Have to admit it: I was very jealous when City got Pep. Always been a massive fan of his and the way his team play. Thought he would've been perfect at United. His start only served to emphasis that for me. City in so many games were really unplayable. They tore us to shreds at OT and were cruising in those early months.
However, what did surprise me was the way Pep reacted when they eventually ran into difficulties. It was completely bizarre. He essentially threw the strategy out the window and reverted to players like Yaya, Zabaleta, Kolarov and Caballero to steady the ship. It worked for a bit but it was never going to last. These players are finished and need to be moved on. Toure can go 80-85 minutes without doing anything these days. He went with these players and didn't trust the players he had brought in e.g. Sane, Nolito, Gundogan. In my opinion, he should've kept faith with the new players he brought in and tried to focus more on improving on the defensive side of their game. When they hit rough patches in games just park the bus. Instead he's changes way too much and those players look so confused as to the approach and tactics for each game.
He's doubted himself and just reverted that City side to type and it was a massive mistake.