Confirmed: Moyes sacked.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're dead right, because there will always be naive gossip hounds prepared to digest what they read in shitty tabloids without so much as taking the time to chew, and then only too happy to shout the same shit, as loudly as they can, as if it were fact.
When United is back next season (assuming that we will go for a competent manager like Van Gaal or Ancelotti) playing much better than we have played this season, almost anything the players will say will be believed. A lot of staff will be said from players which will be hard to know which is true and which isn't. I also don't get why you all the time point me when I quote stuff from the media, looking like you somehow know that it is made up stuff.

As FlawlessThawa said, even Everton players aren't complimentary for him and have hint many times (in different voices) how much better things are now.

I just don't understand how you're still in his defense when it looks that even SAF saw Moyes for the incompetent he was, and Giggsy - the mister Man United himself - was one of the laders on this so called 'mutiny'.
 
Must admit I didn't think Moyes would have been this much out of his depth. As for his signings did he actually sign Mata and Fellaini? I think both were panic buys of sorts...It's as if the board made the decisions.
 
Well said Mockney. Spot on.
Nail on the head.
Oh god this!.

I understand it. I don't think it's bonkers. Perhaps a little naive and self important but I get it. We'd spent years crowing at the behaviour of Chelsea and Liverpool, all safe in our ivory tower of exception that was Sir Alex. To want us to display a more classy front to the world when finally thrown into the same boat is perfectly understandable. To display it behind closed doors, or in pubs, forums etc would be wilfully disingenuous though. Actually, I think we achieved it all rather well. The match going crowd kept up their veneer of support whilst letting their frustrations be known elsewhere. I think we actually did come out of it all slightly better. Or at least better than expected. It's not as if other clubs fans thought we were a paragon of virtue to begin with.

The problem is that a lot of those types of fans are the same types of fans that say things like "I'd take a couple of years in the doldrums to weed out the glory hunters and re-ignite the atmosphere" whilst insisting that any fans who hope for a couple of losses to put pressure on the manager are the definition of plastic. Both attitudes are daft IMO, but at least one is thinking of what will benefit the club.
 
I'm not arsed Revan, to me you're a prime example of whats wrong with the world of football these days, indirectly it's fans like you who fuel whats turning football to complete shite.

Nothing personal, I'm sure you're a nice guy, I just hate fans like you and wish you'd all feck off and watch WWF of something.

On the other hand to me fans who don't use their heads but go either with misguided loyalties or with romantisms when they talk about football. It was quite funny people posting Fergie's speech during the last few weeks how we should support Moyes when it looks that Fergie himself was on favour of sack now. Hilarious!

I also don't know what is that wrong with the football and how it is turning into complete shite (despite the big wages, which anyway are present in all types of entertainments).

Of course there isn't personal as it should not be.
 
I don't think that post was ridiculous... The man is ALWAYS Blameless... Everything and everyone else is to blame for his failings!! He treated Everton like crap towards the end... Met Fergie privately and behind the clubs back, ran down his contract to ensure he got the Utd Job, put in derisary offer for Baines & Fellaini... there are host of other reasons too!

He then took over Utd where from day one the manner in which he spoke about the club was insulting... "aspire to be like city" and "Fergie would of struggled"...Directly insulting the man who backed him in the first place...is it any wonder fergie agreed he had to go!!

I think Moyes is simply a bit dim really, he is an awful speaker and aside from that just does what suits him best I would suggest and has by and large managed to remain blameless until recently...

The guy will probably be unveiled as the Norwich Manager during the summer and in 12months time I'd suggest you log on to their forums and it'll be like a repeat of everything that is said here...
Not really as Norwich's priority is survival in the PL, ours isn't.
 
On the other hand to me fans who don't use their heads but go either with misguided loyalties or with romantisms when they talk about football. It was quite funny people posting Fergie's speech during the last few weeks how we should support Moyes when it looks that Fergie himself was on favour of sack now. Hilarious!

