Next permanent manager | Poll updated

Who should be the next permanent manager?

  • Luis Enrique

    Votes: 113 7.4%
  • Erik ten Hag

    Votes: 1,300 84.7%
  • Julen Lopetegui

    Votes: 10 0.7%
  • Mauricio Pochettino

    Votes: 79 5.1%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 32 2.1%

  • Total voters
    1,534
Status
Not open for further replies.
Poisoned chalice this job.
Whomever decides to join I can't see them winning anything.
 
True, it is a gamble. But, many people on here were/are so confident that ETH will be our next savior, but I don't see how they can justify that opinion based on his time at Ajax. I have seen no credible evidence other than he has a good philosophy that he should be the ideal candidate. Poch, luis Enrique, ancellotti, nagelsman, tuchel, are all more qualified than ETH for this position. The premier league and handling huge ego is another level compared to managing Ajax. I love ETH philosophy, but people might be in for a shock similiar to Ralf if ETH becomes our manager. And before, I get quoted in the future, I believe that he may win us a trophy like van gaal, and mourinho did, but it is hard to see him taking us back to the united glory days unless he hit the jackpot with great signings.

Bringing in Ancelotti would depress the shit out of me and indicate the club has no idea how bad a mess things are.

I can't imagine Nagelsmann leaving Bayern anytime soon.

Tuchel I guess could, that would be fine, but I'd gamble on Ten Hag as likelier to bring in youth and not take shortcuts but look to rebuild the squad.

Luis Enrique could work, but his teams at Barca weren't as cohesive as Pep's and more reliant. But I think there's a path to it working potentially. Doesn't hurt that he works with lots of players who play hard and with skill and aren't at massive clubs yet like Pau Torres, Soler, Merino, Porro, Olmo and Yeremy who might well all start for us if we bought them tomorrow.
 
Guys, Ten Hag will do wonders here.
A proper coach can change EVERYTHING.

I’m giving you a local example. My bulgarian team Levski Sofia was in a dire state for 6-7 years. The absolute bottom was reached with an ex player as coach for season and a half, he turned us into a laughing stock.
We finally managed to get Stanimir Stoilov - one of the best bulgarian coaches in the last two decades, the same coach who led us to Champions League group stage and 1/4 final in UEFA cup back in 2006 and 2007.
Even with the club in financial crisis and no expensive players in the team, Stoilov transformed us completely in just 5 months or so. Our football is improving by the minute, we look so much better and dangerous, players we thought were amateurs are putting in great performances week after week. We win game after game, drew against our biggest rivals and actually outplayed Ludogorets (they are kinda the bulgarian Bayern Munich atm - winning everything and buying whoever they want) away in our last game against them (despite unlucky 2-1 loss because of GK error.).
The only factor creating the new and good face of Levski is the coach!

This will happen to United I’m 100% convinced.
Get Ten Hag in and watch us become great again.

Thanks for giving us hope. We really need this. Hope ETH will have the same effects like when Klopp took over Liverpool. Clear improvement and entertaining modern attacking football right from the start.
 
Guys, Ten Hag will do wonders here.
A proper coach can change EVERYTHING.

I’m giving you a local example. My bulgarian team Levski Sofia was in a dire state for 6-7 years. The absolute bottom was reached with an ex player as coach for season and a half, he turned us into a laughing stock.
We finally managed to get Stanimir Stoilov - one of the best bulgarian coaches in the last two decades, the same coach who led us to Champions League group stage and 1/4 final in UEFA cup back in 2006 and 2007.
Even with the club in financial crisis and no expensive players in the team, Stoilov transformed us completely in just 5 months or so. Our football is improving by the minute, we look so much better and dangerous, players we thought were amateurs are putting in great performances week after week. We win game after game, drew against our biggest rivals and actually outplayed Ludogorets (they are kinda the bulgarian Bayern Munich atm - winning everything and buying whoever they want) away in our last game against them (despite unlucky 2-1 loss because of GK error.).
The only factor creating the new and good face of Levski is the coach!

This will happen to United I’m 100% convinced.
Get Ten Hag in and watch us become great again.
The manager in your example doesn't have to deal with a group of entitled multimillionaire ego maniacs, and a board whose primary objective is to strengthen the commercial appeal of the club. Ten Hag is going to encounter so many hurdles and barriers at United. Players like Rashford, Maguire, Shaw and McTominay will be forced on him as they're the British core. Washed up star players will be signed against his wishes, because it generates likes on social media. We're as much of a circus as a football club and there's certainly no guarantees regardless of which manager comes in. Don't get me wrong, I want us to hire him. But I'm not going to delude myself into believing he's the magic bullet. Realistically he'll be sacked within 2 years and we'll be left with a slightly different group of overpaid wasters.
 
