- Joined
- Mar 17, 2018
- Messages
- 206
I turned the game off as soon as he brought on Amrabat. Could we not put in one of the youths? I know he's blooded Mainoo, but who else? Play more of the kids, please.
Except now you would be accused of being miserable for not celebrating a winHe isn’t good enough and there are thousands of minutes of proof. Way too open.
Just wanted to write that so when we rightfully complain after a loss, there are no accusations of knee-jerking.
He needs to go.
Why do we even have a manager then? If there's absolutely nothing the manager can do due to the state of the club and the squad, why do we pay him millions per year? Why not just play without a manager at that point?Who refused to replace players that were ill suited to repeated 360 degree footballing change of direction?
Why do you think a mere Burnley when they were certain to part with Dyche and head in the opposite footballing direction to him. Chose to commit fully and not renew a whole host of players and sold a number of others? Was it just for shits and giggles?
What could conceivably make ANY of you think Manchester United should be succesful repeatedly half commiting to differing footballing directions, in terms of player roster, with almost each change of manager in 8 years?
Except now you would be accused of being miserable for not celebrating a win
I think it's a combination of injures, ill suited personnel even with a fit XI but also some managerial errors.
I think the heaviest weighting is injury though, and sadly the squad players are reverse profiles of the ones they are meant to replace. E.g Lindelof for Licha for example who aren't remotely alike.
However I disagree about defensive structure (if you mean cohesion and organisation). No chance we allow so many shots and still win quite a few games if we weren't defensively resolute. Pointing to isolated numbers generally is no good, I prefer to understand the quality of a lot of chances.
We are defending deeper out of obligation which makes us tricky to unpick but does allow for more pot shots as teams try different ways to score.
In fairness we did play most of that game with 10 men and it was what our 3rd game of the season after we had a pre-season that was 1 week long with 1 friendly match played. There was context behind it.
It’s just not long range shots though, against Everton today the amount of times they had the ball in our box with space and able to get a shot off was ridiculous. Been the same in most games this season, we consistently leak chances and we were lucky today to get a clean sheet.Oh noes, whatever shall we do with all those long range shots against us.
To save face. So that a number of fans will fall for the hope of every purposeful engineered false dawn and go for the manager after EVERY boom and burst cycle rather than after who is to really blame. It's a strategy that has worked to perfection 8 years running.Why do we even have a manager then? If there's absolutely nothing the manager can do due to the state of the club and the squad, why do we pay him millions per year? Why not just play without a manager at that point?
DelusionOh noes, whatever shall we do with all those long range shots against us.
You do realise where we are right?Oh noes, whatever shall we do with all those long range shots against us.
This team that hasn’t performed for years should be playing much better football even though they’ve never really looked capable of it before.
That's some conspiracy.To save face. So that a number of fans will fall for the hope of every purposeful engineered false dawn and go for the manager after EVERY boom and burst cycle rather than after who is to really blame. It's a strategy that has worked to perfection 8 years running.
Reality.Delusion
Use a midfield?Oh noes, whatever shall we do with all those long range shots against us.
The same cycle has repeated itself since Moyes was sacked. All your posts in this thread are the literal embodiment of the final phase of the cycle. No wonder you think it consiracyThat's some conspiracy.
The fact is no manager after SAF EVER has. The fact 8 years running you are STILL blind to that reality says it all really.The fact is the manager has full control over the entire first team.......
Not that it was directed to me, but I think it shows that more has to change than just the manager if we are to actually transcend our footballing philosophy.So you are saying Erik Ten Hag hasn't been able to positively affect probably the main problem he was hired to address in the first place?
No. The reality is that we are fecking shite.Reality.
Reality.
We've won 8 and drawn 1 out of our 11 games of 2024. I really don't think we are as shite as you say we are.No. The reality is that we are fecking shite.
Thats actually bollocks. With a 38 year old at Cb and slow CB at left back, it means our defence is a lot deeper and not as progressive building out. Our DM has also proven to be very erratic and ill suited to the direct style from the back.Teams regularly run through us at will every single game. They’re constantly in behind our midfield and on top of our defence.
That has nothing to do with injuries it’s just piss poor tactics.
