the wrong teams, too. Goes to milan instead of inter in 2006, wins league title and CL in 2006/07 and the BoD ahead of Kaka. If he played in a top english side between 2007-2009 instead of inter, he'd probably be considered on the same level as cristiano ronaldo by nowAgree with you. It's a shame that he's had to compete in the same generation as Messi and Ronaldo. He's been somewhat in their shadows. I'm almost certain that if Ibra had M's/R's speed than he would probably be as good as or even better than them.
It's not the loss of pace so much as the loss of his impressive explosive acceleration. That, and he became a smarter player. Started forcing things lessI miss the times when he used to dribble, but like you said, he's lost this because of the loss of pace.
Wouldn't say he's more special than messi or 2006-2012 cristiano, but certainly a special player to watch, I agreeI know that both Messi and Ronaldo should be considered as the best in the world but I appreciate Ibra more than them. Maybe because he's a type of player I've never seen before. He possesses a kind of "aura" that makes you mesmerized. A feeling quite similar to Zidane. He was also a very interesting player.
I've no idea He's still one of the 10 best players in the world at 35. Honestly, he could very well stay at this level for another 10 years for all I knowHow long do you think he could/would stay in PL? I really hope he can stay for two more years - that is if he can conserve his superb physical qualities and not lose anymore than he has til this age (speed).