Paul Pogba

Status
Not open for further replies.
If we'd managed to keep him, this thread would probably now be about the inevitability of him leaving for somewhere like Madrid this summer.
 
Pretty sure thats an old quote just dug up from the media to take a dig at United. I read that interview before like a year ago.
 
I think City have a good shot at getting him. With Yaya Toure leaving they'll be desperate to land Pogba and will throw a fortune at both Juve and the player.
 
Pretty sure thats an old quote just dug up from the media to take a dig at United. I read that interview before like a year ago.

That story is about a year old. Rehashed crap. The media is getting worse.

Are you talking about Buffon's bit here? Because that's not a year old. It was earlier today/last night.
 
I think City have a good shot at getting him. With Yaya Toure leaving they'll be desperate to land Pogba and will throw a fortune at both Juve and the player.

You'd think that if he's willing to go to City then United and Chelsea would have a great chance too. Chelsea have the location and the team whereas despite League positions United look to be on a similar footing with City currently and can be said to have a younger more promising squad. I also don't believe Pogba holds it against us as a club more so than has a grip with Fergie.
 
Are you talking about Buffon's bit here? Because that's not a year old. It was earlier today/last night.

Its old.

Juve are desperate for him to remain in Turin and team-mate Buffon admits he cannot understand why Pogba was allowed to leave United in the first place.

"Pogba is one of those players who leaves you speechless," Buffon told TV show Tiki Taka.

"When he came we didn't know him but after only three or four training sessions we were impressed by his enormous qualities.

"My team-mates and me looked at each other as to say 'Are they blind in Manchester?' (to let him go away)."

Stemmed from this article at the start of 2014.

A lot of Pogba comments about Man Utd are old rehashed comments.
 
Its old.

Juve are desperate for him to remain in Turin and team-mate Buffon admits he cannot understand why Pogba was allowed to leave United in the first place.

"Pogba is one of those players who leaves you speechless," Buffon told TV show Tiki Taka.

"When he came we didn't know him but after only three or four training sessions we were impressed by his enormous qualities.

"My team-mates and me looked at each other as to say 'Are they blind in Manchester?' (to let him go away)."

Stemmed from this article at the start of 2014.

A lot of Pogba comments about Man Utd are old rehashed comments.
I stand corrected. It's odd, as F365 had it all over their front page, and a quick Google showed SkySports reporting it earlier today, Yahoo news etc.

Oh well.
 
It really does! Plenty of our players live the club & want to be there, Smalling opted for Unted over Arsenal whom he's supposed to support. Yet you name the fan boi favourites, as though they're a shining example. Personally I think Mata will be gone in the summer, but that's a whole new topic.

And if Pogba returns it'll be as he wants to play for United, he'd have plenty of other options & the decision will be his. So how exactly would he not want to be at United?
You seem to be fixating on Mata and Herrera too much here. Fair enough Smalling is another example. There are plenty of players that love United at the club and I don't think Pogba has the same connection. Obvioulsy if Pogba returns, it shows that he likes United but my point is he won't return, showing he doesn't have the same love as other players.
 
What is the relevance of re-earthing these old comments by Pirlo and Buffon? Someone is trying to pull something in the background. I reckon he will be off this summer.
 
If we'd managed to keep him, this thread would probably now be about the inevitability of him leaving for somewhere like Madrid this summer.

You're quite right I'm sure it would be. To be honest I'd be happier if that was the case because we could sell him for £60 million plus rather than leave for nothing.
 
No - it's not just that.

It's been 3 years since he's left. Buffon has just come out with a statement, on the eve of Juve making a CL final for the first time in 12(?) years. Surely, that'd be a better thing for Buffon to harp on about. Pirlo did the same earlier on in the season. The agent did it last year I think. And this isn't including Poggers' own comments.

It's just boring now.

Pogba's only had good things to say about us.
 
You seem to be fixating on Mata and Herrera too much here. Fair enough Smalling is another example. There are plenty of players that love United at the club and I don't think Pogba has the same connection. Obvioulsy if Pogba returns, it shows that he likes United but my point is he won't return, showing he doesn't have the same love as other players.

Fixating on players you brought up? simply pointing out the flaw in your logic, I did not bring them into the thread.

Go google some of the comments Pogba has made about United since leaving. Then you'll have a better understanding of how he feels about the club. Not what you think he feels.

I'll start you off....

“I love Man United,” he revealed. “I learned a lot there and they make me improve, and give me something to come here and play for Juventus.

“I thank Man United every day because I learned there, training with big players, which gave me experience to come here and get used to playing alongside big players like [Andrea] Pirlo, Arturo Vidal, [Claudio] Marchisio and [Gianluigi] Buffon.”
 
Fixating on players you brought up? simply pointing out the flaw in your logic, I did not bring them into the thread.

Go google some of the comments Pogba has made about United since leaving. Then you'll have a better understanding of how he feels about the club. Not what you think he feels.

I'll start you off....

“I love Man United,” he revealed. “I learned a lot there and they make me improve, and give me something to come here and play for Juventus.

“I thank Man United every day because I learned there, training with big players, which gave me experience to come here and get used to playing alongside big players like [Andrea] Pirlo, Arturo Vidal, [Claudio] Marchisio and [Gianluigi] Buffon.”

