Messi v Ronaldo | Contains double your daily salt allowance

Messi or Ronaldo

  • Messi

  • Ronaldo


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I always tend get annoyed by the arguments why Messi is better then Ronaldo. (and vica versa)

People rate Messi mostly for his dribbles and passing. Yet, why is this more important then aerial strength, his skills, speed and positioning, shot, strength? Sure one is more entertaining then the other but its kind of biased isn't it?

Benzema's dribble and passing is far superior to that of Drogba in his prime. Is Benzema a better player then Drogba who scored more, was godlike in the air and has phenomenal strength and positioning?

The one who performs best at the end and wins the titles is the best player in the world for me. Not the one who can dribble, longshot, do tricks the best.

Messi is edging it atm, but lets be honest here he was absolutely invisible for 77 minutes tonight, yet people act like he played fantastic.

:lol:
 
I always tend get annoyed by the arguments why Messi is better then Ronaldo. (and vica versa)

People rate Messi mostly for his dribbles and passing. Yet, why is this more important then aerial strength, his skills, speed and positioning, shot, strength? Sure one is more entertaining then the other but its kind of biased isn't it?

Benzema's dribble and passing is far superior to that of Drogba in his prime. Is Benzema a better player then Drogba who scored more, was godlike in the air and has phenomenal strength and positioning?

The one who performs best at the end and wins the titles is the best player in the world for me. Not the one who can dribble, longshot, do tricks the best.

Messi is edging it atm, but lets be honest here he was absolutely invisible for 77 minutes tonight, yet people act like he played fantastic.
In the first half he did some nice dribblings, I mean, he participated in the game, not like Bale the day before, and he performed best at the end, assuring the final for his team. Maradona was not good with the head or with the right foot but is still Maradona
 
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and it's really sad that you all are harassing Cal? for standing up for what he believes in. I too know ronaldo is better overall and it's not only for his performance in La Liga. He has excelled in 2 different leagues as compared to Messi who has only been stuck in one league. Ronaldo is a predator in the air. Has Messi even ever score from a header ? Ronaldo is a beast where free kicks are concerned. He's also much faster than Messi. You all keep saying he's older than Messi, I would like to see how well Messi performs when he's Ronaldo's age.
Ronaldo was cultivated on English soil in the English league so that ultimately makes him better in my opinion. He's also a former Red and even though he can be a twat at times I'll always respect him as a player for that. Isn't he better internationally also. I'm not sure but I think he has more international goals than Messi ? Correct me if I'm wrong.
1. Messi has made our League look like a joke on multiple occasions, 4 goals against Arse, destroyed us in several finals, made City look like a pub team etc.
2.Considering you're a United fan it's surprising you don't remember his header against VDS, one of many he's scored in his career. So yes, he has scored headers.
3.Ronaldo's FK conversion rate as of late is terrible, how often does he actually score them :lol:
 
In the first half he did some nice dribblings, I mean, he participated in the game, not like Bale the day before, and he performed best at the end, assuring the final for his team. Maradona was not good with the head or with the right foot but is still Maradona

You are probably the only sensible one on here (Team Ronaldo).
 
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and it's really sad that you all are harassing Cal? for standing up for what he believes in. I too know ronaldo is better overall and it's not only for his performance in La Liga. He has excelled in 2 different leagues as compared to Messi who has only been stuck in one league. Ronaldo is a predator in the air. Has Messi even ever score from a header ? Ronaldo is a beast where free kicks are concerned. He's also much faster than Messi. You all keep saying he's older than Messi, I would like to see how well Messi performs when he's Ronaldo's age.
Ronaldo was cultivated on English soil in the English league so that ultimately makes him better in my opinion. He's also a former Red and even though he can be a twat at times I'll always respect him as a player for that. Isn't he better internationally also. I'm not sure but I think he has more international goals than Messi ? Correct me if I'm wrong.

CL final, 08.
 
You are probably the only sensible one on here (Team Ronaldo).
thanks, the truth is that it breaks my heart that our greatest rival has been lucky enough to find Messi. I used to dream with some Figo situation :drool: . I imagine reading my negative post against Messi within 20 years and I´d feel as a weird, but in the other hand I am very happy with Cristiano, yesterday he equaled Di Stéfano with 307 goals , doing it in 6 years!. If they were born at different times what Cristiano does would be more valued
 
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and it's really sad that you all are harassing Cal? for standing up for what he believes in. I too know ronaldo is better overall and it's not only for his performance in La Liga. He has excelled in 2 different leagues as compared to Messi who has only been stuck in one league. Ronaldo is a predator in the air. Has Messi even ever score from a header ? Ronaldo is a beast where free kicks are concerned. He's also much faster than Messi. You all keep saying he's older than Messi, I would like to see how well Messi performs when he's Ronaldo's age.
Ronaldo was cultivated on English soil in the English league so that ultimately makes him better in my opinion. He's also a former Red and even though he can be a twat at times I'll always respect him as a player for that. Isn't he better internationally also. I'm not sure but I think he has more international goals than Messi ? Correct me if I'm wrong.
:lol: I'm sorry but you're so clutching
 
Seriously those who say he was invisible for 77 mins (fortunately there aren't too many of them) should really quit watching football altogether.
 