I also don't know what is that wrong with the football and how it is turning into complete shite (despite the big wages, which anyway are present in all types of entertainments).

Of course there isn't personal as it should not be.

Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....
 
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....

Gone are the days when a fan follows a football club for any reason other than because they win. Rarely, anyway. And that is indeed highly unfortunate.
 
Oh I have. There are still a couple of posters here getting overly working up by the players supposed behaviour and claiming Moyes could've still turned it around if he'd had their support, or the fans, or the elusive ever mystical "more time", but admittedly it's not so much this site as others. Ones with far more entrenched views on match going fans, modern fans and plastic fans. Those who usually only ever pop on here to have a go.

I don't think they're hugely prevalent, but they certainly exist. They're the kind of fans who say things like "I'd take a couple of years in the doldrums to weed out the glory hunters" whilst claiming hoping to lose a couple of games to get rid of a manager was the epoch of plastic.

Both of these attitudes are daft fwiw, but you know they definitely exist.



Oh I agree, both sides have been silly, and those who gave up straight away and wanted us to lose have hardly covered themselves in any glory. Fact is though, they were proved right. The winner takes it all.

I don't think anyone come out of this well. The board for not going through a proper interview process. Moyes for changing the coaching staff completely. Some of his comments or more that he kept on contradicting himself, which told me he was drowning in the job. The players for showing lack of heart and fight. I think they were putting in just enough effort. I am more annoyed with at times the indiscipline i.e. the tweets, the ill advised parties. The supposed turning up late for training drunk. Then we are back to Moyes for not putting his foot down and taking proper disciplinary measures, or maybe taking them with some and no others. The final act of stupidity is leaking his sacking before actually letting Moyes know. I thought we were a better run club than that.
 
Agreed. That stuff needs sorting out but for me its just another symptom of a continuing post SAF meltdown that Moyes tenure simply fuelled rather than arrest.
Does anyone else think the changes brought in since SAF went, i.e. Official Twitter account have not helped? We have gone to wondering what is going on at our club, to far too much and ill timed information coming out.
 
Which is why he has been briefing his mates in the press all season, saying nothing was his fault, how he was left a shit old squad, how Martinez's success at Everton is all down to him, and on and on his bullshit went.

I told you he was snide shithouse, his meek man of the people act is fecking tiresome. You're shit Dave, you got £10 million for being shit, have some self respect, keep your gob shut and feck off.

I totally agree. The stories emerging of him self-righteously being shocked at the sacking, and demanding his compensation through the LMA just show how disingenuous he truly is. Any sane man would have been fearing for his job for months, expecting the axe to fall at any moment. He got better than he deserved - more time and more wages. His poor choices and awful management have cost the club about one hundred million pounds. We can safely say that no one individual has damaged Manchester United more than David Moyes. Not even Bebe.

He is beyond clueless and obviously does not have a manner that endears him to other people. The honesty & integrity act is just that. Some people bought into it but at heart he is a delusional hypocrite who cannot accept responsibility for his own shortcomings and decisions, and who is completely unable to change or adapt in real time.

And thankfully, like all dinosaurs, he is now extinct.
 
Last edited:
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....


Not nice seeing folk lose their jobs, I think any tinge of sadness is down to empathy. That said getting rid was the best for United...and I'm not sure I could've stomached another dull season.
 
Does anyone else think the changes brought in since SAF went, i.e. Official Twitter account have not helped? We have gone to wondering what is going on at our club, to far too much and ill timed information coming out.

I think things like Social media do unfortunately need to be integrated into our club. We need to keep up with technology and the social trends. However, we should have much better control over what happens on such things.
 
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....
Hilarious was the part how people were still using Fergie's speech as a pro-Moyes argument when it looks that Fergie himself have gave up, and Giggs - possibly Fergie's most loyal player ever - was against Moyes as early as me.

There is nothing hilarious on us sacking the manager after 10 month, but it came the time when the mistakes had to be corrected, so better now, then believeing in some prophecy that things will improve itself because time makes average managers great.

