I’m not sure Omar Berada or Blanc will be too keen on this appointment?
Transfer Tweets - Manchester United - 2024/25
- Thread starter mazhar13
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have four new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting.
A new Odds or Evens competition is starting now. Click here to read the rules and message Damien to submit your eight players by 14th September 2024
A new Carabao Cup prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for round 3 which begins 17th September.
A new Champions League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 17th September.
A new Europa League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 25th September.
For Odds or Evens you have until the 14th September to submit your players. Submissions will be open for the next 6 days, 11 hours, 23 minutes, 2 seconds, and will close on Sep 14, 2024 at 12:30. -
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) get the depressing job of reviewing United's 3-0 loss at Old Trafford to Liverpool. They discuss what went wrong, Casemiro's day to forget, and the pressure now on Erik Ten Hag. They also take some time to give McTominay a proper farewell, and give their overall thoughts on the Summer Transfer Window.
Admire ? Rich Fay is full of rubbish I believe
8th is mid-table.
This is a pointless courting attempt if Real Madrid is involved, unfortunately.
Yeah go and get Todibo who isn't fluttering his eyelashes for Real Madrid, well not yet anyway
The only thing that we possibly have over them is that we can guarantee him minutes because he's coming instead of Varane and he's better than any player we have bar maybe Licha.
Madrid have Rudiger, Militao, Alaba and Nacho(which they maybe sell) and it will be pretty challenging for him to get some minutes. Other than that - they are favourites in every category.
It's just agent noise to get RM to hurry up. We're not getting him.
Nacho said he was leaving on a free but has been given time to decide as he was offered a 1yr extension. Madrid probably need another CB but they do have Vallejo out on loan who could be a depth option.
It seems strange they aren’t going for Yoro now instead of asking him to wait until next year unless they want a more senior guy this summer.
Yeah you are absolutely spot on
Or they have limited money left after signing Mbappe
I agree with this, there's also a heavy rumour that Perez wants Haaland so Madrid will try to save money for him.
We do have an option to extend which I think may have been activated so we in theory have 2 years, but I agree it looks like £30m is the maximum we will recoup.
No it isn't and even if you really fought for the idea that 8th from 20 is the middle (factually it isn't but let's just give you it) my point still stands. That's a complete anomaly.
He's also finished third, so why not assume he'll just finish third again? He's never had a season that doesn't include at least a cup final, am I OK just assuming that won't change either and he therefore will always reach a cup final? No Because that's stupid, right? I agree.
So to also just assume 8th is now his level and ignore any and all context regarding the season is equally stupid.
There's a clear history to show that it's reasonable to think finishing 8th is a one off. Not typical. Less likely to happen than finishing above that next year.
Like I said, some people are just determined to be negative. You're welcome to it, I don't care, it's only yourself that you're needlessly finding reasons to make miserable.
I'll be alright, I'm mildly optimistic most summers because that's generally football. Even when you get slapped 4 nil you go into the next hoping for a better result. Unless you're like people such as you. Then you spend the week miserable and hating the idea of the next game coming. Cool.
In which case, I just pity that attitude.
But I'm talking to someone who insists that 8 is the half way point of 20 so I may as well be taking to a 10 year old. I've never seen 8th commonly referred to as mid table at all. At worst it's always been referred as a 'top half finish'.
Enjoy being miserable I guess! Gunna be a fun, fun few months for the like sof you hahahaha.
I’d love for us to sign Fofana from Monaco. He’d probably cost like 25/30m. Which would allow us to sign another midfielder.
Fair to say most people associate 8-12th as mid table
And it’s not like it’s a one off result that led us to 8th. It’s a seasons worth of effort (or lack of) it’s his poor judgement, team selection, playing style.
id say over his 2 seasons, the start of his first was good and then after then its been poor to awful and only getting worse.
I’m not particularly ETH in or out. I find his two seasons very difficult to assess because there is too much conflicting information. I’m also broadly an optimist. I don’t know where you get that I’m negative for pointing out 8th is mid-table. Even if you think last season was an outlier (and even just a couple different results would have had us 6th) we finished 8th and that’s more recent information than the prior year of 3rd. That makes it more important information from a data perspective
That being said I can’t think of anything much more mid-table than 8th. It’s pretty damn close to exactly mid-table. It’s safe from relegation but also misses out on Europe so it’s part of the middle.
If you divide 20/3 get 6.66. That makes the top 6.66 places the top part of the and the bottom 6.66 paces the bottom third of the table. Obviously you can’t have 2/3 of a place so to my mind that makes mid-table 7th to 13th. Some years when 7th gets European football I’d make it 8th - 13th.
Therefore, 8th is at best the top of mid-table. You can describe it as a top-half finish but that doesn’t make it not mid-table. Those two things aren’t mutually exclusive.
That makes far too much sense for this club
I would love for us to make a decision about ETH and Greenwood - but that is still under review apparently
Mid-table doesn't mean the middle point.of the table. It's generally used to describe the range of mediocrity where you're not in the European places and you're not under threat of relegation.
They will In 2025
Certain Greenwood is gone when we get offer
Tier 2:
More info: Jason Wilcox and Matt Hargreaves are leading the way in executing the summer transfer window plans
More info: Jason Wilcox and Matt Hargreaves are leading the way in executing the summer transfer window plans
€25m? Still have to pay 25m? We paid 10m for the loan so he’s 35m then?
If it’s FA Cup final Amrabat for a full season, sign me up.
This worries me, should have nothing to do with if Ten Hag stays or not. If he's the profile of player the club think we need then sign him. If he isn't then don't, regardless of if Ten Hag wants him or not.
It definitely won't be. That's a hard pass as far as I'm concerned
Sky reported last year that it would cost €25 million (about £21 million) to sign him after the loan deal expired
Exactly, and even though I appreciate him, I don't think he's good enough, even as a squad option, we need him to be good enough to threaten the position of a starting DM which isn't the case for Amrabat
Seems Jose wants Greenwood at Fernbache
Show us the money
I'd take him as a squad option for £21M
The problem is we possibly dont have enough cash to sort the first team to warrant spending money on squad players sadly/frustratingly.
I don't know, we should have more spending power available than recent seasons, whilst being less retricted by FFP now the loss is out of the three year cycle.
No point spending 25m on him. May aswell put that 25m towards a really good solid DM. I’d rather have quality than quantity.
I read something this morning that said greenwood isn’t keen on working with him though. Plus they won’t be able to afford 50m and we can’t afford to loan him again.
I daresay that Turkey wouldn’t be a good experience for him and his family. Fans are very intense there and on top of you.
Big difference from playing in a more relaxed environment such as Spain or Portugal
Nobody is paying anywhere near £50m for him.
Fenerbahce offer 8 million for Greenwood
It’s amazing how one performance (usually the last performance ) changes mindsets. The guy is terrible , send him back to Italian where he won’t get caught in possession .