Seriously those who say he was invisible for 77 mins (fortunately there aren't too many of them) should really quit watching football altogether.
Yeah that's just nuts. In that case it was a terrible game till the 77th minute. And if that game was terrible for 77 minutes then football isn't for you.
 
I always tend get annoyed by the arguments why Messi is better then Ronaldo. (and vica versa)

People rate Messi mostly for his dribbles and passing. Yet, why is this more important then aerial strength, his skills, speed and positioning, shot, strength? Sure one is more entertaining then the other but its kind of biased isn't it?

Benzema's dribble and passing is far superior to that of Drogba in his prime. Is Benzema a better player then Drogba who scored more, was godlike in the air and has phenomenal strength and positioning?

The one who performs best at the end and wins the titles is the best player in the world for me. Not the one who can dribble, longshot, do tricks the best.

Messi is edging it atm, but lets be honest here he was absolutely invisible for 77 minutes tonight, yet people act like he played fantastic.

Dribbling breaks defenses down by taking defenders out of the equation and forcing other defenders to leave their position. Vision leads to a lot of dangerous attacks. How is that not more important than what you listed (aerial strength as Messi has everything else you listed too)?

Those aren't tricks. Since when is passing, vision, and dribbling just tricks?


That's just crazy. I wonder what people think of Hazard who uses his dribbling, and vision to win his team games? Do people consider Chicha as good or better than Hazard because he can score as many goals and has better aerial ability and only consider the rest of Hazard's game to consist of nothing, but tricks and flashiness?
 
No I'm not I'm just stating why I prefer Ronaldo over Messi. It's a valid reason isn't it ?
1. Two different leagues - irrelevant. He plays in probably the best league in the game. Why would he leave? Is sir sir lesser for not moving from England?
2. Has he scored from headers? Only as far back as his last la Liga game.
3. "Ronaldo was cultivated in English soil and that makes him better. "What?!

I don't care for this comparison and getting involved in it properly, but people should at least post proper reasons. The third is just..
 
1. Messi has made our League look like a joke on multiple occasions, 4 goals against Arse, destroyed us in several finals, made City look like a pub team etc.
2.Considering you're a United fan it's surprising you don't remember his header against VDS, one of many he's scored in his career. So yes, he has scored headers.
3.Ronaldo's FK conversion rate as of late is terrible, how often does he actually score them :lol:
I was obviously being sarcastic about the header. He did score a few but not as many as Ronaldo. His conversion rate may but be as good at the moment but his accuracy and technique is better than Messi's.
Of course Barca had notable victories over the PL teams but it's not only Messi who's a quality player on that team. He had plenty support, he didn't do it all by himself.
 
1. Two different leagues - irrelevant. He plays in probably the best league in the game. Why would he leave? Is sir sir lesser for not moving from England?
2. Has he scored from headers? Only as far back as his last la Liga game.
3. "Ronaldo was cultivated in English soil and that makes him better. "What?!

I don't care for this comparison and getting involved in it properly, but people should at least post proper reasons. The third is just..
Adapting to different style of play also contributes to a player's quality. That's just my opinion you might think that it doesn't and that's your right. In not going to try ti change your mind and you're not going to change mine.
 
I was obviously being sarcastic about the header. He did score a few but not as many as Ronaldo. His conversion rate may but be as good at the moment but his accuracy and technique is better than Messi's.
Of course Barca had notable victories over the PL teams but it's not only Messi who's a quality player on that team. He had plenty support, he didn't do it all by himself.
It really isn't, Ronaldo rarely hits the target. He's gotten worse at them with each passing season
 
No facts that all the Messi fans bus want to ignore because it's cool to be on the Messi bandwagon. At the hack of your mind you'll always know Ronaldo is just as good.
Except he obviously isn't. And I've never actually felt he was, even when I was biased against Messi and towards Ronaldo. Anyways, I'm not getting dragging into this comparison! I really find it tedious.

My point was that the reasons should be relevant and meaningful. That's all.
 
Adapting to different style of play also contributes to a player's quality. That's just my opinion you might think that it doesn't and that's your right. In not going to try ti change your mind and you're not going to change mine.

Adapting to a different playstyle? Just look at the role Ronaldo play for Real Madrid and United during his peak years. He plays the exact same way since 2008. He has total freedom to go everywhere, but starts from the wing. He gets into good scoring positions and finishes as good as anyone. Ronaldo didn't have to adapt his playstyle. It's not like he's playing in a possession based team with a different role.