The biggest tragedy was us making that decision on the first place, not how fans on an Internet forum acted.
 
Not nice seeing folk lose their jobs, I think any tinge of sadness is down to empathy. That said getting rid was the best for United...and I'm not sure I could've stomached another dull season.

Aye, definitely the best for United. It's just the fans who want to continue beating Moyes with their e-stick and kick him while he's down and already sacked that are irritating. No dignity, no class.
 
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....
Well said.
 
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....

Yep . . Instant dinners, on demand tv and instant gratification , Gimmme Gimme gimme, now now now . . .

The attention span of the average fan is extremely limited. Also, everybody is now an armchair pundit and some people cannot accept a difference of opinion.

The fact I chose to support DM all along was widely condemned and people just couldn't understand how I chose to show faith in SAF choice. That aside I always felt DM was the riskier bumpy choice given his lack of experience but my belief was that they were prepared to let him grow into the roll. It was an unconventional choice from the start but people kept rolling out names of managers who they felt would of done better with the squad which I felt was like comparing apples and oranges. .

Ultimately, it seems that there were players who were not only against Moyes from the start but they undermined him and made his job even harder. Those who don't like Moyes will say its his job as a manager to motivate and sell the players his vision, which is to a degree fair. However I tend to think it actually ignores the fact that some or many of our players effectively downed tools or at least didn't give it their all. This puts their character into question. I don't imagine the team of the early 90s putting in the kind of performances we saw against City/Liverpool even if krusty the clown was our manager.

I actually think Roy Keane was spot on when he said that the players and the club let him down . .
 
Yeah, third. On 75 points.

The point being not having Europa would be more damaging due to our inability to rotate. Having Europa wouldn't harm our chances of top four as the point of those games would be to give the second eleven a chance and to be honest, it seems to be a good second eleven (especially with a sprinkling of the first).

Same they've got the next year with 3 games left. The decision to sack Moyes was definitively taken after Everton, according to several accounts. Of course it was merely the straw that broke the camel's back in all likelihood, but we didn't know that. Right before Everton there were still plenty convinced he'd be given until Christmas. So yes, I wanted it, and I feel vindicated. If there was even the slightest chance Moyes would stay with a convincing win over Everton (plus winning out probably), then it was worth it.

The decision to sack Moyes was likely made up a while back however they waited for top four to be mathematically impossible so they could justify only one season of severance.

Plenty convinced? Those plenty had no idea what was happening behind the scenes. There were plenty (especially non-united fans) that thought he was gone whatever happened so this point of yours is useless. I'm not sure how you can argue the board would have trusted him next season with how this season has gone, unless you are insane...

You wanted Everton to win and you wanted them to win big. Who knows what other games you've wanted Man United to get hammered in, and one can only assume you will give the next manager that treatment too.

I cannot understand how a real fan could bring themselves to support Everton over United in that last game.

And of course I'd rather Liverpool/United winning the league in consecutive seasons over Chelsea/Chelsea. That wasn't the scenario presented. I really don't see a dead rubber win having that much of an impact on a team's chances of winning the league the following season. I note you never answered my query about you and the escort. You don't get the rivalry, do you? It's just another 3 points to you.

You miss the point. I did not talk scenarios, I said your action of not wanting United to focus on preparing for the following season to their absolute max but instead focusing on Liverpool shows your desire for Liverpool to lose is stronger than United to win. Such therefore suggests you would rather Chelsea win twice than Liverpool followed by United otherwise you would want United to do all they possibly can to reclaim the trophy next season and you would accept there are no meaningless games. You would accept the focus must be to win every remaining game and to put in a performance that will return the confidence the squad has lost.

You would sooner the squad not find that confidence that is so important and Liverpool lose than find the confidence and be better for it.

I get the rivalry. But you don't understand elite performance, I'm approaching this from the mentality of the manager. And it's about the players and it's about being best prepared for the following season. I mean, you think there are such things as meaningless games therefore you do not understand elite performance. To think the last game of the season is meaningless is to think friendlies are meaningless also. Pre-season would be meaningless to you however I cannot accept such a viewpoint.