Yesterday the commentators were almost pitying us. Like one day one manager will crack it. Hopefully ETH cracks it. We should back him with whatever decision he takes regarding the squad. No more starboy or captain fantastic treatment.
 
Players like Rashford, Maguire, Shaw and McTominay will be forced on him as they're the British core.

Yup like Neville yesterday.
These United pundits have inflicted irreparable damage to the club and its about time the club stops listening to them and thinking they represent the opinions of the fanbase.
 
True, it is a gamble. But, many people on here were/are so confident that ETH will be our next savior, but I don't see how they can justify that opinion based on his time at Ajax. I have seen no credible evidence other than he has a good philosophy that he should be the ideal candidate. Poch, luis Enrique, ancellotti, nagelsman, tuchel, are all more qualified than ETH for this position. The premier league and handling huge ego is another level compared to managing Ajax. I love ETH philosophy, but people might be in for a shock similiar to Ralf if ETH becomes our manager. And before, I get quoted in the future, I believe that he may win us a trophy like van gaal, and mourinho did, but it is hard to see him taking us back to the united glory days unless he hit the jackpot with great signings.
He’s the only one that went in and said that he didn’t need to make a multitude of signings whilst detailing his plan. We need to change from this attitude that money fixes everything as far as teams go. We need a coach with a plan.
from reading more and more about his methods im convinced that he’s the strongest candidate. PL experience shouldn’t even be a thing, many have come before to do great jobs, such as wenger and Klopp for example but also the likes of Hussenthal
 


Struggling to care about this really. Sign who we can and promote players from the academy. There are about 2-3 players currently in the first team picture who I would care about keeping, the rest can get fecked as far as I’m concerned (Yes I know that is not realistic)
 
Struggling to care about this really. Sign who we can and promote players from the academy. There are about 2-3 players currently in the first team picture who I would care about keeping, the rest can get fecked as far as I’m concerned (Yes I know that is not realistic)
Something has to give and if 11 players leave it would actually be doing us a favour and give the new manager more time in the job as we'd all be of the understanding he has to build a new team and be given time to do so.

If the squad isn't cleared out the new manager has been handed a poisoned chalice anyway. These players can't win anything as a collective but the expectation is still there.
 
Something has to give and if 11 players leave it would actually be doing us a favour and give the new manager more time in the job as we'd all be of the understanding he has to build a new team and be given time to do so.

If the squad isn't cleared out the new manager has been handed a poisoned chalice anyway. These players can't win anything as a collective but the expectation is still there.
I will give them time. Unfortunately a lot of those players listed are options off the bench or non options to be honest, which is likely why Ole did not make subs as most of them couldn't change a bed nevermind a game.
 
I will give them time. Unfortunately a lot of those players listed are options off the bench or non options to be honest, which is likely why Ole did not make subs as most of them couldn't change a bed nevermind a game.
Yep, I agree but they're certainly adding to this negative culture around the club. We often hear about defenders who can't get a game, so Bailly basically, moaning about Maguire being super shit and him still not getting a start. We just need to clear them all out and build a first 11 that's backed up by younger, hungry players on the bench who want to dislodge the established players.
 
It's actually quite surreal how many players I'd happily never see play for us again. I thought I had a low opinion of the squad under LVG/Jose but bloody hell, it's really hit rock bottom now. It would be a blessing for the new manager if half of them were gone in the summer.
 
Correct , Ten Hag would be wise to steer clear , coming to United could seriously damage his career.
I struggle to understand this kind of thinking. If you are ambitious and know you are good enough, why would you shy away from a job like United. If he turns it around then he will be remembered for generations.
 
It’s obviously a massive task with huge rewards for someone who can find the ‘secret sauce for success’ - but it’s going to take the Glazers releasing an awful lot of money (purely with regards to the player turnover.
 
I struggle to understand this kind of thinking. If you are ambitious and know you are good enough, why would you shy away from a job like United. If he turns it around then he will be remembered for generations.
Knowing he is good enough may be conditional. I mean, what person is so good that they can be successful under literally any circumstances? If he can see there will be issues working with the United board that will make it difficult for him to succeed, it wouldn't be through lack of ambition or self-confidence that he'd turn the job down, it'd be looking out for his best interests.
 