I think he's only been able to field his first choice defense alone less than 6 times this season, or something like that. That's before we consider other areas of the pitch with injury.Looking at the squad available to him, was wondering how many times did he have first choice 11 available to him this season?
Not that it was directed to me, but I think it shows that more has to change than just the manager if we are to actually transcend our footballing philosophy.
Then do what any elite manager would do and change the effin tactics...the fact that he can't/ is unwilling is why he should go.Thats actually bollocks. With a 38 year old at Cb and slow CB at left back, it means our defence is a lot deeper and not as progressive building out. Our DM has also proven to be very erratic and ill suited to the direct style from the back.
Thats personnel not suited for the tactics. Not the tactics necessarily being poor.
We are. Watch our games. Today for example, atrocious stuff.We've won 8 and drawn 1 out of our 11 games of 2024. I really don't think we are as shite as you say we are.
The money is immaterial - if Murtough can't negotiate well it shouldn't be a slight on Ten Hag. We have wasted money under Ten Hag as manager and for a decade before him, so I Think the question is "why is £500m spent actually looking like £100m spent" more than anything else.I don't necessarily disagree but after 2 years and around £500m spent on players, most of them hand picks by Ten Hag to suit his style. The fact that we are now worse in terms of results and football played than we were before ETH arrived. Would point to the conclusion that Erik certainly isn't helping matters and probably isn't the man to take United to the next level.
There are very limited workable options with the available players at his disposal. He has had extended periods with no striker or no proper defence and in overlapping scenarios both.Then do what any elite manager would do and change the effin tactics...the fact that he can't/ is unwilling is why he should go.
Thats actually bollocks. With a 38 year old at Cb and slow CB at left back, it means our defence is a lot deeper and not as progressive building out. Our DM has also proven to be very erratic and ill suited to the direct style from the back.
Thats personnel not suited for the tactics. Not the tactics necessarily being poor.
I've seen our games. We weren't atrocious today - that's exaggeration. We didnt dominate but we created enough, we were organized enough and we were professional enough to churn out a clean sheet. Which is about what I'd expect for now given the circumstances.We are. Watch our games. Today for example, atrocious stuff.
Jamie Charrager ripped nothing - he just pointed out there is a big gap between defence and midfield, which we all know. What he did not focus enough time on is the "why". That is lazy punditry, its easy to point at gaps but you need to ask why that's happening.It’s not bollocks though it’s just shite tactics. Because it’s been happening all season, ever since pre-season (when plenty pointed out it was suicidal tactics that would never work) and has happened with every single combination of defenders & midfielders all season long. Not just a ‘38 year old centre back (he’s actually 36) & a slow CB at left back’
And even if it was just a case of the ‘personnel not suited for the tactics. Not the tactics necessarily being poor’ why the feck continue with them all season long when everyone can see they don’t work? How is that a sign of a good manager?
When Jamie Carragher can rip apart your whole tactical plan live on MNF you know you’re in trouble.
We've won 8 and drawn 1 out of our 11 games of 2024. I really don't think we are as shite as you say we are.
Jamie Charrager ripped nothing - he just pointed out there is a big gap between defence and midfield, which we all know. .
And wins against Villa, Wolves, West Ham and a draw to Spurs.Ah yes those glorious wins against League 2 Newport Country, League 1 Wigan, 18th placed Luton, 17th placed Forrest & 16th placed Everton. A run of form that will go down in the ages.
If you actually think today was "atrocious stuff " you seriously call into doubt your understanding of the termWe are. Watch our games. Today for example, atrocious stuff.
When did I say the gap was there by design?Thank you for finally admitting the tactics and set up are shite. Took you long enough but we got there.
It was awful. Zero control of the game whatsoever. 2-0 was incredibly flattering, particularly in the first half. Everton continued to probe in the second half, but with less and less belief. It was embarrassing how poor we were in possession. Sloppy would have been an improvement. Also, as usual, plenty of gaps and space for Everton to play through us with ease. We won't get anywhere with such a lack of appreciation for possession and control.I've seen our games. We weren't atrocious today - that's exaggeration. We didnt dominate but we created enough, we were organized enough and we were professional enough to churn out a clean sheet. Which is about what I'd expect for now given the circumstances.