European Super League

Do you want the ESL to happen?


  • Total voters
    1,921
  • Poll closed .
Playing the likes of RM, Barca, etc... every week devalues the prestige of draws or ties that come when you get into the higher stages of European competitions. It would never last, especially if the included teams were also allowed to play in their domestic leagues and cups at the same time. Players would be run ragged and injuries more frequent. Terrible idea.
Exactly. All these clubs have hundreds of years of history, the ESL dilutes all of that.
 
So is this league going to just replace the PL or not?

I feel all our history would be gone then and nothing to build on it.

It would just ruin everything.
Think it is supposed to be an alternative to the supposed restructure of the CL. The big clubs want more money, not have it shared out to even more clubs. The problem then starts if said clubs are chucked out of their own league. It's a mess.
 
I think that's the idea yeah, all clubs involved will be extremely rich. Right now clubs like Barca are haemorrhaging money just to try and compete, the idea of this league is surely to try and level the playing field financially somewhat.
In big parts due to their faults, their solutions is a big treason to their faithful fans.
 
How are Man City even fecking invited, they’ve won a few league titles, never won a champions league, got about ten fans, what criteria have they met other than having shitloads of money?

Tottenham out of all teams got an invite for this and they are a nothing club.
 
With the money involved, I doubt thats needed. They arent going to bid 400m for a player, and if they do then happy days to the selling club

I hear you but then a few years ago I (and presumably Barcelona) never thought I'd see a player being bought for £200m and yet PSG paid that for Neymar.
 
Total disaster. The closed shop franchise system, around which team sports in NA are organised, just cuts right across how international football works. The damage will be enormous. And with UEFA fighting back and banning SL players from all tournaments, it will feck up international football too.

The worst of it is it takes clubs with a century of tradition right out of their own history and that context. Every individual and team record, every comparable from club history will just be so much dust. It will hugely diminish football. Sure it's fun to play Real Madrid, but as long as we can do that once every few years in the CL that's fine. I for one would rather see United play Southampton and Brighton twice a year than Bayern and PSG.
This is purely for the moneybags. They would get everything their own way. It’s a shambles and I cannot believe that clubs have voted in favour of it.
 
So is this league going to just replace the PL or not?

I feel all our history would be gone then and nothing to build on it.

It would just ruin everything.

No, it's an answer to UEFAs new Champions League vision from 2024.

And what about UEFA’s reformed Champions League? UEFA wants a new format for the Champions League from 2024, with one 36-team league replacing the current group stage, where every team plays 10 matches. This is called the ‘Swiss model’. Under the proposed format, by the time winner has lifted the European Cup, the competition will have produced 100 new games, and the finalists will have played at least 17 matches, four more than under the current system. Accommodating four additional games in the autumn will be a challenge for most national leagues, however, including in England, where the Carabao Cup would be under threat. Three of the four extra Champions League places would meanwhile go to clubs based on past performance in Europe, using the UEFA coefficient ranking system
 
Give it enough time and I'm afraid you'll understand. What UEFA want is to allow as much money as possible come into football but have the biggest revenue makers accept it. They want a 'fairness' that can allow Man City to have a better bench than Arsenal do a first team but still take in all the revenue from Arsenal fans anyway. They want a 'fairness' that is a European 'Champions' league that gives multiple places to big revenue leagues that means that the actual champions from Scotland, Ireland, etc will never be able to make it to the competition proper. They want a 'fairness' that suits only them. The only reason that UEFA care about this is because they stand to lose revenue. If this was Rangers and Dundalk and other small clubs, who are champions, from small nations planning this UEFA wouldn't give a shit.

Well then maybe UEFA should have done more to stop UAE and Qatar from making a joke out of football. Maybe they should have stopped the likes of Leeds, Wigan, us and Liverpool from being taken over by obvious leeches and straddled with huge debts. They created this shit and it is their fault. I hate the super league idea but I simply don't blame the clubs I blame UEFA, the FA and the other league authorities.
Totally this! I feel it’s lazy for the media to blame the clubs associating to create the ESL while overlooking the total negligence and greed on the part of UEFA and some national leagues which created the environment for this.

