Life after ETH — the next United manager

If we sack ten Hag who would you want as manager?

  • Massimiliano Allegri

    Votes: 24 1.8%
  • Rúben Amorim

    Votes: 280 20.5%
  • Michael Carrick

    Votes: 33 2.4%
  • Roberto de Zerbi

    Votes: 18 1.3%
  • Thomas Frank

    Votes: 70 5.1%
  • Sebastian Hoeneß

    Votes: 59 4.3%
  • Eddie Howe

    Votes: 6 0.4%
  • Simone Inzaghi

    Votes: 66 4.8%
  • Andoni Iraola

    Votes: 36 2.6%
  • Thiago Motta

    Votes: 8 0.6%
  • Julian Nagelsmann

    Votes: 256 18.7%
  • Graham Potter

    Votes: 26 1.9%
  • Ruud van Nistelrooy

    Votes: 30 2.2%
  • Marco Silva

    Votes: 8 0.6%
  • Xabi Alonso

    Votes: 217 15.9%
  • Xavi

    Votes: 58 4.2%
  • Kieran McKenna

    Votes: 81 5.9%
  • Unai Emery

    Votes: 90 6.6%
  • Fabian Hürzeler

    Votes: 1 0.1%

  • Total voters
    1,367
I am not sure INEOS can afford a season-long interim in order to get someone like Inzaghi next Summer? As such, their best path is to get the best, currently available manager on a 2+1 yrs contract imho… with an exit clause / agreed compensation if targets for the season are not met !?
 
Why Nagelsmann want to ditch his national team for us ?? even he is interested in joining us.. it will be after 2026 world cup unless he perform poorly in the qualifiers. Zidane.. close to impossible.. if he really wanted to join, he won't join at this time.

I don't know, man, many were adamant Yoro wasn't choosing United over Real Madrid and there was no way United would get him. Well, that's not what happened. I don't believe he will come either, but if there ever was a time it's probably now. Far enough from 2026 and with little happening international wise. He might decide to instead come back into the club game rather than twiddle his thumbs for months.
 
I would agree that Thomas Frank is a decent candidate, we've got to be honest about where we are right now and the type of character we need to get the team playing effective football again. I don't think without his influence Brentford would be as secure a PL outfit as they currently are.

On the other hand though Potter is a great example of a mid table PL manager stepping into a bigger environment at Chelsea and flopping harder than a wet mattress falling of a balcony.
There is that risk yeah. I do think Frank comes across better than Potter though. Potter always seems a bit flat / boring in interviews. I do get the impression that Frank could inspire confidence better than Potter.

But yeah it's a risk, although I think Amorim would be equally as risky, if not more tbh.
 
Refusing to get excited about the next great thing from Europe. Amorim, Alonso, Nagelsmann.

the EPL is a different beast.

Whilst it’s possible any of the above could come in and turn it around, my preference would be Emery

What he’s done at AV is nothing short of excellent. With plenty of EPL experience, he knows the league. He’s brilliant in knock out football and has AV playing some very good football.
 
If it could be anyone of the list, I would love Emery, if not I'd go for T.Frank, 2 managers with over achievements in the league already and the pedigree would surely give them a better jump off point than most.

We need to steer clear of Emery. His teams are questionable out of possession, to put it lightly. It has been clear at every team he's been at so far, even at Villa, and to this day it's a problem, despite the significant improvement of that team under him. It was a problem vs United too when they played us a few weeks ago.

In my opinion, ETH's failure can also be attributed partly to his United side being really bad out of possession. There's no point in getting in someone who might be an improvement but with a heavily limited ceiling.
 
I am not sure INEOS can afford a season-long interim in order to get someone like Inzaghi next Summer? As such, their best path is to get the best, currently available manager on a 2+1 yrs contract imho… with an exit clause / agreed compensation if targets for the season are not met !?

I'm also not sure there's a single manager out there, Pep included, who you could absolutely guarantee would be a success. There's so much wrong and it could sink even a good manager.

If there was a candidate out there with a profile who made you think they would be significantly more likely to succeed than any of the currently available options you'd think maybe it's worth waiting, but as they're all as much of a gamble as each other you might as well pick who can get to work straight away.
 
If the Nagelsmann rumours are true, why would he want to come into this mess? Seems lots of money going on for him though, according to Oddschecker. Problem is going to be that most serious managers will want to overhaul the squad, with money we don’t have. Yes, EtH was an utter failure as a coach, but he’s also left us with a squad that’s not top drawer.
 
We might be a at a bad moment as a club, but this is still one of the biggest jobs in club football. Any manager who isn't already at a big club would kill for this job. I find it strange that some people are still underestimating the pull of United.

Some managers might prefer a summer move out of their respect for their current clubs, but all in all this a great job that pays a great deal of money and can spend well in the market. Most managers would back themselves to make a difference.
 
Bit tongue-in-cheek, but a Danish manager bringing in many Danish players into his Brentford side makes me think that he's got a high level of trust in players from his homeland.
We already have 3 Danish players, not long before a front 2 on Hoijlund and Obi-Martin
 
If the Nagelsmann rumours are true, why would he want to come into this mess? Seems lots of money going on for him though, according to Oddschecker. Problem is going to be that most serious managers will want to overhaul the squad, with money we don’t have. Yes, EtH was an utter failure as a coach, but he’s also left us with a squad that’s not top drawer.
It depends on his preference. A lot of people mentioned that he likes to the Germany job because he wants to be close to his family, but other than that, a national team job isn't one for young managers imo. It's boring and you barely see your players. He must fancy returning to club football at some point. But none of us know what he's thinking at the moment.
 
What style of football does Naglesman play?

And do we really expect him to leave his position with his country for us.
 
What makes you think that? Have their been any reports about what it might cost to get him?

I can imagine the German FA fighting hard to keep hold of him (unless Klopp gives them the green light and ditches his Red Bull job).

Purely basing it off of the wages an international manager gets vs club football. I imagine a contract termination clause isn't a made-up number and has some function of (# of years left, annual wage).
 
Am so tired. Am not choosing any manager. I have no clue what or who will work...
 
I think the club needs to detach itself more from managers in general, just treat them as someone playing a role instead of this hero cult of personality figure that defines the club. The other thing is there are so many managers out there, like a revolving door, you get someone in, they do okay or not, you move on. Managers can also do a bad job somewhere like Flick at Germany and still be a good manager in the right circumstances. Shouldn't be seen as precious as it is.
Well said.