I think anyone will appear bigger and stronger when you're hitting them as hard as you can, trying to take them down, and they're still just standing there ready to push the pace. DC has definitely fought stronger men, but maybe none who can push the pace like Jones. For me, his stamina and endurance is one of his biggest weapons. Just keeps coming at you, so impressive.
Stronger men whilst at 205? Not sure about that. Cormier is a HW fighting at LHW; there's got to be a fair amount strength lost for him in dropping/cutting and he could get away with that against the calibre of opposition he faced pre-Jones, but against an athlete in his probable fitness prime, it did expose DC a bit.
Stephan Bonner was bigger than Jones and had a reach around 80", and Jones destroyed him. Rampage, Glover, Rashad weighed more than Jones on fight night and so had more mass, but it didn't make any difference either. I don't get the reach argument, just because you have a long reach doesn't mean you're born also with the skills to use it. Stefan Strive has a longer reach and is terrible at using it effectively. Not only that but Jones fought DC a lot in the clinch and against the fence, he wasn't even fighting tall. He also dirty boxed with Glover and fought inside too, and beat both of them. In regards to Gus, he is an excellent boxer, and has really good movement, I think that threw off Jones more than the similar reaches.
Do you have the numbers to hand? I'd like to know what the differences were.
I haven't once knocked Jones ability - he is an elite fighter who uses his tools to exceptional level, but that's part of the problem with him in the LHW's... it's like a HW fighting smaller guys with much shorter appendages. It's a gripe I've had with the Jones GOAT talk for a while. Guys like Silva, St. Pierre, Mighty Mouse etc are all the same size etc as their opponents with no enormous physical advantages in
addition to their elite skillset. If Silva towered over the guys in his division in addition to the skills he had, he wouldn't have got the same level of acknowledgement, imo, same as people like me need to see Jones do something in a weight class where his stature is the norm'. He'd always be a lighter class of Heavyweight, for sure, which probably puts him at a disadvantage, but if he pulled of victories there, his legacy would become concrete and his skills regarded as the greatest if he could toy around with bigger guys in the same way he toys around with smaller ones.
Your point about Gus goes hand in hand with his size. It wasn't just that he was a good boxer that threw Jones, imo, it was also the fact Gus' equally long reach meant he could get through consistently in ways Jones wasn't used to. It would be interesting to see how Jones would cope with guys with similar range and a lot more power behind their shots.
I think he uses his physical assets extremely well, but he has so many tools to dig into that he is pretty much the complete fighter. And if he is destroying nearly all in his division, then he shouldn't move up. He is a natural LHW, just with an excellent reach, and if he doesn't struggle with the cut at all, which he doesn't, then LHW is were he should be.
Now that the news about the drugs has come out, it does throw a wrench into the works with regard to the ease with keeping the weight in line, no?
I don't think he is a natural LHW, I also don't believe he's a natural HW, however, he's an oddity in that regard, to me, a catchweight fighter - too big for LHW, but not big enough to go up against monsters like Browne in HW and have a chance. He'd have to gain a lot to be a true HW, but irrespective of that debate, I still think he's too big for LHW.