Morgan Schneiderlin | BBC: Morgan Schneiderlin is currently having a medical at Manchester United.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carrick and Schneiderlin in a midfield two would be my prefered choice if both were fit, but i realise he would be meant for Carrick's position. I see him more as a defensive box-to-box midfielder, but he can definitely also play the holding position. It's going to be interesting seeing how it all pans out, first and foremost we need to get this deal done, still not sure at all we have this guy in the bag yet.
 
morg_2086875a.jpg

Ugly. Don't want :(
 
A midfield three of:
Schneiderlin - Herrera
--------Carrick---------

:drool:

I'm not too fussed about any single combination.

There's plenty of quality, choice, rotation and cover if you have Carrick, Bastian, Schneiderlin, Herrera, Fellaini and depending how you want to play, Di Maria and Mata too to choose from.
 
Is Schneiderlin actually that good though ? I always feel that Southampton play a system which suits all their defensive players and they all kind of look better than they actually are.
 
What a signing Schneiderlin would be. I hope the news of us signing him is true as he's one of the best defensive midfielders around at the moment and is proven in the Premiership. I would like to see us go for Schweinsteiger too though just to have extra cover in the midfield and let's be honest, If Schweinsteiger is available at decent price you can't pass on that.
 
Really excited about this. I was annoyed that we didn't even seem to be interested earlier on. It seemed like Arsenal was a done deal. Really hope we get him.
 
Did Arsenal's reported interest cool or what? Felt like they were front runners for his signature for a long time.
 
Yeah!!! Although nothing reliable happened today on this front, I am going to bed with a positive feeling. Hope Woody prepares a beautiful bid until tomorrow morning. Also morning = Morgen (in German) which almost equals Morgan. Clear positive sign as far as I am concerned.

Not bothered with tonight's Copa game, good night!
 
------------------------Rooney-------------
--SchweinsTiger------Mata--------Di Maria
--------------Schniederlin---Carrick------
---Shaw----Otamendi-----Ramos---Valencia

...?
 
------------------------Rooney-------------
--SchweinsTiger------Mata--------Di Maria
--------------Schniederlin---Carrick------
---Shaw----Otamendi-----Ramos---Valencia

...?
Feck right off with that. Might as well not sign him if you are going to use him like that and put two true wingers with real pace on the bench.
 
Is Schneiderlin actually that good though ? I always feel that Southampton play a system which suits all their defensive players and they all kind of look better than they actually are.

Dig out the video of his performance v Chelsea at Stamford Bridge and there is your answer
 
------------------------Rooney-------------
--SchweinsTiger------Mata--------Di Maria
--------------Schniederlin---Carrick------
---Shaw----Otamendi-----Ramos---Valencia

...?
LW? Go to bed.
 
Arteta has not played a game for us since November. Rumor is he may quietly retire this summer and become a coach. Even if he is fit to play again, he was in rapid decline before his injury and is not at the required standard anymore and neither is Flamini.

If I'm being honest, Coquelin is probably the only midfielder we have who is good enough to start and loves defending. Ramsey/Wilshere constantly abandon to central midfield area which leads to Coquelin having to make a lot of interceptions and tackles to compensate, which inflates his statistics. However Coquelin is an average passer at best, so Wenger has had to stick Cazorla in central midfield. This allows us to get our passing game going and Cazorla is good with the ball at his feet so won't get dispossessed.

Schneiderlin is good defensively and can pass the ball a bit so if we brought him in, we would be able to use one player instead of the two we do currently and this would allow Ramsey to return to his central midfield position instead of out on the right.


quite right this. though i can see arsenal going for a more defensive CDM like wanyama or carvalho
 
GK
NewRB Ramos Smalling Blind/Shaw
Schneidy Carrick/Schweiny
Mata Herrera Depay
NewSTR
I like this one. Possibly playing Di Maria instead of Mata depending on who's playing better, or having Herrera play deeper, Di Maria play out wide and Mata behind the striker when Carrick is inevitably injured.
 
He's a good player. Not exactly a world class signing, but maybe he'll fit well into one of our round holes as a round peg.

I wouldn't count on us challenging for the title yet, with signings like Memphis and Morgan. At least not in the coming season.

I'm not ecstatic about this signing, just relieved that we signed someone in the midfield.

His chances of coming good are reasonable, but it is still a gamble.

24 million, if true, is a little high for Schneiderlin. Hopefully, it'll prove not to be too high.
 
He's a good player. Not exactly a world class signing, but maybe he'll fit well into one of our round holes as a round peg.

I wouldn't count on us challenging for the title yet, with signings like Memphis and Morgan. At least not in the coming season.

I'm not ecstatic about this signing, just relieved that we signed someone in the midfield.

His chances of coming good are reasonable, but it is still a gamble.

24 million, if true, is a little high for Schneiderlin. Hopefully, it'll prove not to be too high.
With all due respect, I think you underestimate him slightly. He is a very good player.
 
I think Schneiderlin is as good now as Carrick was when we bought him from Spurs (obviously slightly different type of player).
 
With all due respect, I think you underestimate him slightly. He is a very good player.
He was the backbone of Koeman's Southampton. But, I have noticed that his defensive play is very reliant on a particular system. He needs others around him. Also, his attacking, in terms of his passing range, isn't the greatest.

He may become a great player with United. But, as of now, I think he's just above average.
 
Think he's the 2nd best defensive midfielder in the Prem, only behind Matic, he'd be a really good addition to the squad.
Good fee for him as well, in a world where people are talking of Kane for 50mill+
 
Status
Not open for further replies.