For people who have completed the game, how do you rate it? As a massive fan of the soulsborne series, I think I would give it an 8 or 8.5/10. The open world feels empty in the sense that there is nothing but enemies and bosses. It becomes very predictable. Bosses arent as good or memorable as in Bloodborne or DS3, and many of the bosses are just copies of each other. and the combat isn't better. It's still a good game. With a staggering amount of areas. I feel the graphics could have been better on ps5, but i'm not complaining. As someone else said this basically open world ds2. I feel the difficulty of a lot of the bosses, especially late and end game just takes the piss and aren't fair. I feel open world games get overrated in general including BOTW/GTA etc. but perhaps that's because i'm not a kid or a teenager anymore, so my sense of immersion is less. Still it's a impressive effort from From Software, but I'm not going open world managed to improve the formula. If they are doing it again, they are going to have to throw in some more story and more npc's ala The Witcher to make the world interesting apart from non stop figthing with enemies and bosses. Also I never used about 99% of the items I picked up.