Today is definitely exhibit A
The only person near the touchline was Mike Phelan. And it was enough to make him lose more hair. In my mind if coaches sit still during matches where the team is on the backfoot, they are either a very calm person or haven't got a scooby doo on what to do/say. How many times have you seen Pep, Sir Alex and Klopp go mental on the touchline? haven't seen it at United since Van Gaal complained to Mike Dean on the sideline and morphed into a cock.SURELY there is one coach out there who has an idea about how to beat a low block?
It's not Ole, not Carrick, not Mckenna and doesn't look like Ramsay has a clue either
Someone out there must have a clue?
Ha its true though. Hes in his 4th year and the team has collectively under performed versus Young Boys, Southampton, Wolves, West Ham and Villa.Your post was so short, yet so cutting. Gave me a laugh.
Its going to be Zidane if hes given the boot.I like Ole and really wanted him to be a big succes with us, but my faith in him is almost all but gone.
Who out there to take over? We missed the boat with Tuchel.
As an Arsenal fan I love this. You guys are joining us in the party of accepting mediocrity.
So true! in 3 years one would see some sort of style or pattern of play. NothingAs a team, we are diabolical. Can't defend, can't play about, can't attack properly. We rely on the stardust of our best players. Whoever denies that is either blind or a totally delusional fanboy.
Ha its true though. Hes in his 4th year and the team has collectively under performed versus Young Boys, Southampton, Wolves, West Ham and Villa.
With his quality of squad its inexcusable at the least.
So true! in 3 years one would see some sort of style or pattern of play. Nothing
The only person near the touchline was Mike Phelan. And it was enough to make him lose more hair. In my mind if coaches sit still during matches where the team is on the backfoot, they are either a very calm person or haven't got a scooby doo on what to do/say. How many times have you seen Pep, Sir Alex and Klopp go mental on the touchline? haven't seen it at United since Van Gaal complained to Mike Dean on the sideline and morphed into a cock.
Its going to be Zidane if hes given the boot.
He has zero ability to influence a game from the bench. It's not all about ranting and raving but there's work to do as a manager during a game too. You don't have to rant and rave on the touchline constantly to be a good manager but if you're sit passively watching the drizzling shits what are you being paid for? Screaming and shouting doesn't make you a good manager but sometimes it's needed. You've got to put a flea in a player's ear sometimes. Okay if we were playing our of our skin and he wants to sit back and watch the game then fair play to him. But there's no leadership there. Players turn to the bench and he's sat there looking like someone's boyfriend sat outside the changing rooms of Top Shop waiting for their girlfriend to emerge with her 8th outfit change.
Even if there was some kind of influence noticeable through how we play or how we react to adversity it'll be one thing but there rarely isn't. We're playing poorly in the 34th minute the odds are we'll play poorly every minute through until the end of the game. His influence once a game has started does not exist and that's been a problem for a long while.
I'm cautious about going back to full blown Ole out mode like I was circa Oct to Dec 2019. I've had doubts since then, but he seems to always do just enough.
I missed the match today so can't comment on it. But our last 4 games haven't been great at all. I came into this season expecting big things, but I'll admit, I'm starting to get worried.
SURELY there is one coach out there who has an idea about how to beat a low block?
It's not Ole, not Carrick, not Mckenna and doesn't look like Ramsay has a clue either
Someone out there must have a clue?
Lost to Young Boys, West Ham and Villa in our last 4 games. Drew against Southampton. Scraped wins against West Ham and Wolves while playing terribly.
Finished last season like shit too, and - as is now customary - bottled a big knockout match, didn't even turn up against Villarreal.
The bigger issue is that anything you expect to be coached - style of play, set pieces, attacking patterns, defensive organisation - are all consistently terrible. We get outworked and outpressed by every team we play. We're awful at attacking set-pieces and even worse at defending them, despite having some absolutely massive players who are good in the air. Almost everything good we do is chaotic and relies purely on individual quality...hence 'system' players like Sancho and VDB looking like complete misfits.
Good chance that Villa would have steamrolled us even more if we wouldn't have had two CDMs. I don't think think McFred was the issue today, McTominay was a bit invisible but Fred was pretty fine, his best game for quite a while. What really killed us, was being so susceptible to their pressig all over the pitch, the non-existing plan in attack that lead to shots from nowhere all the time and mostly our inability to recycle possession to control a game.The McFred combo always made sense to me until today.
Having to watch the Chelsea vs City game I have noticed how City are playing with KDB, Silva and Rodri a their CM.
