sillwuka
Full Member
Guys I have a hunch, I reckon he will either stay with Barca or sign with us.
Amazing FdJ, or his agent, told Berger that they don't want to come to United, however, neither of them had the decency to tell EtH, or the club, even though they have close working relationships!
Seems a fair analysis of the situation to me.
Season over if he doesn't come.
I think 99% of fans, if not 100% understand and accept that he’d stay at Barça on his current deal in a perfect World.
I reckon he’d even likely accept a small pay reduction as long as he is reimbursed for his generosity over the past two seasons.
Neither of those things look at all likely.
Not even United are dumb enough to have spent the window chasing a deal for a player they’ve not had the green light from personally. It just isn’t possible.
Fabregas was willing to leave if he wasn’t in the manager’s plans - then there was a change of manager that summer due to totally unforeseen circumstances and he was told he would be.Didn't we do that with Fabregas?
No we didn't i don't believe.Didn't we do that with Fabregas?
We did it with Vidal tooDidn't we do that with Fabregas?
Not really. He told Moyes would come if he didn’t get playing time, but he started the first game of that season, played well and the rest is history.Didn't we do that with Fabregas?
Didn't we do that with Fabregas?
Amazing FdJ, or his agent, told Berger that they don't want to come to United, however, neither of them had the decency to tell EtH, or the club, even though they have close working relationships!
Correct. He also had no connection to MoyesFrom memory he’d given Moyes promises but it hinged on playing time with Barca?
Exactly. He obviously would prefer to stay, but isn't against joining us. It's clear Barca want rid, and if i was him i would leave if the reports around his salary are true.Not even United are dumb enough to have spent the window chasing a deal for a player they’ve not had the green light from personally. It just isn’t possible.
Exactly that.From memory he’d given Moyes promises but it hinged on playing time with Barca?
We did it with Vidal too
Aa long as we get 40points....Season over if he doesn't come.
Season over if he doesn't come.
Barca should not be able to buy new players. It's as simple as that. Pay your debts, struggle for a few years then come back again.
It's madness they're allowed to keep spiralling deeper and deeper
That is some top tier mismanagement. I never understood why they constantly gave Messi such outlandish contracts, yes I understand he's Messi, but even CR7 never went to those levels. Messi was also unlikely to ever leave them, so it's not like it was totally necessary. From there it spiralled with other contracts, now it seems they were actually worse than us in that regard. On top of that they absolutely squandered the Neymar money.
Common sense would dictate that they use their money to pay off everything and take a few years in the wilderness; they're unlikely to really miss out on top 4 and they're still producing or acquiring good young talent. They would be back sooner rather than later, but they're here signing players left right and centre and still saddled with huge wages.
The second half isn’t true. That’s on Laporta. Apparently he didn’t realise what the ins and outs of FFP were and wrote off assets as 0 that would normally have allowed them to spend more but it was -250 odd million and absolutely fecked it. Barca would still be in debt but at least they’re be allowed to operate as a proper football club without fecking themselves over like this. That’s on LaportaLeo Messis contracts was never THE issue by themselves. Barcelonas problems are all about Josep Maria Bartomeus insane incompetence. The Messi money could certainly have been better spent, but its just one of many contributing factors.
The man is single handedly responsible for the current financial situation of Barcelona, and its frankly outrageous that he is not in prison for the gross negligence he has displayed over the years.
Barcelona managed to put themselves in a situation where they straight up were paying more salary than they had income. Or, Bartomeu did.
Barcelonas transfer spend the last few years, in million £
2014/2015 150.05
2015/2016 45.90
2016/2017 112.28
2017/2018 337.05
2018/2019 126.99
2019/2020 270.90
2020/2021 100.80
19/20 saw Griezmann and Frenkie join the club. 17/18 saw Dembele and Coutinho.
The transfer spend is important because of the way Barcelona does transfers: In installments. They have sales as well which makes the picture better, but the balance books does nothing for the cash flow. Its why they still owe so much money to so many clubs.