No facts that all the Messi fans boys choose to ignore because it's cool to be on the Messi bandwagon. At the back of your mind you'll always know Ronaldo is just as good.

I think Messi is better because he is better. I'm not a fan boy and try to be as objective as I can be. I have no problem praising rival players. A lot of us have no reason to prefer Messi over Ronaldo considering Ronaldo was a United player and helped us win titles. A fact is a fact. If Messi was a dick who bit players and was racist it still wouldn't change my mind because all of that is irrelevant. I don't take Ronaldo's antics into account and nobody should either.
 
Adapting to a different playstyle? Just look at the role Ronaldo play for Real Madrid and United during his peak years. He plays the exact same way since 2008. He has total freedom to go everywhere, but starts from the wing. He gets into good scoring positions and finishes as good as anyone. Ronaldo didn't have to adapt his playstyle. It's not like he's playing in a possession based team with a different role.




I think Messi is better because he is better. I'm not a fan boy and try to be as objective as I can be. I have no problem praising rival players. A lot of us have no reason to prefer Messi over Ronaldo considering Ronaldo was a United player and helped us win titles. A fact is a fact. If Messi was a dick who bit players and was racist it still wouldn't change my mind because all of that is irrelevant. I don't take Ronaldo's antics into account and nobody should either.
The premier league is a much more physical league. More hard tackles more aggressive. That's what I meant by adapting. I don't think Messi will shine in the English league the way Ronaldo did. He's like a one trick pony who excels at familiarity. Barca is the only place he will ever shine.
 
The premier league is a much more physical league. More hard tackles more aggressive. That's what I meant by adapting. I don't think Messi will shine in the English league the way Ronaldo did. He's like a one trick pony who excels at familiarity. Barca is the only place he will ever shine.

Players less good and less strong on the ball than Messi have been successful in England (David Silva being the best example) so Messi would have no pb in the very tough and "physical" PL. Are you really serious ?
 
The premier league is a much more physical league. More hard tackles more aggressive. That's what I meant by adapting. I don't think Messi will shine in the English league the way Ronaldo did. He's like a one trick pony who excels at familiarity. Barca is the only place he will ever shine.
I mean, come on now, it's not even funny.
 
Players less good and less strong on the ball than Messi have been successful in England (David Silva being the best example) so Messi would have no pb in the very tough and "physical" PL. Are you really serious ?
Well we'll never know. We can only speculate. All I'm saying is respect to Ronaldo for proving he can excel in more than one league. we don't have to speculate because he's been there and done that.
 
I'm out of this. Not getting involved in this shit throwing fest.
 
When someone compares the Messi and Ronaldo debate to Drogba and Benzema (WTF) you really shouldn't take them seriously.

You are stupid beyond belief.

All im doing is naming 2 other players with completely different play styles. Purely Indicating that although Benzema makes far more entertaining plays, he is nowhere near as efficient as Drogba.

So im asking the question to the non retarded readers (which seems to be close to 0) in this thread, that why Messi is better in their eyes. Because they seem to value entertainment more then efficiency when calling someone "the best".
 
You are stupid beyond belief.

All im doing is naming 2 other players with completely different play styles. Purely Indicating that although Benzema makes far more entertaining plays, he is nowhere near as efficient as Drogba.

So im asking the question to the non retarded readers (which seems to be close to 0) in this thread, that why Messi is better in their eyes. Because they seem to value entertainment more then efficiency when calling someone "the best".

It's not like Messi isn't "efficient" though is it ? He generates more goals and chances than Ronaldo. So he's more efficient and definitely more pleasing on the eye. If that doesn't make him better, what could ?
 
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and it's really sad that you all are harassing Cal? for standing up for what he believes in. I too know ronaldo is better overall and it's not only for his performance in La Liga. He has excelled in 2 different leagues as compared to Messi who has only been stuck in one league. Ronaldo is a predator in the air. Has Messi even ever score from a header ? Ronaldo is a beast where free kicks are concerned. He's also much faster than Messi. You all keep saying he's older than Messi, I would like to see how well Messi performs when he's Ronaldo's age.
Ronaldo was cultivated on English soil in the English league so that ultimately makes him better in my opinion. He's also a former Red and even though he can be a twat at times I'll always respect him as a player for that. Isn't he better internationally also. I'm not sure but I think he has more international goals than Messi ? Correct me if I'm wrong.

:lol:

That's an impossible thing to 'know' as it doesn't exist. It's not reality. It's your very very minority-based opinion.

Any neutral non-Barca or Real/United fan will tell you Messi is the superior player. Anyone who watches them both respectively will confirm this for you.

But please, rationalise your opinion and explain why and how exactly Ronaldo is superior. Keeping in him he cannot dribble, pass, has vision, dictate tempo, shoot from distance, score free-kicks, track-back, tackle and assist like Messi. Though I guess he can jump higher, is lazier and is far better looking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.