Scott McTominay (Out) - Newcastle, West Ham, Everton, Southampton, Leicester interested

ETH has had the chance to see him first hand over the last few months and if he has deemed him surplus then so be it. I’ve never seen a United first team player in him and he’s had more than enough chances.

If we can get £20million+ then sell him. Pointless keeping players who’ll never adapt to a system or are just not the standard needed.

Sell them and move on, we need to be more ruthless.
 
Vapor trail said:
Think Mctomminay is usable as a squad option especially in this era of 5 substitutes. So long as he's not a pivotal first team member he surely can have a role to contribute to this season.
Click to expand...
Best way for McTom to contribute to our season is to be sold for a decent amount of money so we can fund other signings.
 
If selling him means providing extra funds for Frenkie. On your bike son.
 
I will believe it when I see it. And I don't think I will see it. Tinfoil hat on, but I'm certain there are certain people within the structure of the club that are protecting him. There is no other explanation for his participation week in week out for so many years despite never being even remotely good enough. And don't give me that shite about 4 different managers rating him.
 
In all likelihood, Leeds would fit such potential transfer. They had recent experience wirh us for the Dan James transfer and McT did well against them.
 
It's kind of ironic that people talk about Iqbal and Savage as ready for the first-team when they often struggle to make a huge impact against other teams reserve-sides. Garner yes - the other 2 need to go out loan and prove themselves first
 
I'd get him out the door for £10-15m if that bid arrives. We need to end this charade once and for all.
 
Loved him when we played against Leeds last season, he was a fighter in that game.
But he's too limited and not what we need, sell him and get either Frenkie or SMS please, or someone we get linked to tomorrow I don't care at this point.
 
Joseunited said:
Almost on the same level as McTominay covering for Casemiro.
Click to expand...
Did you bang your head this morning? This is the post you initially replied to, about 15 minutes ago;

redcucumber said:
Every game we play McTominay at DM is a potential defeat. He isn't of any use to us, even as cover.
Click to expand...
What have you gleaned from this conversation that makes you think I'm advocating McTominay to remain as cover for Casemiro? Think you need to get back to bed, bud.
 
I personally think he’s got talent in him that some manager will be able to nurture. He’s shown glimpses of it but not nearly consistently enough. Much like many good players in our squad, he is completely bereft of confidence at the moment. A David Moyes type of manager will do him good.
 
CM10 said:
I'd get him out the door for £10-15m if that bid arrives. We need to end this charade once and for all.
Click to expand...
With 5 English clubs potentially interested and also some German and Italian clubs, plus players like Chukwuemeka going for £20m and Morgan Gibbs-White for £42.5m I would hope we could get a bit more.
 
Mctominay should be leaving if we are sure to bring in another CM after Casemiro, on second thoughts no he can go right away.
 
redcucumber said:
Did you bang your head this morning? This is the post you initially replied to, about 15 minutes ago;


What have you gleaned from this conversation that makes you think I'm advocating McTominay to remain as cover for Casemiro? Think you need to get back to bed, bud.
Click to expand...
Look mate read our little interchange,you jumped in when i responded to a poster saying we might sell 3 players to offset Casemiro.
I said we might need to buy another midfielder(implying we would be light in midfield).
Feck knows what you think I was implying but crack on anyway.
 
Mike Smalling said:
Why? The guy is 25. He is not going to massively improve somehow. His faults as a player is massive, and he won't ever be good enough for us.
Click to expand...

They’ve been this/last season, yes. But before that he was a player who added to his game season by season. I believe there’s a decent player beneath his current form and 25 might not be the worst age for him - he clearly takes care of his body. So both to see if he can become a better player, and also to raise his price if he performs at a loan-side.
 
Joseunited said:
Look mate read our little interchange,you jumped in when i responded to a poster saying we might sell 3 players to offset Casemiro.
I said we might need to buy another midfielder(implying we would be light in midfield).
Feck knows what you think I was implying but crack on anyway.
Click to expand...
It seemed like you were implying we'd be left short at DM if we sold McTominay as he's our only other option. Both firmly agreed that he needs to go.
 
Sounds of the Aquarium said:
With 5 English clubs potentially interested and also some German and Italian clubs, plus players like Chukwuemeka going for £20m and Morgan Gibbs-White for £42.5m I would hope we could get a bit more.
Click to expand...
If we can, great. This is a player who has played 122 Premier League games for us and has 3 more years on his contract. My primary concern isn't how much money we get for him, it's the potential damage of keeping a player of his quality around the first team for another year or two.
 
Seeing his back would make me as happy as when I saw the legendary paddy own goals mcnair out
 
CM10 said:
If we can, great. This is a player who has played 122 Premier League games for us and has 3 more years on his contract. My primary concern isn't how much money we get for him, it's the potential damage of keeping a player of his quality around the first team for another year or two.
Click to expand...
100% agree. We all know the squad needs a massive overhaul. I am only now starting to get the feeling that might now be happening. The players out of contract like pogba and lingard were a given but these sub par players is the next phase (and then also getting the replacements in, which we seem to be doing as well)
 
Marcelinho87 said:
Fred is miles ahead of McTominay, McTominay can't get in Scotland's midfield nevermind the Brazil one
Click to expand...

And Carrick and Scholes always got looked over for England. It’s a meaningless metric that has just been picked up as another way to try to bash McTominay.
 
Turn him into a defender. I bet he does better than maguire as a cb.
 
roseguy64 said:
Yeah, I can tell by how much they've each played.
Click to expand...
Silly, he's had a pre season with both - one has been in our first team for about 3 years with no rumour of a move away and now all of a sudden Iqbal is with the first team squad, we've signed Casemiro, we want another midfielder and Scott is linked for away.
 
Somebody like Moyes would happily spunk £30 million on this chuffer.

If the club was in any way competent then we’d get rid and bring in another central midfielder to complement Casemiro.
 
Walrus said:
And Carrick and Scholes always got looked over for England. It’s a meaningless metric that has just been picked up as another way to try to bash McTominay.
Click to expand...
Scholes never got overlooked? He was a great player. He might have been played out of position as a player deemed capable of playing in other positions but he was never overlooked like Carrick or McT
 
Walrus said:
And Carrick and Scholes always got looked over for England. It’s a meaningless metric that has just been picked up as another way to try to bash McTominay.
Click to expand...

Fred is a significantly better midfielder than McTominay irrespective.
 
Please be true! Then lets work with one of our younger players to take his place in the squad
 
Bang. Average.

If we can get him out the door and another in it would be great business
 
A loan would be worse than keeping him. Either sell or retain him. You don’t loan out players who have played as much football as him at his age unless you can’t sell, which isn’t the case here — there’d be plenty interested.
 
He was good when United played on empty stadium plus he isn't on high wage. It's no surprise many clubs want him
 
Really sad to see how many people wanna get rid of (what was the name of the title/trophy that JM inveted just so he could be seen as youth promoter) winner.
 
McTominay has the worst first touch I've ever seen from a Manchester United midfielder.
Even as a cover, every minute he plays is better given to Garner, actual young player who we try ro figure out whether he can handle playing for Man United.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.