I lay the full blame for this mess firmly at the foot of the corrupt bureaucrats at UEFA/FIFA/national leagues. The latest case in point being the announced (completely pointless) change in format of the CL. Permitting the takeovers of clubs which destroyed the ecosystem of the football landscape was always going to end in tears for everyone, and I mean everyone.
 
Think it is supposed to be an alternative to the supposed restructure of the CL. The big clubs want more money, not have it shared out to even more clubs. The problem then starts if said clubs are chucked out of their own league. It's a mess.

Sounds like a mess. I like the current structure and CL as it is. 64 teams in CL would be fine too if they want to improve it, but group stage would get more boring potentially.
 
Playing the likes of RM, Barca, etc... every week devalues the prestige of draws or ties that come when you get into the higher stages of European competitions. It would never last, especially if the included teams were also allowed to play in their domestic leagues and cups at the same time. Players would be run ragged and injuries more frequent. Terrible idea.
No it doesn't. Go back and look at the CL group stage 2 from the 00's. It was the pinnacle of elite football:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000–01_UEFA_Champions_League_second_group_stage#
 
It's because the likes of Barca are haemorrhaging money in the PSG/City inflated market, they need more guaranteed money in order to be able to compete and not go under in the process.
Aye but it has always peed me off that Real were able to afford to take Ronaldo off us because they got far more money from the La Liga tv rights than we were..and it continues. Talk about Financial Fair play? There has never been any when Real.and Barca get half the Tv revenues and the rest of La Liga including Atletico share the rest, while in the Prem all the clubs get an equal share. So there is no differential between what Burnley get and what United get. Who wants to watch Burnley?
 
Except that in Spain Real and Barca are in on it, and they do not have foreign owners. It amazes me that Barc and Real are doing this when, unlike the Prem, they share 50% of the TV money with the other La Liga clubs sharing the remainder. So the big two in Spain have a huge financial advantage from TV compared to big clubs in the Prem where the TV money is shared equally amongst all clubs, no matter how much of a draw they are.

Significant financial advantage, yes. But also significant financial mismanagement. The greed of these clubs is sickening.
 
For people that missed it, this is where it comes from it's a long standing issue. This sentence echoes what the G-14, ECA and the cartel of top clubs have been doing for more than 20 years.

Several months later, in August 2016, Karl-Heinz Rummenigge made a sensitive statement at a meeting of the European Club Association (ECA). By that time, he had been chairman of the ECA -- the world's largest club alliance, representing the interests of more than 220 teams -- for eight years. According to the minutes of one meeting, Rummenigge said that "the big clubs received big offers to create a super league and that UEFA then called for a meeting with representatives of some of these big clubs a couple of weeks ago with a proposal to keep European club football united."

The message was clear: Unless the big clubs got more money and power from UEFA, they would start their own league.For smaller and midsized clubs, whose interests the ECA is also supposed to protect, such a scenario would be a disaster. UEFA distributes TV revenues to teams playing in the Europa League and Champions League according to a revenue-sharing formula ensuring that smaller teams also get a cut. But if the top clubs were to turn their backs on the UEFA competitions, the other clubs would lose out on millions in revenues. For some of the clubs, such a rearrangement could threaten their very existence.
 
In big parts due to their faults, their solutions is a big treason to their faithful fans.

"treason", bloody hell. I think so many fans are getting too emotional, they want it to replace the CL, we've replaced the old EC in my time, we've been banned from it for years too.

People hate change, but makes no mistake, the takeovers of PSG and City have forced this.
 
Gary Neville said it spot on.

Of course he did, he's probably the footballer whose benefitted most from Sky's dominance.

I must have missed Gary ripping Sky a new one over their above inflation price increases at the time of pandemic.
 
There was a leak suggesting that a spending cap would be in place at 55% of revenue earned but I’m not sure how legitimate it is. I think this league is born out of frustration from Barce and Real at clubs like City and PSG throwing around oil money, they’ll be something in place.

Of course it is, once Oil rich countries were allowed to own football clubs this was inevitable.
 

He's fecking shill. Sully you've made more informative posts in 12 months than Ducker and Ogden have did in years. Last time Ogden got something right was when he said that United wanted Lukaku on Phill Brown's show. I mean he's a total fecking shill. It would be awkward if you were that ugly looking creature.