He also said he would never speak ill of us.
 
If we'd managed to keep him, this thread would probably now be about the inevitability of him leaving for somewhere like Madrid this summer.

This is the hard reality of the situation.
 
Under the current rules it just has to be 3 years before his 21st birthday that he is registered with a club in England or Wales, I do not think it has to be THE 3 years before his 21st birthday. It does not even have to be 3 years with the same club, just 3 years in total. So if a player signs for an English club right at the age of 16, stays until after he is 19 say. Then leaves for a club in another country, but comes back at some point, under the current rules he is still a home grown player.

That at least is how I remember it, I know when the rule first came into play there were all sorts of discussions about this. I used to have a link to the rules on the official Premier League website but it does not work anymore. But maybe they changed the rules since they first went into effect and I missed it.


EDIT:

Okay here is one link from last summer.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/...home-grown-rules-explaining-epl-player-quotas

It says the player only needs to spend a total of 36 months or 3 entire seasons registered with a club or clubs that belong to the FA or the FA of Wales. Included in this can be the season in which he turns 21.

Would have to look at the actual time Pogba spent with us, as I can't remember it off the top of my head.
October 09 to July 12 so not the required 36 months
 
Expect this thread to grow by a good chunk of pages tonight.

Carragher talking sense on the topic on Sky right now.
 
Fixating on players you brought up? simply pointing out the flaw in your logic, I did not bring them into the thread.

Go google some of the comments Pogba has made about United since leaving. Then you'll have a better understanding of how he feels about the club. Not what you think he feels.

I'll start you off....

“I love Man United,” he revealed. “I learned a lot there and they make me improve, and give me something to come here and play for Juventus.

“I thank Man United every day because I learned there, training with big players, which gave me experience to come here and get used to playing alongside big players like [Andrea] Pirlo, Arturo Vidal, [Claudio] Marchisio and [Gianluigi] Buffon.”
What are you on about???? THE PLAYERS AREN'T IMPORTANT!.....I simply mentioned two players who seem to love it at United. Throw Smalling in there, Jones, Shaw...whoever ya want.
He also had some not so flattering comments about Fergie.
So hows about ya lose the attitude and keep your opinions to yourself if ya can't be civil. You're the one that replied to my comment in the first place if ya haven't forgotten.
 
What's he saying?
He was asked in a leading way whether United would regret the way they handled the situation and he basically said it's not that simple, the player was making demands above his station and that you gave to have policies in these situations and giving in can have a knock-on effect on other players etc.

Said LVG would undoubtedly love to have him as part of his squad, but that it's easy to say with hindsight and you can't just say it was a mistake.
 
Loved watching him develop in our youth team. Gutted when it became clear he was leaving.

Have seen lots of quotes but nothing direct from his mouth so I cant judge how he feels about us as a club with any accuracy. However if he does come back to our city but as a blue he will have to put up with a lot of shit off of the pitch, thats for sure. He only needs to ask Tevez what that is like. Not vey nice at all.

Whatever happens he's just a another player and United will still be great along time after Paul Pogba is forgotten.
 
Aye, he's not (yet) worth the figures being quoted.

But saying that, he might just pop up with a spectacular.

Have to agree. He's not really able to get involved.

Have to say he looks to have all the tools but looks a bit hit and miss. I think it would be unwise for a City or similar to blow their budget on him. He'd be under huge pressure to perform.
 
Pogba is worth 2p. Everytime I see him play I think what's the hype? A hit and miss player - City welcome to him.
 
Have to agree. He's not really able to get involved.

Have to say he looks to have all the tools but looks a bit hit and miss. I think it would be unwise for a City or similar to blow their budget on him. He'd be under huge pressure to perform.
Yeah, he'd thrive in Yaya's best role IMO - behind the striker. But yeah, he's a tad too inconsistent if you consider they're talking about world record transfer fees (or in that range).

Get in. 1-1.
 
Just as I slag him off, he sorta gets involved in their goal:lol:

Mind - still think he's hit and miss.
 
According to my sources, Pogba will join manutd in the summer. His agent mino raiola was seen having a chat with Woodward a few days ago


dreams do come true...i hope.
 
It's crazy to draw conclusions from a rusty performance returning from injury against one of the best sides in Europe.
 
It's crazy to draw conclusions from a rusty performance returning from injury against one of the best sides in Europe.

I've watched him a few times and I've never really seen him do anything in terms of running a game that I'd expect for £60 or £70 million.

That being said, I don't watch Juve or France fanatically so I'm not going to make snap judgments and others rate him highly so fair enough. For that kind of transfer fee though he'll be expected to be the star man most weeks.
 
Last edited:
I've watched him a few times abc I've never really seen him do anything in terms of running a game that I'd expect for £60 or £70 million.

That being said, I don't watch Juve or France fanatically so I'm not going to make snap judgments and others rate him highly so fair enough. For that kind of transfer fee though he'll be expected to be the star man most weeks.
abc?
 
Pogba is worth 2p. Everytime I see him play I think what's the hype? A hit and miss player - City welcome to him.

He wont go to City. He will go to a big club like Madrid or Bayern.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.