Alex Ferguson went mental when United won the league but did so with a draw. These are the standards you don't care for. He didn't care the league was won, he was furious with how they performed. Just like his rant when Aberdeen won the cup, he was furious at the performance.

Everybody on here understands the United - Liverpool rivalry and you are foolish to think they do not. The point here however is to understand the mentality of the champions, clearly you do not understand this. Champions win, these are the standards set and so it is important when they have failed in pursuit of the title one season then all focus and all attention is directed to winning it in the following season, one cannot do anything that would compromise this.

You would tell your players to compromise this. You would sooner Louis van Gaal have United lose the game than win it, just so you feel better. I can tell you now that Louis van Gaal wouldn't let you anywhere near the squad, and quite rightly so :nono:

You look at this from only the perspective of the fan ignorant of elite performance and mentality. There are no meaningless games, Liverpool had little to play for last season but they didn't throw in the towel, they were way off the pace after the first half of the season losing 6 of their 19 games but in the second half they lost 3. They could have given up and accepted the season to be a write off however they focused only on themselves, they focused on improving and it seems that was the right thing.

Ryan Giggs' focus now should be on winning these last four and ensuring the team are performing to the best of their ability. It is not a characteristic of the champion to lose games on purpose. It is the characteristic of the champion to win and this is what he must do.

Should you understand elite performance then you would understand why losing is not tolerated. Especially the Everton scenario that just happened, which on your part was disgusting behaviour, but even in your fantasy (very improbable) Liverpool one. The team should not lose focus of their own preparations, they should not get distracted by what their opponents are doing. They must focus on being the best they can because next season will be very tough and they will need to be on form if they are to rise above the rest.
 
Almost all other clubs, if not all clubs, boo the hell out of returnees most of the time as a matter of routine.

Not always, it depends on the manner of the departure. I've been to games at Brighton a lot in the last couple of seasons but I've only ever heard two returning players get booed (Glenn Murray and Stephen Dobbie, both of whom left Brighton for Cryst*l P*l*ce). Sure there are a few jeers if they miss a sitter or whatever but that happens anyway.

When (if) Poyet and Bridcutt come down and play Brighton next season that might be a different kettle of fish. Both left in a rather unsavoury way and I think both will get some off the crowd. Certainly Gus.
 
Give me misty eyed romanticism over the bullshit some third rate journo stuck on a page any day of the week. I've followed utd for over 30 years, through worse than we're seeing now, and no I really don't find it hilarious watching Utd sack a manager after less than a season in charge.

Anyone amused by the situation should take a step back and take a long hard look at why they follow a football club... but hey, thats modern fans for you....

Yep . . Instant dinners, on demand tv and instant gratification , Gimmme Gimme gimme, now now now . . .

The attention span of the average fan is extremely limited. Also, everybody is now an armchair pundit and some people cannot accept a difference of opinion.

Yeah kids these days and that music they listen to, ey?...Tell you what, I'd take a couple years in the doldrums just to weed out this lot.
 
Yeah kids these days and that music they listen to, ey?...Tell you what, I'd take a couple years in the doldrums just to weed out this lot.

You're like one of those plastic fans I bought from Wilkinsons - started fizzing, caught fire and fell over. Bit like the last 10 months, come to think of it...
 
If someone from the players confirms some of the staff which media has said about him, he will look a total idiot, not only misjudging things.

I don't think that there will be a mass exodus with either Van Gaal or Ancelotti. Both are managers who utilize players they have instead of making big culls and signing a lot of players. United will be pretty much the same (with probably 2-3 additions and 3-4 players leaving) next season.
I always thought the number of players going was exaggerated. However, we know Vidic is gone, Rio might as well, possibly Evra. I would hope Young. We need at least one CB, a backup RB(I am sick of the make do and mend when Rafael is injured), a LB, a couple of midfielders, a winger that can actually cross. I am also hoping a new manager will persuade Hernandez to stay.
 
