Heinze was a fair defender but a shite attacker, he's crossing was poor, he seemed like he had a good free kick but only scored 1 for us I think, TBF, he was poor playing CB for us when all our defenders were injured and once Evra settled down and was one of our best players, he starts bitching like Tevez did and once Rafa wanted him and he wanted to move.... this angered all the fans..
TBH, he wasn't totally shite, had a few good moments, was a really tough and crazy defender and will always stick his leg in just like Vidic did but he didn't have the pace, the flair, the attacking presences that Evra gives us and once Evra started to show that he is GOD, sadly Heinze fell out of the pecking order which by fair, Evra will and always will be the better player.
In summary, he was good, but only a little bit good... just above average.