Israel - Palestine Discussion | Post Respectfully | Discuss more, tweet less

Can anyone on this forum confidently say that if they and their family lived like this, for years and years, with no end in sight, they wouldn’t be extremist?
Thanks for posting this. But I think it’s wasted on those two posters. They are indoctrinated with hate for Arabs from a young age. You’re not gonna get through to them.
They have forgotten what treatment Jews had under the Nazis and now cheer when the same is done to Palestinians by Jews. It’s the most twisted thing I’ve ever come across .
 
Some Israeli media outlet claimed that "Sabia" means "(female) slave". it's so fecking stupid to lie about something that is so easily shown to be false.
Bu media outlets in general profit from the fact that the headlines of articles stick in the memory of the majority of people, not the truth and not complicated perspectives about anything.

re: getting hostages pregnant, it doesn't make sense from the angle you mentioned, but you won't expect people to act sensibly in situtions like these.
I don't believe that there are female hostages in these situations that are not at minimum touched, harrased,and sometimes raped, in any place on earth.


Islam/Judaism/whichever religion will not stand for it,
but people are not saints, and they are angry. females are easy targets. I wouldn't be surprised if their reproductive systetms don't work because of the conditions in which they are held. won't be surprised to have learned that fetuses didn't survive, if indeed they have been created.
I suspect that both the male and female people inside those tunnels have been deeply harrased in many ways.

not everything has to go down the "oh but the Israeli propaganda machine always lies, I call bollox" road.
Not specified towards you but generally in this thread. It's tiresome.

I also don't want to imgagine what Arab boys, teenagers, women in israeli prisons go through in places that the CCTTV cameras don't cover.

The arabic word for slave is "abiid" or "abiida" (feminine form), there's no mistaking that.

I do not either and absolutely get what you're saying. I'm under no illusion, sexual harrassment or rape can never be ruled out in war times and I would be the last person to handwave it. The allegations of mass rapes on Israeli soil in a time limited operation with enemy helicopters and tanks on the way, are where my doubts lie.

I sincerely hope that no hostage had to endure this horrible fate, but the translation of the video in this case is just false, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
The arabic word for slave is "abiid" or "abiida" (feminine form), there's no mistaking that.

I do not either and absolutely get what you're saying. I'm under no illusion, sexual harrassment or rape can never be ruled out in war times and I would be the last person to handwave it. The allegations of mass rapes on Israeli soil in a time limited operation with enemy helicopters and tanks on the way, are where my doubts lie.

I sincerely hope that no hostage had to endure this horrible fate, but the translation of the video in this case is just false, in my opinion.

yeah I was atlking about hostages in the tunnels already in Gaza, no at the party on Oct 7th.
and I agree, the translation seems very much false.
 
‘Health catastrophe’ imminent if fuel not supplied to Al-Aqsa Hospital

The Al-Aqsa Hospital just issued a press release providing an update on the dire situation at the central Gaza health facility.
Here is a summary of the statement:
  • The administration of Al-Aqsa Hospital warns of an imminent health catastrophe if fuel is not supplied to the hospital within the next few hours.
  • We express our deep astonishment and disapproval at the policy of procrastination that Al-Aqsa Hospital is being subjected to.
  • For many hours, we have been in contact with the relevant authorities and the World Health Organization, which is the body responsible for supplying fuel to the hospital. But there has been no response to our request to supply fuel immediately and urgently.
  • We appeal to the international community to supply 50,000 litres of fuel to the hospital in the coming hours before the health disaster strikes hundreds of sick and wounded people. Any procrastination in supplying fuel means a death sentence for these sick and wounded people.

 
So getting back to the bolded part, there are countless examples that you are simply wrong. Here you have just one:
R3YMHGSUJD54DQWDYBAA4V7CFU.jpg


Care to explain the map?

Care to explain what are those means?

I wonder why a picture that has the palestinian flag all over the region and argument has been mounted around is maintained without bejng deleted. And i cant compare it with a picture of netanyahu doing the same in the UN but as israel ignoring gaza and west bank and is deleted on "keep it civil" measures

Both pics the same, but one are anonymous and another being the PM of israel
 
And those you encountered so far were all propaganda (meaning all those that do not align with your view). How unlucky.

