Scott McTominay image 39

Scott McTominay Scotland flag

2021-22 Performances


View full 2021-22 profile

5.0 Season Average Rating
Appearances
37
Goals
2
Assists
1
Yellow cards
10
Status
Not open for further replies.
It was Varane. And by a distance
Wasn’t asking you, sunshine
I wouldn’t argue with that necessarily I thought varane was good but hard to reconcile a motm performance with a team that was clearly outplayed and gave up so many attempts at goal
 
those comments by the manager are very worrying the lad being talked about as a future captain.. hes 25 and playing his part in one of the worst united teams in the PL era.

Where are the clubs standards? Same goes for some of the fans.. you'd never ever see Real/Barce have a player in such a pivotal role on the pitch.
 
McGinn outplayed and outfought him again. The goal and the shots don't mask his lack of control in midfield.

It was Neves and Moutinho last week, Johnjo Shelvey the week before, Gilmour and MacClean before that, Capoue, Cleverly, Koomeiners etc.. it's pretty much the same every week.

Him and Fred get out fought and out thought by most players they come up against.
 
Was good for the first 20-30 minutes, winning the ball in midfield and spraying long passes out to the wing. Kind of fell collapsed with the rest of the team but he’s been one of our better players under Rangnick.
 
All those managers that like him have one thing in common, they have been sacked by us for producing god awful football, seems like we’re heading in the same direction again.

I'm rooting for Ten Hag over Pochettino just to get the club used to the idea that want the ball and being able to keep possession under pressure are good quality and not witchcraft.

When you add Bruno constantly turning it over (which I do think we can live with and the right manager could maybe address personally with Bruno and also make less of a problem tactically) how many teams have a midfield that would upset a Guardiola style manager more than ours in the Prem? Not more than 7 or 8.

I'm gonna start ranting about how if we'd given Moyes a few more years we'd actually be in better shape because we'd be hard to beat at least while still being unable to dominate games and keep the ball and get banned or swatted, I'm logging off.
 
If he's been one of our best performers since RR took over, how shite have the rest been?

https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSeQPkcE7/

Failed to close down McGinn the first time round, then slowly jogged while watching McGinn line up. He even pointed out that someone needed to close the shot down.

Total lack of effort. For someone so technically limited, he should be working his ass off to compensate. Instead he jogs about like he's Zidane.
 
We have to try him at the back. There's no way he can have a future in midfield at our club. If he's not hiding, he's making terrible passes, if not that, he's not aware of where opposition players are who are trying to take the ball away. This just won't work.
 
I thought he was good earlier on especially in attack but his defending was bad and Fred did not help it at all. He is not good enough.
 
Gotta love his thirst for attack and hunger for goals, but he needs to be more consistently better at attack and his defensive work is simply abysmal for a top club we aspire to be.
 
His facial reactions when he pops off a half-decent volley every once in a while reeks of an average player surprising himself
 
Scott is good box to box or attacking midfielder.
Excellent positioning on set pieces, good long range shot, has a through ball in him.
DM he is not.
He is asked to do things he is bad at. With a proper DM and a more attacking role, he will be great.
 
Scott is good box to box or attacking midfielder.
Excellent positioning on set pieces, good long range shot, has a through ball in him.
DM he is not.
He is asked to do things he is bad at. With a proper DM and a more attacking role, he will be great.
I tend to agree with this. Both him and Fred are squares asked to be perfect circles and then take criticism for it. They don’t work as a pairing in a 2. I don’t know why our managers constantly think that they do.
 
Scott is good box to box or attacking midfielder.
Excellent positioning on set pieces, good long range shot, has a through ball in him.
DM he is not.
He is asked to do things he is bad at. With a proper DM and a more attacking role, he will be great.
I tend to agree with this. Both him and Fred are squares asked to be perfect circles and then take criticism for it. They don’t work as a pairing in a 2. I don’t know why our managers constantly think that they do.

100% correct. I actually went to this thread to write exactly this, but you saved me the effort. :) I'm not trusted with liking posts yet, but would have done so if I could.
 
I absolutely love Mctominay.

I've seen so many more average midfielders at United starting matches than him.

For me, it's not his fault that we lack World Class midfielders that puts him in his "righteous position" at the club. Good player.
 
I absolutely love Mctominay.

I've seen so many more average midfielders at United starting matches than him.

For me, it's not his fault that we lack World Class midfielders that puts him in his "righteous position" at the club. Good player.
Name one. Who was midfielder who started games for us and was worse than McT? I will accept players who were only rotation players too
 
Name one. Who was midfielder who started games for us and was worse than McT? I will accept players who were only rotation players too

Cleverley, Schneiderlin, Bastian, Pereira, Fellaini from the recent ones.
 
He can have a solid midtable career grabbing the odd goal while others do his midfield work, like Kevin Nolan
 
First 30 mins or so he was playing very well. Hit some beautiful passes and some good shots.