During the pandemic, Barcelona flat out did not have money to pay salaries. With a wage bill larger than the annual income per year pre-covid, no one is remotely surprised that the well dried up real fast.
Where Real Madrid has a incredibly competent director in Florentino Perez (even if he is a dick), Barcelona have had to suffer a guy that spends money like a drunk sailor and closes his eyes, hoping it will all work out.
Barcelona lost nearly 500 million euro due to covid.
Due to the FFP regulations in Spain, which are a bit harsher than the ones UEFA put out, Barcelona had to let their biggest ever player leave for free. They couldnt even re-sign him if he played for nothing as Spanish law dictate that a new contract cant be less than 50% of the previous. Leo Messi did offer to take a 50% paycut to stay. I dont have a clear picture on ALL the Barcelona stars, but its smy impression that a lot of the oldtimers were well and ready to take large paycuts, and have done so.
All because of Bartomeu.
The players and everyone else at Barcelona are innocent in what has been the biggest mismanagement of a large business in sport history lead by one man in particular.
In the real world, Barcelona would have been put out of its misery by now.
. They couldnt even re-sign him if he played for nothing as Spanish law dictate that a new contract cant be less than 50% of the previous.
Comedy Fail.Di maria vives off this one.
Slightly contradicting yourself there mate, but I think the key thing is there is more in our favour than against. Barca has to sell, we are ready to buy. I think it happens eventually.I’m starting to feel pessimistic about this unfortunately. But I can’t see him lowering his salary.. and if he doesn’t do that, he has to leave.. (and if he leaves, I think we’ll get him)
Im holding out hope that the ‘I don’t want to leave’ is just him standing firm in the upcoming negotiations about reducing his fee as a way of controlling the negotiations. I’ve no fecking clue, but I struggle to believe we’d chase a player for so long without assurances that he’d join
Spanish law, especially around sport seems complicated as feck.This was never true.
Even if we ignore the De Jong example of him deferring 17m of wages in 2 years, where he took a paycut of 76% for 2020/21, Messi was not renegotiating a wage, nor taking a pay cut. Even under contract, nothing would have prevented Messi from taking similar cuts or 99% cuts till his career was over with a loyalty bonus in say 2030.
Messi was however no longer an employee and was out of contract, the was no wage to renegotiate nor “cut”.
There is no law to prevent an unemployed person accepting whatever wage he wants.
Hende why Laporta came out a few months later and said “I had hoped Messi would decide to play for free”.
I imagine we will give him a better deal than what Barca are asking him to reduce it to, but not as a high as what he's on right now.Even if United can do a deal with Barcelona there remain personal terms. If FdJ is used to being paid so highly will he even accept personal terms with United?
He’s only paid so highly to compensate for his deferred pay. I think his ‘normal’ contract is kinda reasonable. I’ve seen a circa 250k pw figure reported. I don’t think we will struggle to agree a deal with him.Even if United can do a deal with Barcelona there remain personal terms. If FdJ is used to being paid so highly will he even accept personal terms with United?
Most likely. Think it will be a big week - at least we should get a better idea of which way it’s going.This has been dragging and dragging with nothing happening for 2 weeks now
Fair to say since he’s back at Barca tomorrow we will finally hear something soon?
The second half isn’t true. That’s on Laporta. Apparently he didn’t realise what the ins and outs of FFP were and wrote off assets as 0 that would normally have allowed them to spend more but it was -250 odd million and absolutely fecked it. Barca would still be in debt but at least they’re be allowed to operate as a proper football club without fecking themselves over like this. That’s on Laporta
Not even United are dumb enough to have spent the window chasing a deal for a player they’ve not had the green light from personally. It just isn’t possible.
De Jong may or may not arrive, but I wouldn't trust Berger to know. Below is what he reported earlier this year.Amazing FdJ, or his agent, told Berger that they don't want to come to United, however, neither of them had the decency to tell EtH, or the club, even though they have close working relationships!