For all the criticism levelled at him, and I honestly think the criticism is justified, it's not like Roy had many options this summer. I'm really not convinced Barry, despite a good season, would've been any better (he would've brought something else to the table, but he has his limitations), and truly what Gerrard's 'downfall' highlights is the lack of more continental styled midfielders in England's ranks. Seriously, how many have there been over the last 10 years? Scholes, in his late career, who excelled in the role, but was never used as such in the England outfit, as far as I recall? Carrick, who completely fecked up his good work last season by being quite awful this one and ruining any chance he may have had to make the squad? (and who hasn't ever been as good with England as with Utd, which could be explained by other factors)
I think Gerrard should stop being used by England, I really don't see how the team is going to benefit from his presence anymore, but I'm honestly wondering how Roy would go about building a midfield that would be able to compete in 2 years in France if England qualifies. Henderson is incredibly limited, may progress but won't ever be that type of midfielder we're talking about, Wilshere also has a more dynamic profile, I just don't see anyone who could fill that role of being able to retain the ball and control the tempo. I think there's talent in some positions in the team, but I also think there's the glaring weakness of the midfield which will carry on causing us disappointments when face with good opposition.