He then did his usual trick of switching off defensively and let Mcginn have a piss easy shot under no pressure, then proceeded to start mishitting every pass.

He's very odd in the way he can go from looking like the next Micheal Ballack to Bebe in a number of minutes.
 
First 30 mins or so he was playing very well. Hit some beautiful passes and some good shots.

He then did his usual trick of switching off defensively and let Mcginn have a piss easy shot under no pressure, then proceeded to start mishitting every pass.

He's very odd in the way he can go from looking like the next Micheal Ballack to Bebe in a number of minutes.
Pretty much.

I want him in the squad though, I just don't think he should be in the first XI.
 
Cleverley, Schneiderlin, Bastian, Pereira, Fellaini from the recent ones.

None of these players have played in midfield for United as much as him, Fellaini and Celeverly were also better players than him.
 
Cleverley, Schneiderlin, Bastian, Pereira, Fellaini from the recent ones.
Same Cleverley who looked like Zidane playing against McT month ago? Fellaini? Fellaini was much better player for us than McT.
Others never were starters or regular players.
 
First 30 mins or so he was playing very well. Hit some beautiful passes and some good shots.

He then did his usual trick of switching off defensively and let Mcginn have a piss easy shot under no pressure, then proceeded to start mishitting every pass.

He's very odd in the way he can go from looking like the next Micheal Ballack to Bebe in a number of minutes.
Pretty much agree with this, thought first 30 mins he was going to have one of those games where he is class, but then it all went to pot and we just got completely over ran. He can spray the ball about quite well when not under pressure, but he really isn’t the quality United should be relying on as a 1st 11 player if we want to win things.
 
Would love if it his game highlights weren't being muscled off the ball, ran through, dispossessed, giving the ball away etc. The goal was nice but being more reliable in possession and shielding the defense is what we need.
 
Clearly more of a number 8 who needs more of a licence to push on. He's got a very good shooting technique but he doesn't get in those positions often enough and his physicality would cause real problem for defenders if he could make those late runs into the box.

The hatred he gets from our fanbase is disgusting. He's the least of our problems. A good player and every manager has loved him for good reason.
 
To be fair he’s not really our biggest problem right now. It’s just him and Fred have inconsistency which is part of problem if we want to challenge the league. The biggest problem right now is that our attackers are off form (all of them). I would like to see how our current team are running when Bruno, Sancho, Greenwood, and Rashford are performing.
 
Cleverley, Schneiderlin, Bastian, Pereira, Fellaini from the recent ones.

Seriously, what is up with our club? This is all while the likes of Modric, Vidal, Kdb, Thiago, Kroos and so on were changing clubs and some on cheap deals. We are just so terrible at spotting up and coming first team talent or when we spot it we drop the ball or spend the summer chasing Fabregas or Bale. Christ! If we just swapped cities DOF and gave them the same money we’ve spend we’d currently be dominating the game.

Bruno. That’s pretty much all we’ve got to show for in the market since 2013
 
consistency will never be there from him to be a top CM. Standards have fallen so much for this club. Would be a good squad option to keep around but that should be it. Future club captain? Feck me man.
 
Cleverley, Schneiderlin, Bastian, Pereira, Fellaini from the recent ones.

Kleberson, Djemba Djemba, Alan Smith, Phil Neville, possibly Fortune, O'Shea, Kieran Richardson, Darron Gibson (although he could have been class if not for the booze/attitude/whatever it was).
 
Kleberson, Djemba Djemba, Alan Smith, Phil Neville, possibly Fortune, O'Shea, Kieran Richardson, Darron Gibson (although he could have been class if not for the booze/attitude/whatever it was).


did you actually ever watch united ? kleberson is a world cup winning midfieder, djemba djemba probably started about 10 games.. alan smith was 10 x the player, watch any united arsenal game where phil neville played cm and tell me youve ever seen McT have a performace like that . Fortune.. the LB ? who played a few in midfield..at a time we had keane scholes butt etc.. oshea. is 100 x the player he is, richardson .. again a left back..and another who never played 150 apps for the club and to finish off darren gibson performed in important CL games for us..and has far more technical ability.

the only one in that list is Djemba Djemba.. and he didnt play a 1/4 of the games McT has.

The Mediocre this fan base accept now is astonishing, we have a lad who in past years would never ever had played 5 games for this club being talked about as a future captain.

whats worse is fans who claim hed be decent further up the pitch...so we want to be in for the likes of Haaland for him to be supplied ammunition by Mctominay.. wake the f up will ya
 
Scott is good box to box or attacking midfielder.
Excellent positioning on set pieces, good long range shot, has a through ball in him.
DM he is not.
He is asked to do things he is bad at. With a proper DM and a more attacking role, he will be great.

I agree with this BUT as a box to box or attacking midfielder he is not good enough either. He's decent at running forward through the midfield but there's a lot more to that job than that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.