Robbie Boy
Full Member
It's almost like the quality of a squad is much, much more important than the manager.
Those examples
Full of world class players who had won the biggest trophies vs this mismatch of nonsense inherited by Amorim.
It's almost like the quality of a squad is much, much more important than the manager.
How? The 3 biggest holes are the same. There rest still aren't good enough.More money.
That doesn't mean that he's free to lose every home gameIt’s a free hit this season. It was screwed before he got here. Hopefully he can guide us to the CL via the EL, maybe pick up the cup too, but the league is over already. We’d do well now to finish top 10, let alone the top 4/5.
It’s more in our interest to let him breakdown the squad now to rebuild for the long term. I know it’s not much fun, but it’s the right way. There isn’t going to be a quick fix.
You're right, we should have got Slot and won the league.Man United fans with being delusional.
Explain Slot winning the league with Liverpool without any signings.
Explain Zidane winning the UCL with Madrid after mid season take over from Benitez and finishing 1 point behind Barca in the league.
Explain Pep winning 6 titles after coaching Barca only that season.
Explain Flick winning a Treble after taking Bayern mid season.
Just to tell you, when a team does a mid season managerial change, it means the team was doing poorly, so how comes some managers can come mid season in a team and achieve success..
Or you will say they were team B managers.. probably we should sign team B managers then.
Even Conte won the EPL on it's first try. Slot will do it. While us we need 600m, 3 years project, 15 new players, new stadium and new owners...
In the words of big Ange, it is what it is, mate!That doesn't mean that he's free to lose every home game
He’s busy still not being interested in the PL or England in general.My system shall always play.
What's zidane up to these days?
If I were him I wouldn't have taken the job given how ill suited the team is to the one system he plays and our historic inability to recruit wellUnited setting him up to fail? If I was him, I'd be a bit worried by the lack of backing in this window - Ineos hedging their bets in case a change is needed in the summer?
You're right, we should have got Slot and won the league.
Zidane would win the CL with my Sunday league side too.
Another lie that has been thrown around frequently.
Pep had Kompany, Aguero, KDB, Fernadinho, Silva from previous managers and Pep was able to achieve 100 points in a season with them being the main spine of the team.
Let nobody cheat you that you need 11 new players to win anything. Good managers should know how to play with what you have.
He’s busy still not being interested in the PL or England in general.
Cult of the manager?! He's been here 3 monthsI'm not 100% against Ruben but I am 100% against the cult of the manager bollocks that has infected the minds of most reds. It's that attitude that is one of the reasons why we've failed as a club throughout our history when it goes bad. ETH did wake up some people, but not enough.
I recall when Amorim joined, he said he needs to get time and the only way he gets time is with results.
After all these weeks, the results aren’t good. Hopefully one of the journalists asks him to evaluate himself based on what he said (assuming Rashford isn’t a hot topic anymore).
And had the worst three months any United manager in living memory hadCult of the manager?! He's been here 3 months
It shows how low standards are that the 4th richest team in the world and second best paid team in the league are playing like relegation contenders and it’s being explained away.Right. But then, nobody is asking United to win the PL with 100 points.
Most top managers need 'their' team to achieve their highest highs. But they also need to show very good/great performances and results without "their" team. That should be obvious, as most jobs will not give them the time or money to build their own team before judging them.
And had the worst three months any United manager in living memory had
Unfortunately I don’t think Amorim is here next season either and through no fault of his own as he said himself he was told by Ineos he either joined now or never even though Ineos knew there was barely any room to do anything in regards to bringing players he’d want in and knew Amorim was married to his system, he’s been set up to fail and brought in under false pretence although as Amorim has said himself he will play his system until the very end so won’t change no matter what.I'm 60-70% certain he's sacked by the seasons end with the current trajectory. INEOS planning for his arrival and the lack of movement in the window points towards them having a heightened expectation compared to what the manager is vocalising.
The same Pep who's team have fallen off a cliff because their DM is injured and a few others have got old.
Its not about having your own players it's about having good players.
For the same reason Liverpool haven't had a drop off from Klopp.
It's simpler than that. We are broke. Can't draw blood from a stone.United setting him up to fail? If I was him, I'd be a bit worried by the lack of backing in this window - Ineos hedging their bets in case a change is needed in the summer?
which has nothing to do with my point.And had the worst three months any United manager in living memory had
What reset? He won't get a resetwhich has nothing to do with my point.
