Why it is not true for Hojlund too? He just scored two in a game! Your post makes no sense.
Ruben Amorim - Manchester United Head Coach
- Thread starter sewey89
- Start date
Against Arsenal we’ll see a bit more who he’s starting to rate the most I reckon
People making sweeping statements about who the manager does and doesn't rate based on who has been starting after three games when he's come out and said that he wants to rotate is hilarious.
His honesty is refreshing. Despite the results, our performances haven't been that great. We struggle to keep hold off the ball and still do a lot hoofing, huffing and puffing in the 90 minutes. It's important that the system is drilled in this season and then as we add important pieces to the puzzle so that it starts coming together from the next season on.
His comment on Amad and how Ruud giving him a chance in the games he was the interim that built his confidence was excellent. When the interviewer asked him about Rashford and a few others buzzing (don't remember the exact word), he instantly said that it is the new manager bounce as the players want to give a little extra for the new guy. He is a very likeable character and comes across really well. He knows that a lot of work needs to be done before we can hope to challenge for the big trophies again. It has been a relatively easy ride so far against a Norwegian team and two struggling PL teams. Lot of tough games to navigate through in the next two months before the mid-season break. Keeping my fingers crossed that we keep growing as a unit.
I think this is very exaggerated. It wasn't perfect or even good but it was far from that bad.
Definitely not a performance where you would expect the other side to score 5.
I never said they should have scored 5. I just said we were quite poor. There was a 2 v 1 where De Ligt intercepted the cross for a tap in.
There was Beto through on goal but he took it wide.
There was 2/3 where their players ran in behind our wing backs.
We got lucky that we scored when we did as our build up was really poor as well in the first half.
Actually our build up has not improved since Ten Hag. We still struggle to build out properly.
Posts that feel like a heart-warming coming out story but aren'tJust sang "She is the One" by Robbie Williams, changing the lyrics to "He is the one" Mever been happier at the local karaoke, except for my friends eyes being like
This is rather bewildering. Rashford has almost none of the traits required to play the CF role in this system whereas Hojlund profiles very similar to one particular player who has excelled under Amorim in this setup...
And given Rashford didn't even play upfront yesterday this is essentially a non-argument anyway which makes it even more complexing.
Yes, the undeniable form of rashford. 4 goals in 13. That'll win us titles.
This will improve as players get more used to the spaces that are naturally open in build up (specifically that cross field quick switch that works so well). We also don't particularly have a front 3 where the ball will "stick" if pinged into them right now. Zirkzee will at times and Mount sometimes, but Bruno/Rashford/Garnacho/Hojlund aren't those types of players which can make it tougher to break lines through a press.
They accumulated an xG of 0.20 in the first half, they basically had a couple of long shot opportunities due to individual mistakes from our defenders/midfielders but more often than not we end up with clean sheet.
Between this game and Bodo game I feel our offense has improved. Of course it’s not at the level we should expect it to be but it’s hard to get there in a week. We haven’t even played the same front 3 as Amorim is trying to find the right setup, and it will take several more games before he does eventually, so expecting improvement to be rather slow.
Has he ask for 3 years and 700M to implement his style of play yet?
That's a good way of telling me you didn't watch the game.
I agree. I can see this improving as we get more time to train. I was just saying we shouldn't let stats and results cloud our judgement.
Yeah as far as yesterday goes, think it was pretty clear we were getting outdueled on any 50/50's for majority of that first half which led to a lot of our issues. But at least the way in which we look to attack and play looks sustainable, and I really like how the formation gives natural spaces and openings to exploit without players having to be really clever about it.
Yep agreed. I think its more our players haven't learnt yet the defensive / pressing shape yet.
You could see that Kobbie / Casemiro were confused at times, who to mark or when to press.
I also think having Kobbie / Casemiro does not work as they are not very nimble, they struggle to cover grass, which is why we looked better with Ugarte there.
It could also be that Ugarte knows the system more?
My guess, annoyingly suspensions rule mainoo and martinez out.
Hojlund
Rashford - Bruno
Case - Ugarte
Dalot -Shaw - De Ligt - Maz - Amad
This seems an eminently sensible approach. As such you can guarantee it will be ignored.
Edit: except Antony. He’s bobbins. No amount of time and patience is going to change that.
Yes I couldn’t agree more. Even Amorim had admitted that we were fortunate and didn’t play as well, we scored during a key moment in the game where we lost control. Everton have made it easier for us to increase the score when they had to come out and chase the game that resulted with plenty of space for our players to exploit
I am sure Amorim knows full well of this, as opposed to some fans where they can’t get past the number of goals we scored and pick players purely on this metric.
Yep, well Amorim in his presser said.. 3-2 V Bodo was a better performance but it was 3-2 and this was a worse performance but we won 4-0. He acknowledges that we were poor in the first half after 15 mins until we scored.
I dont understand why some fans think we were amazing, bringing out xG against in the first half. Yeah, they didn't create a clear cut chance but we were lucky that they didn't. They got into multiple dangerous positions.
My point was, if we played that first half against Arsenal, we are 2/3 goals down at half time. That was just my personal opinion.
Yes, and also a fully fit squad. As soon as one player gets injured, the 3 year timer resets and he gets £700 million more to spend.
Yep, as you have said it’d be interesting to see how he sets up the team for Arsenal, whether he goes defensive and opts for Rashford to counter on the break with Casermeio alongside Ugarte or go head to head with players that can press and pass effectively i.e. Mount & Garnacho as 10s with Bruno & Ugarte in midfield.
“Bye bye ETH” to the tune of Angels by Robbie Williams
I sit and wait
Does ruben contemplate our fate?