Gone are the days when a fan follows a football club for any reason other than because they win. Rarely, anyway. And that is indeed highly unfortunate.

I'm sorry, but what utter nonsense.

Go and ask the fans of a club in the bottom half of the table, or from the lower leagues. Of course you want them to do as well as possible, but outside the few clubs that share the spoils at the top table, and those that gain promotion and so win a lot of games in a particular season, most fans accept that they are highly unlikely to reach that pinnacle.

The majority of fans support a club because they were born in the area, because their dad or close family member does, once you get old enough, it doesn't matter how badly they fair, the supporters will say loyal. It's only at the very top where the fans may be more fickle, or maybe younger fans are more prone to chop & change, but once you're set on one club, that's it.
 
Yeah kids these days and that music they listen to, ey?...Tell you what, I'd take a couple years in the doldrums just to weed out this lot.

:lol: This mentality was amazing especially when those posters posted next on an another thread how it is disgusting for fans to want United to lose a game just in order for Moyes to get sacked.

I always thought the number of players going was exaggerated. However, we know Vidic is gone, Rio might as well, possibly Evra. I would hope Young. We need at least one CB, a backup RB(I am sick of the make do and mend when Rafael is injured), a LB, a couple of midfielders, a winger that can actually cross. I am also hoping a new manager will persuade Hernandez to stay.

Don't expect Van Gaal to sign 6 players, DT, it just won't happen. A midfielder (hopefully two but highly unlikely), a left back and a CB would be the maximum number of players he'll sign. On the other side, expect all of Varela, Pearson, Keane, Lingaard and maybe a few others having their chances on the first team.
 
I see the fans who didn't support Moyes are being lambasted as being terrible fans again. How dare we have opinions which differ from the "true" fans. We're the real bastards in all of this, We should have been grateful the club was anything better than mid-table in League 2.
 
All this talk of modern fans, spoilt, gimme gimme gimme bollocks. :lol:

You have to laugh. The players (mainly giggs), and the board all agreed the whole time. Ferguson agrees he should be gone. The only reason it took so long is the 4th place clause.

All the "give him time", "united aren't that sort of club", moyes in camp are seething they were completely wrong. Brilliant. Very funny to be honest.
 
Someone came up to me today with the theory that we hired Moyes to sack him, so that the next manager we hire has a clean slate to follow. Not saying I believe that, just putting it out there.
 
All this talk of modern fans, spoilt, gimme gimme gimme bollocks. :lol:

You have to laugh. The players (mainly giggs), and the board all agreed the whole time. Ferguson agrees he should be gone. The only reason it took so long is the 4th place clause.

All the "give him time", "united aren't that sort of club", moyes in camp are seething they were completely wrong. Brilliant. Very funny to be honest.
This. I really wonder what those 'holier than thou' fans have to say now.
 
Aye, definitely the best for United. It's just the fans who want to continue beating Moyes with their e-stick and kick him while he's down and already sacked that are irritating. No dignity, no class.
then again, it doesn't reflect well on those fans.
 
One of moyes biggest downfall was his failure in the summer transfer market. He needed to be decisive with our midfield and left back situation, he wasn't. To be fair to him, he recognized what was needed. You could say Woodward basically screwed him up.
 
Someone came up to me today with the theory that we hired Moyes to sack him, so that the next manager we hire has a clean slate to follow. Not saying I believe that, just putting it out there.

Doubt that very much. However, the man following Sir Alex had a hell of a lot of pressure. The man following Moyes however...
 
I see the fans who didn't support Moyes are being lambasted as being terrible fans again. How dare we have opinions which differ from the "true" fans. We're the real bastards in all of this, We should have been grateful the club was anything better than mid-table in League 2.
All this talk of modern fans, spoilt, gimme gimme gimme bollocks. :lol:

You have to laugh. The players (mainly giggs), and the board all agreed the whole time. Ferguson agrees he should be gone. The only reason it took so long is the 4th place clause.