It's incredible that someone posting Douglas Murray and travel bloggers attempts to be condescending. Just no self-awareness whatsoever.
 
I wonder why a picture that has the palestinian flag all over the region and argument has been mounted around is maintained without bejng deleted. And i cant compare it with a picture of netanyahu doing the same in the UN but as israel ignoring gaza and west bank and is deleted on "keep it civil" measures

Both pics the same, but one are anonymous and another being the PM of israel
Because you constantly attack me personally to which I have to react. But it brings nothing to the discussion so no wonder bunch of posts get deleted. Attack the ideas but dont insult others.
 
It's incredible that someone posting Douglas Murray and travel bloggers attempts to be condescending. Just no self-awareness whatsoever.
This is a very nice example.

Post something that Douglas Murray said/wrote about the conflict and agree/disagree with that. Don't use it as a tool to get at me like you won some sort of argument. You didn't. I don't lurk around the thread and look for every mention of Filkenstein, Pappe or Chomsky and use it against some poster. We can discuss their views.

What do you mean about Oren? He is a travel blogger. So what? He is also an Israeli who gives his point of view. Do you judge fellow Israeli Caftards in this thread based on what their job/occupation is? So speaking of condescending.

Typically, you couldn't help, but finish with a little personal insult.
 
This is a very nice example.

Post something that Douglas Murray said/wrote about the conflict and agree/disagree with that. Don't use it as a tool to get at me like you won some sort of argument. You didn't. I don't lurk around the thread and look for every mention of Filkenstein, Pappe or Chomsky and use it against some poster. We can discuss their views.

What do you mean about Oren? He is a travel blogger. So what? He is also an Israeli who gives his point of view. Do you judge fellow Israeli Caftards in this thread based on what their job/occupation is? So speaking of condescending.

Typically, you couldn't help, but finish with a little personal insult.

Are you comparing scholars to a clown? :lol: of course people will laugh at your posts if you use Murray as a source.
 
This is a good page that highlights some of the more extreme crimes against humanity that the Israeli Defense Forces have carried out over the past 6 months including rape and sexual violence against Palestinians. This is important to keep in mind as "the most moral" disinformation is starting to rear its ugly head again.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexua...ainst_Palestinians_during_the_Israel–Hamas_war

The IDF has been accused of committing acts of gender-based violence, war crimes and crimes against humanity in keeping with the recognition of the International Criminal Court (ICC) that sexual violence is a war crime and a crime against humanity.
 
It's ... something... to see Zionists invoke fecking Nuremberg as an unjust and political show-trial in order to make the ICC case look worse:

 
Because you constantly attack me personally to which I have to react. But it brings nothing to the discussion so no wonder bunch of posts get deleted. Attack the ideas but dont insult others.

How I insulted in any way?
 
How I insulted in any way?
I meant you in plural, which was probably not very wise in highsight. You personally didn't so I apologize if you took offence. (you should have seen some other posts which are already deleted :) )
 
I meant you in plural, which was probably not very wise in highlight. You personally didn't so I apologize if you took offence. (you should have seen some other posts which are already deleted :) )

I can't be responsible of others. But anyway now that I ve got your attentio, do you have anythingto say on the map that Netanyahu showed in the UN were gaza and WB was covered for a full total israel state in the middle east of the future in contraposition of the one you posted? And taking in account that Netanyahu is the PM with actual power what is scarier?
 
I can't be responsible of others. But anyway now that I ve got your attentio, do you have anythingto say on the map that Netanyahu showed in the UN were gaza and WB was covered for a full total israel state in the middle east of the future in contraposition of the one you posted? And taking in account that Netanyahu is the PM with actual power what is scarier?
Yes, that was incredibly stupid stunt from Bibi. Completely unnecessary provocation. It didn't help Israel at all. You can find similar pictures of Abbas holding the same map, handing out scarves and little mock ups without Israel. I guess we don't have to talk about Hamas. I see it as mutual provocation. You can argue that Israeli PM holds much more power than Palestinian counterparts, what is true of course. But in no way it is official Israeli governmental policy with enough political capital behind it. Smotrich and Gvir say stupid shit time from time, but it is about it, for now.