And does he know the places where they go
When the players are grey and old?
'Cause I have been told
That motivation lets the wings unfold
So when I'm lying in my bed
Thoughts running through my head
And I feel that football is dead
I'm loving Amorim instead
And through it all he offers me protection
A lot of goals and dedication, whether he’s right or wrong
And down the waterfall, wherever it may take him
I know that United won't break him
When I come to call, he won't forsake me
I'm loving amorim instead
I sit and wait
Does ruben contemplate our fate?
And does he know the places where they go
When the players are grey and old?
'Cause I have been told
That motivation lets the wings unfold
So when I'm lying in my bed
Thoughts running through my head
And I feel that football is dead
I'm loving Amorim instead
And through it all he offers me protection
A lot of goals and dedication, whether he’s right or wrong
And down the waterfall, wherever it may take him
I know that United won't break him
When I come to call, he won't forsake me
I'm loving amorim instead
I did watch the game. We were chaotic for about 20 minutes in the first half, that’s all. It wasn’t that bad, they weren’t all over us, they should not have scored several goals or anything.
I think from his subs / line up, he has given a slight clue..
I suspect Mount and Ugarte come in for energy. Hojlund didn't get on and Zirkzee played 90, so I suspect Hojlund starts.
Mazroui and De Ligt came off, suggests they will start.
I think it will be Hojlund, Garnacho, Mount as front 3.
Bruno is the question mark, if he starts might be in the 2 with Ugarte, which is a risk imo.
Rawk esque poetry. Brings a tear to my eye...
That’s what I am thinking too, it’s a tough call with Bruno or Cas in midfield, whether the latter defensively is enough to compromise for his inability to pass and gives the ball away constantly, particularly against sides like Arsenal who presses effectively. Personally he will struggle badly and we’ll end up defending deep most of the game so if we opt for Cas, we might as well play Rashford as one of the 10 to play on the counter.
Agreed on Bruno, I dont know if he is good enough defensively. There is a difference between tracking and having energy and actually shielding.
its almost we want a combination of Case and Bruno as 1 player. Bruno has the energy / desire/ aggression but whenever I see him defend, its so easy to sidestep him and go past him.
I just cannot see him against Odegard and Saka playing one twos around him.
I suspect he will use Garnacho's counter attacking ability as Rashford doesn't offer the same off the ball work.
Yes, we did. In 2016.
So much improvement in general position discipline in 2-3 weeks
Certainly, there is a different level of risk between Bruno and Cas, this is a game where Amorim can closely observe what these players are made of if they can maintain a decent level of control against the elite teams.
I also prefer Garnacho, not only his off-the ball work but also his ability to dribble and maintain possession of the ball in confined space, at least compared to Rashford, who is a better finisher.
I didn't say they should have scored... I said a better team punishes us by 2/3. Whilst they didnt have the clear cut chances, they definitely had clear opportunities to create chances.
Just in the first half... their winger down the right latched onto 2 balls in behind our defence, one of them was a 2 v 1 and De Ligt intercepted the pass..
There were other instances down the left they got in and just couldn't produce the final ball.
To say they had only long shots... is trying to paper over the cracks.
Agreed, this is a very good test to see if old habits come back or do they trust the system?
I guess Amorim will be stuck in 2 minds, to continue the teams progress and accept we could lose, or change it slightly and get a result? Remember where he said, he wishes to risk it for the long run? This is the game he is going to be tested.
Another one of those where we have 2 players with attributes that should be in 1 player.
Like these quotes. 4-0 result was bit flukey imo (not that we didn't deserve to win the game) so shouldn't get carried away. Amorim has been around for 3 weeks now and (if we're going into right direction) it'll take lot of time and also some frustrating results before we become better. Think this season will be more interesting in finding out how we'll play under him and perhaps going for it in Europa and cups if possible.
Indeed, wish we have another semi capable midfielder from our squad instead of going from one extreme to another. M gut feeling is Bruno in CM, we shall see.
I generally agree, first half I thought we were really poor but second we were good - although it's always easier when an opponent then chases the game because we have a front line that is good in transition. it is early days in a new system though so I think we wait at least a few more games before judging how well it's going.
What I would say about build up is that fielding an extra CB and now having Maz as well as Licha to receive the ball is a pretty mental upgrade on what we had before. De Ligt is also no slouch on the ball. If Shaw comes back and we can put out a back 5 of Shaw - Licha - De Ligt - Yoro - Maz it is an unbelievable change within on season. I would say technical abilities and athleticism were our main issues before, the latter is now the only think I think we're really lacking in.
Exactly. At this stage, he is just getting everyone minutes, working some players back in that have been unfit or completely out of form and seeing who may be able to fit into his system. Not easy doing that when there is 9 games in December.
Plus, we may see that he seems to prefer certain players over the next few months, but that doesnt mean they are going to be in his long term plans. Even on their best days, there are few of these United players that would have walked into Sportings team - certainly not from what they have been showing over the past couple of years. Can they adapt and reach the level of players like Goncalves, Gyokeres and Trincao - that is to be seen.
I think Mount or Mainoo with Ugarte is probably our most well rounded midfield as things stand.
Mainoo leaves us very open in a 2 man midfield.
Yes, i agree. Everton were crap.
Also, when they opposition is in rest defence, United dont seem to know how to move the ball from front to back. We are still seemingly aimlessly passing the ball back and forth across the back line. Our midfield two were not making themselves available. Hopefully that changes when Kobbie is upto speed as he is the only center mid we have that wants to take the ball in tight positions. I would like to see our back 3 move forward with the ball at feet to start attacks more. That will help open up space for others.