KDB is playing high up, and Silva and Rodri seem to be sitting back. City are dominating the Midfield battle and Silva is holding his own against Rudiger.
I really don’t know know why we can not play with one defensive mid and a playmaker and still have Bruno operate as a number 10 or the furtherest CM.
I am getting sick of having to play McFred as if we can’t cope without playing with 2 CDMs.
The problem isn't the low block, the issue is inexisting plans in the attack. Villa was pressing pretty much, it isn't a low block only because it takes United 2 minutes to reach attacking positions because they can't control the ball properly.SURELY there is one coach out there who has an idea about how to beat a low block?
It's not Ole, not Carrick, not Mckenna and doesn't look like Ramsay has a clue either
Someone out there must have a clue?
You call today a low block?
Villa gave us plenty of chances to run out them, but we were disjointed as feck today.
It really intrigues me why English teams are frequently held hostage by sentimental attachment to past club glories even if it leads them to misery.
Arsenal compromised a whole football generation just to keep Wenger, a totally outdated manager, because he won them a title without defeats in 12917 BC.
Now it's Manchester United clinging to Solskjær, a nice guy but a mediocre manager, just because he scored the winning goal in the 1999 Champions League final.
I can't bear to see this.
Portuguese domestic football is far from being the Premier League but when a manager is not up to the task, he's gone, doesn't matter when or who he is, we call it "the psychological whiplash", the sooner the better, what more do you need to see?
And get Leonardo Jardim, Zinedine Zidane or Paulo Fonseca. Please stop thinking about anyone else, specially those classical outdated English blokes like Moyes.
He'd at a minimum implement a playing style that exposes their weaknesses in the least way.I wonder what one of the best midfielders of his era would do to McFred.
I wonder what one of the best midfielders of his era would do to McFred.
The problem isn't the low block, the issue is inexisting plans in the attack. Villa was pressing pretty much, it isn't a low block only because it takes United 2 minutes to reach attacking positions because they can't control the ball properly.
The match is worth a watch, so if you can, re-watch it. I didn't think we were as terrible as some depict it around here. But certainly we were not forcing anything and it seemed a bit desperate in the end because we looked somewhat clueless as a collective while no individual player was really bad.I'm cautious about going back to full blown Ole out mode like I was circa Oct to Dec 2019. I've had doubts since then, but he seems to always do just enough.
I missed the match today so can't comment on it. But our last 4 games haven't been great at all. I came into this season expecting big things, but I'll admit, I'm starting to get worried.
This is how I know people just say anything on this board, We had so much space it was unreal
He'd at a minimum implement a playing style that exposes their weaknesses in the least way.
The problems weve seen is way more beyond having them in midfield. Ole just wants a bunch of realy good attackers and hope they work it out on the pitch.
Exactly. We need a coach and Ole isnt a good enough one.I think he'll replace them both as neither of them are anywhere near to United's level. However I do believe that we'll have a change of system. We're really relying on individual talent. That's basically Ole ball in a nutshell.
I use this analogy to all of Ole defenders. It doesnt matter if the car could fly or shoot rockets if the driver is still a truck driver. He still doesnt know what to do with itPerfect analogy. Wonder what Conte is up to?
Exactly. We need a coach and Ole isnt a good enough one.
It really intrigues me why English teams are frequently held hostage by sentimental attachment to past club glories even if it leads them to misery.
Arsenal compromised a whole football generation just to keep Wenger, a totally outdated manager, because he won them a title without defeats in 12917 BC.
Now it's Manchester United clinging to Solskjær, a nice guy but a mediocre manager, just because he scored the winning goal in the 1999 Champions League final.
I can't bear to see this.
Portuguese domestic football is far from being the Premier League but when a manager is not up to the task, he's gone, doesn't matter when or who he is, we call it "the psychological whiplash", the sooner the better, what more do you need to see?
And get Leonardo Jardim, Zinedine Zidane or Paulo Fonseca. Please stop thinking about anyone else, specially those classical outdated English blokes like Moyes.
We may well win this game, because we have much better players.
But performances like today are exactly the sort reflected in last season's stats, where the league winners had an xG difference of +24 more than us. Meaning their general play was sufficiently better than ours to be the equivalent of 24 projected goals over the course of the season. Which is a lot.
You can't keep relying on your better players to bail out your general play with their sheer quality, even if you are continually improving the quality of your players. It doesn't mean we'll never win or never play well, we just don't have a consistent enough standard of performances to build a title win on as games like today will go against us too often.
That needed to improve this season. And, thus far, it hasn't.