We've been saying for years that we need a complete reset and then when one happens people wet the bed because the results are all over the place. Absolute babies.
what are you on about? He's in the midst of a reset.What reset? He won't get a reset
Exactly, I think most of us could do well exposing the players’ limitations. On the other hand it may be because we’re not good enough for the task.Can we copy & paste this for Spurs fans too? And any manager currently doing shite?
Probably something along the lines of "we have no money, so you'll need to work with what you've got".Tuchel apparently turned us down according to him, so why was that? What did we tell him that put him off.
And how is it going? He can't get a tune out of anyone and we won't be able to make big moves in the marketwhat are you on about? He's in the midst of a reset.
He's not going to get a full-scale squad clearout and replacement like his predecessors didwhat are you on about? He's in the midst of a reset.
Sensible man then.Probably something along the lines of "we have no money, so you'll need to work with what you've got".
Probably something along the lines of "we have no money, so you'll need to work with what you've got".
A squad clearout is fine if you then rebuild a great squad. If anything ours has got worse and worse with every rebuild.He's not going to get a full-scale squad clearout and replacement like his predecessors did
Yup, billions wasted only for the squad to get progressively worse. Borderline criminal malpractice!A squad clearout is fine if you then rebuild a great squad. If anything ours has got worse and worse with every rebuild.
It's not irrelevant. We don't have players who can play wing back and we don't have 10s.
Another lie that has been thrown around frequently.
Pep had Kompany, Aguero, KDB, Fernadinho, Silva from previous managers and Pep was able to achieve 100 points in a season with them being the main spine of the team.
Let nobody cheat you that you need 11 new players to win anything. Good managers should know how to play with what you have.
I haven't seen someone sabotage their own arguments quite like this since my college girlfriend said that my knob was a little bigger than my best friend's.Man United fans with being delusional.
Explain Slot winning the league with Liverpool without any signings.
Explain Zidane winning the UCL with Madrid after mid season take over from Benitez and finishing 1 point behind Barca in the league.
Explain Pep winning 6 titles after coaching Barca only that season.
Explain Flick winning a Treble after taking Bayern mid season.
Just to tell you, when a team does a mid season managerial change, it means the team was doing poorly, so how comes some managers can come mid season in a team and achieve success..
Or you will say they were team B managers.. probably we should sign team B managers then.
Even Conte won the EPL on it's first try. Slot will do it. While us we need 600m, 3 years project, 15 new players, new stadium and new owners...
Anyone that expected that he would come in halfway through a season, with this bunch of players, implement a completely new system of playing, and it not be an extremely rocky few months is utterly delusional.And how is it going? He can't get a tune out of anyone and we won't be able to make big moves in the market
There's rocky and then there's sitting at 1 point per gameAnyone that expected that he would come in halfway through a season, with this bunch of players, implement a completely new system of playing, and it not be an extremely rocky few months is utterly delusional.
Maybe not, but Rashford, Casemiro, Eriksen and a few more will go - which means he may have to promote youth and/or be extremely clever in the transfer market. Let's face the hundreds of millions that we have spent in the last decade has done us no good at all, so I'm happy to see something different.He's not going to get a full-scale squad clearout and replacement like his predecessors did
I said pre season that we hadn't improved our first XI by any significant degree:Just to further your point, they also looked old, slow and crap getting beat every other week a couple of seasons ago. So much so they had to go and buy Gravenberch, Szoboszlai and Mac Allister (They also tried to buy Caicedo/Lavia but ended up with Endo) to completely renew and energise their midfield.
You could prob pick a player from every club outside of the top 6 in this league to improve every position in our 1st team while only being allowed to choose 1 player max from each team, that's damning.
Yeah it’s tough to say “turn down United” but his best move was probably to tell us it’s next summer or nothing and call our bluff. I was worried about this when we first hired him, because our squad and forward line in particular is god awful even with Amad carrying a huge load of responsibility as a new breakthrough player. We were never going to score enough goals to give him a cushion for poor performances, and now you’re seeing that come to fruition where we have games where we play well yet can’t doing anything in the final third and then one individual error costs us and we loseIf I were him I wouldn't have taken the job given how ill suited the team is to the one system he plays and our historic inability to recruit well
We've also knocked Arsenal out of the cup, qualified in 3rd place in the EL, and had excellent performances against our biggest rivals - do they not count?There's rocky and then there's sitting at 1 point per game