Gary Neville

Was he an absolute vital part of United’s success during the Fergie era? No.
What bullshit Fantasy Football standards do you live up to? He was so vital he was made captain when Roy Keane left, because he was a mainstay in the starting 11 for club and country for a decade. What do you consider "vital"?
 
We spent 200 million pounds on five players. Only one of them (Mazraoui) has established himself as a nailed-on starter. One (Zirkzee) looks like a flop. One has been underwhelming at best (Ugarte). It’s not looking like a great window thus far.
What?
 
No, you’re wrong. He was bang average, he played a part in a very good team but United would have won just as much without him.
Not on this I'm not and you won't find many United fans who watched them in that period who will agree with you, you won't find many of the players who played in the same team or against him agree either
 
No, you’re wrong. He was bang average, he played a part in a very good team but United would have won just as much without him.
If he was “bang average” then why did Sir Alex keep playing him week in, week out and not look for a better option then? Bang average players would never have lasted that long under Sir Alex.
 
No, you’re wrong. He was bang average, he played a part in a very good team but United would have won just as much without him.
It takes all sorts and of course you are allowed to hate Neville if that is what does it for you but for the record your comment here is miles off the mark and almost as embarrassing as Kyle Walker’s dive.
 
Never ever have him commentating in our games

First clear penalty and even without a single replay he instantly says just a coming together. Nothing

Then he says it's the worst quality Manchester derby in 15 years or something. Think he was saying team quality

He said something like United didn't play well (not exact words) except Amad. Not true. The numbers on xG plus Maz and Ugarte numbers says otherwise.

Once again, he bends backwards to show he is not biased for us, not sure why, no one cares, and ends up shitting on us.
 
Never ever have him commentating in our games

First clear penalty and even without a single replay he instantly says just a coming together. Nothing


Then he says it's the worst quality Manchester derby in 15 years or something. Think he was saying team quality

He said something like United didn't play well (not exact words) except Amad. Not true. The numbers on xG plus Maz and Ugarte numbers says otherwise.

Once again, he bends backwards to show he is not biased for us, not sure why, no one cares, and ends up shitting on us.

He said the ref might think it's just a coming together, then when he saw the replay he said it was a penalty...
 
Was he an absolute vital part of United’s success during the Fergie era? No.
He was the best RB in the league for the best part of 10 years. Criminally underrated as a player because he talks himself down, so much so its spread to your own fans. He was never Cafu in attack or Maldini in defence but he was very good at both and would probably start at any team in the league today. He was a cog in a machine but a vital cog.
 
I didn't watch the match on sky sports but he's right in that the quality was lacking. United weren't great however city were bang average, I'm not sure how he thinks United didn't deserve to win. Being a little less shit will make you the winner by default.

I think people see as a spokesman for the fans of the club, people need to stop putting so much weight on what he says.
 
You’re all wrong.
Keep swinging. Take your shirt off and box them bare knuckled.
You, obviously, are THE MAN. Everyone else, with sight and an understanding of the game, is wrong. Truth be told the club should have sacked Fergie for continually picking this guy.
I look forward to your next pronouncement. Maybe, choose Brian Robson next. He was also overrated
 
Keep swinging. Take your shirt off and box them bare knuckled.
You, obviously, are THE MAN. Everyone else, with sight and an understanding of the game, is wrong. Truth be told the club should have sacked Fergie for continually picking this guy.
I look forward to your next pronouncement. Maybe, choose Brian Robson next. He was also overrated
Relax, it’s not that deep.
 
For United fans here, am I being paranoid listening him that he has a certain type of agenda against the new coach or does he just try to please the audience trying to be more neutral and being harsher with everything regarding United? Reached a point where I had to turn off the sound because I was fed up of listening him.
I think he tries to be neutral so nobody can say anything about being ManUtd fan that he often sound like some of his ABU commentators/pundits.
I know it is hard but he needs to learn from Keane.
 
To be fair, when he saw the replay he did suggest the Diaz foul on Højlund was a pen but the others in commentary disagreed. (I never got the "not enough for me" when the man completely missed the ball and clearly impeded Rasmus).

Also the who balanced reputation he's tried to build went up in flames when Amad scored :lol:
 
Never ever have him commentating in our games

First clear penalty and even without a single replay he instantly says just a coming together. Nothing

Then he says it's the worst quality Manchester derby in 15 years or something. Think he was saying team quality

He said something like United didn't play well (not exact words) except Amad. Not true. The numbers on xG plus Maz and Ugarte numbers says otherwise.

Once again, he bends backwards to show he is not biased for us, not sure why, no one cares, and ends up shitting on us.
The Rasmus one? He said it was pen and Mike dean said "not in a game like this"
 
To be fair, when he saw the replay he did suggest the Diaz foul on Højlund was a pen but the others in commentary disagreed. (I never got the "not enough for me" when the man completely missed the ball and clearly impeded Rasmus).

Also the who balanced reputation he's tried to build went up in flames when Amad scored :lol:
I never got the "not enough, not in game like this?"

What does the game have to do with whether it's a penalty, as if it was Chelsea Vs wolves (eg) it would be