Correct , Ten Hag would be wise to steer clear , coming to United could seriously damage his career.
You may be right but a proper manager who backs himself would take our job in a heartbeat. We’re at rock bottom and in need of a rebuild with cash to spend. A top manager with time should be able to turn us around. And if they can’t do it there not a top manager!
 
He must have missed the disaster performances vs Watford away, Liverpool home and City both home and away. Our season unravelled before it began, we haven't got going at all this season.
He’s a v reliable journalist though, so the fact his article is weighted in favour of Poch is a big concern. These rhetorics aren’t going away.
 
I think we’ll see an announcement this week, the club is at rock rock bottom , we’re one result away from literally everyone walking away from this season even if it is mathematically possible to make top 4, I think personally I am there myself already.

I think officially it’s a couple mill but we’ll offer them more as a sweetener and announcing it early.

Ajax pretty much have won the league anyway.
 
The board need to make it clear to the players that if any player or member of their entourage leak teams, stories to the press, they will be sold. They need to take a strong stance on this and back the managers decisions.
 
It’s obviously a massive task with huge rewards for someone who can find the ‘secret sauce for success’ - but it’s going to take the Glazers releasing an awful lot of money (purely with regards to the player turnover.
As much hate as there is for the Glazers, it's not like they have consistently failed to back their chosen managers. Van Gaal spent god knows how much on ADM, Jose spent £90m on Pogba, Ole wasted £80m on Maguire.

The bigger issue is their inability to install a structure that knows how to spend the money properly. Hopefully with Woodward gone, Rangnick providing direction on acquisitions, and a manager with a clear vision of their style of play and the attributes a player needs to have to fit that style, we can start turning that corner. The only problem is it will take some time to undo all of the damage done by Woodward over the past few years.

Getting our wages on a par with the other top teams in the league and clearing out the deadwood, overpaid prima donnas, and workshy instagram apologists will be a big step in the right direction, coupled with the aquisition of hungry, young talented players who are ready to work their bollocks off. From Ralfs quotes yesterday he seems very clear on what needs to be done.
 
The board need to make it clear to the players that if any player or member of their entourage leak teams, stories to the press, they will be sold. They need to take a strong stance on this and back the managers decisions.

Yep and I hope the club didn’t consult with our players on the new manager either
 
You only have to look at what the new celtic manager is doing that shows the difference when a good manager comes in. Makes changes to the side and stamps his style on the team. He demands the work and picks players that will deliver it.

If ETH comes in and builds his own team then we'll improve.

If he sticks with them then it's rinse and repeat.
 
Starting to think that the task ahead to rebuild this club is so big now that only Klopp, Guardiola and Nagelsmann would have a shot at succeeding. Ten Hag is a great coach but this job may well overwhelm him.
 
Cavani, mata, lingaard and pogba are definites to leave. Ronaldo probably if he can find a club who can offer CL next season.

I'm personally happy for "big names" to go. Would like ten hag in, back him in the window with the young hungry players he likes to work with and who fit his philosophy and go from there.

Ideally jones and martial would leave, but as usual they are paid well and may not want a paycut.
 
Starting to think that the task ahead to rebuild this club is so big now that only Klopp, Guardiola and Nagelsmann would have a shot at succeeding. Ten Hag is a great coach but this job may well overwhelm him.

One window away from looking much better. Not easy for me to be positive right now but sometimes football can change super quick!

I think losing so many unmotivated players, having a disciplinarian and hopefully a good transfer window could have us looking dramatically better relatively quickly. Only one way to find out.
 
It's actually quite surreal how many players I'd happily never see play for us again. I thought I had a low opinion of the squad under LVG/Jose but bloody hell, it's really hit rock bottom now. It would be a blessing for the new manager if half of them were gone in the summer.
Not one player I’d be upset over them leaving. Zero.
 
You only have to look at what the new celtic manager is doing that shows the difference when a good manager comes in. Makes changes to the side and stamps his style on the team. He demands the work and picks players that will deliver it.

If ETH comes in and builds his own team then we'll improve.

If he sticks with them then it's rinse and repeat.
I don't know much about them but it looks like they brought in 6/7 new regular starters last summer. That's the kind of overhaul we need, without it it will just be more of the same whoever we bring in.
 
If we've got Ten Hag in charge and we've made some promising signings, and you still feel like that, honestly I'd just give up on football, its not for you anymore. The amount of misery on here is stupendous, and if I still have to deal with it and we've got something to be hopeful about its going to be such a drain.

It won't be the first season we get a manager we think will be good enough and sign promising players. What's much different between this and the previous 8 years?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.