All the "give him time", "united aren't that sort of club", moyes in camp are seething they were completely wrong. Brilliant. Very funny to be honest.

Mockney's post on this is amazing. The Moyes-in forever camp somehow expected that their patience and staying by Fergie (ironically at that time Fergie himself actually became in favour of sack) will be vindicated in the end and they will proclaim themselves the best fans in the world, while all other plastic fans who wanted Moyes out would go and support Chelsea. However, in the end they looked just a group of naive childs who wouldn't even think for themselves and the final blow was when it has been 'semi-confirmed' that Fergie understod that Moyes has to go and Giggs was the leader of the troublemakers distancing himself from Moyes as early as January (when the majority of people here were still happy to give Moyes time). Of course, it is pointless to label Giggsy as a shit fan, but they can blame us gloryhunters, despite we did the same thing as him.
 
Someone came up to me today with the theory that we hired Moyes to sack him, so that the next manager we hire has a clean slate to follow. Not saying I believe that, just putting it out there.
i can see this as an "exclusive" piece by some ballague or custis in the coming days
 
For the record, and just so Revan doesn't start making up my opinions for me, I've supported Moyes from the day he was appointed to the day he was sacked.

I wouldn't have picked him personally but I think I understood the motivation behind it on the clubs part, safe pair of hands, old school British manager, build for the future etc. I think Gill going at the same time as Fergie was incredibly poor timing and ultimately I think it is the main thing behind how disastrous the season has been. Had Moyes come in with 2 or 3 top drawer players with him who knows what might have been. No point asking what if's at this point though.

Once again the club seem to have adopted a position of doing their laundry in public and I think Woodward shouldn't be too far behind Moyes. Regardless of results no one should be treated like Moyes was at the end, its not moral high ground or any of the nonsense Mockney is spouting, its just common decency. If I was a binman I'd expect to know I was being fired before everyone else.

And 10 months isn't long enough to get used to and put your mark on a job the size of the Utd manager IMO. I fear for the future, whoever comes in will have to rebuild the first team, play attacking football, win games, and deal with our 'supporters'.... piece of piss yeah.

My fear is that it will result in a short term approach & strategy, but again I don't really think long term exists in football anymore, it can't do when the average manager lasts about 12 months or whatever it is.

It's bascially Frank O'Farrell all over again.
 
Mockney's post on this is amazing. The Moyes-in forever camp somehow expected that their patience and staying by Fergie (ironically at that time when actually became in favour of sack) will be vindicated in the end and they will proclaim themselves the best fans in the world, while all other plastic fans who wanted Moyes out would go and support Chelsea. However, in the end they looked just a group of naive childs who wouldn't even think for themselves and the final blow was when it has been 'semi-confirmed' that Fergie understod that Moyes has to go and Giggs was the leader of the troublemakers distancing himself from Moyes as early as January (when the majority of people here were still happy to give Moyes time). Of course, it is pointless to label Giggsy as a shit fan, but they can blame us gloryhunters, despite we did the same thins as him.

Yeah, they've been proper rumbled. Hilarious.

And aye, @Mockney quoted me last night and made a similar post but I've only seen it now. Spot on.
 
I'm sorry Popps, but once you resort to blaming the modern world you've lost the argument. United sacked Moyes because he wasn't good enough. His record was awful. He'd failed to hit every target. Even his biggest mainstream supporters now agree. Everyone from Martin Samuel and Patrick Barclay to Sir Alex Ferguson. To want them [the club] to have persevered to their own detriment for the sake of validating your moral code is not noble, it's selfish.

And yes, it is like Frank O'Farrell. That great example of spoilt, instant gratification hungry modern football.
 
Yeah kids these days and that music they listen to, ey?...Tell you what, I'd take a couple years in the doldrums just to weed out this lot.

Yep, there's black and there's white... I know not of this peculiar grey you speak of.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.