gooDevil
Worst scout ever
i vote we promote a couple newbies that will agree to post rawk quotes for us.
Roy's 20 PL games in charge of LFC - 25 points
Kenny's last 20 PL games in charge of LFC - 23 points
Careful, you might get banned for stating the facts.
This is the meltdown thread but this is a good post by Siannn.
The only downside to Andy leaving the ground early is that he knows the way back to Anfield.
simpsons handball is a yellow at worst. is these such thing as a red card handball?
I actually thought Kenny might walk a few weeks ago, fed up with the circus the club is becoming.
Perch is a dickhead, but it's modern football. Anyone who thinks Suarez wouldn't have done the same - or worse - is deluding themselves.
I think he's giving Andy more credit than he deserves. Still, he can afford a taxi.
I do. Yes, Reina was an idiot. But going down like you've been shot after your forehead has been brushed is disgusting.
Hand ball on the line = red card. Don't be a burke, mate.
If you say so, I didn't realize that, doesn't happen very often.
If you say so, I didn't realize that, doesn't happen very often. In Simpson's defense, he didn't move his arm, players often touch the post like that so it wasn't an arm raised on purpose to stop the ball.
I would think a defender doesn't have the right to put his arm up on the post like that, surely an unnatural position.
Is the idea that it's a yellow of the handball and another for denying the goal scoring opportunity?
I agree that was a definite peno.He moves his arm towards the ball, it's definitely handball. The red is for denying a goalscoring opportunity, yes.
He moves his arm towards the ball, it's definitely handball. The red is for denying a goalscoring opportunity, yes.
It didn't look that way to me, but I also wasn't that bothered to check it out that closely!
Let's say he didn't move his arm, is reaching out to feel the post an acceptable reason to raise an arm? I could see a defender reaching out to feel for the man he's marking and inadvertently getting a shot kicked against that outstretched arm. Since touching your opponent like that isn't against the rules, would it be a handball?
Seems fair to me. I thought Simpson's movement was him trying to get his shoulder on the ball and not quite making it, which caused his arm to move with his chest, didn't look to me like a man trying to use an arm illegally, or he would have used more of a swatting motion.
Very true - got booked for it though didn't he?
Yes, he did. There was still no need for it.
Totally agree - but have to say (and doesn't happen often) that the ref' got it spot on - Perch deserved the yellow for simulation and Reina the red for his "head-butt"
yeah, people keep dismissing the fact that Perch was punished. The referee knew he dived so that has nothing to do with it. The ref saw the headbutt and punished reina.
I honestly don't know, was Perch booked for simulation as everyone seems to be saying? I thought he was booked for the original trip on Reina that led to him turning round a confronting Perch.
he was not booked for simulation, but for the trip and confrontation.
The one I always remember is Nicky Butt against Barcelona. He got two red cards in a row, and the one against Barcelona was a handball on the line.Ask Kanchelskis
how do you know? did the ref say it?
The one I always remember is Nicky Butt against Barcelona. He got two red cards in a row, and the one against Barcelona was a handball on the line.
I'm struggling to remember who the other was against, but I'm sure I remember it being a big game too.