In context of current events when you hold sign with that map and words "any means necessary" that means only one thing - Palestine will be Jew free. On the other hand, there are 2 million Arabs living in Israel relatively good life. You can agree/disagree what that good life stands for. But can you name one Arab/Muslim country where Jews live as minority? Not even good life. Just where they live. Only one. Can you? Jews have nowhere else to go.
 
I meant you in plural, which was probably not very wise in highsight. You personally didn't so I apologize if you took offence. (you should have seen some other posts which are already deleted :) )
Taking my deleted post as an example, it was the mildest thing imaginable. To be honest I have no idea why mods deleted it. But if these were the kind of deleted posts, then you don't have much to complain about.
 
Yes, that was incredibly stupid stunt from Bibi. Completely unnecessary provocation. It didn't help Israel at all. You can find similar pictures of Abbas holding the same map, handing out scarves and little mock ups without Israel. I guess we don't have to talk about Hamas. I see it as mutual provocation. You can argue that Israeli PM holds much more power than Palestinian counterparts, what is true of course. But in no way it is official Israeli governmental policy with enough political capital behind it. Smotrich and Gvir say stupid shit time from time, but it is about it, for now.

In context of current events when you hold sign with that map and words "any means necessary" that means only one thing - Palestine will be Jew free. On the other hand, there are 2 million Arabs living in Israel relatively good life. You can agree/disagree what that good life stands for. But can you name one Arab/Muslim country where Jews live as minority? Not even good life. Just where they live. Only one. Can you? Jews have nowhere else to go.

The issue is a double standard is employed here. Whenever Israeli or even US politicians make outlandish statements it's waived away as 'not serious' yet some young protesters hold a sign and it's apparently a serious threat and the police need to apply pressure.

Even stepping away from Israel, we have Mitch talking about nuking Gaza with no rebuke yet there's college age kids having their degrees withheld due to protesting.

Each side can choose to get emotional over these fringe opinions or hyperbole but if they do they don't deserve to be treated seriously. What's important is what people of influence are saying.
 
It's ... something... to see Zionists invoke fecking Nuremberg as an unjust and political show-trial in order to make the ICC case look worse:


Totally shocking how they've come around to this well known argument now that it suits them. Maybe they should also retroactively pardon Eichmann, just to really drive home the point. They didn't really have jurisdiction, after all.
 
In context of current events when you hold sign with that map and words "any means necessary" that means only one thing - Palestine will be Jew free.

What does it mean in the context of current events when Israeli officials say "let's kill all the Palestinians" and then Israel kills tens of thousands of Palestinians?
 
Taking my deleted post as an example, it was the mildest thing imaginable. To be honest I have no idea why mods deleted it. But if these were the kind of deleted posts, then you don't have much to complain about.
I do understand why some posts are deleted which derail the thread with unnecessary personal ping-pong. I have never complained about your posts and wouldn't mind if it would still be here.
 
The issue is a double standard is employed here. Whenever Israeli or even US politicians make outlandish statements it's waived away as 'not serious' yet some young protesters hold a sign and it's apparently a serious threat and the police need to apply pressure.

Even stepping away from Israel, we have Mitch talking about nuking Gaza with no rebuke yet there's college age kids having their degrees withheld due to protesting.

Each side can choose to get emotional over these fringe opinions or hyperbole but if they do they don't deserve to be treated seriously. What's important is what people of influence are saying.

The problem is that one of these fringe opinions took action on October 7 and performed the biggest attack on Jews since the Holocaust.
 
Do the Zionist genocide apologists in this thread want to respond to this?

Israeli society is sick.

I mean, they defend the murder of thousands of children and the starvation of 2 million people. Defending a statement will be a piece of cake.
 
What's the political significance of a random college student? You make a lot of generalizations based on that.
More than you think. History provides a valuable lesson.

Expulsion of teachers and students in 1938
More than 2,700 mainly Jewish members of the University of Vienna (professors, lecturers, students and administrative employees) were expelled in 1938. It happened quickly and smoothly, based on the same process that had been used in Germany before that, but much faster – in only a few months – and under active participation by the students, officials and professors that were sympathetic to National Socialism.

https://geschichte.univie.ac.at/en/articles/expulsion-teachers-and-students-1938
 
More than you think. History provides a valuable lesson.

So you don't see any issue with using the picture of a random student and saying hamas has loads of supporters, and at the same time discarding the significance of israeli elected official saying they should kill all palestinians.