Sparky_Hughes
I am Shitbeard.
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2008
- Messages
- 17,566
After seeing this my only thought was finally........Ive been saying that every time she opens her gob for months
I wouldn't say I actually dislike Walt yet but the opinion has certainly dropped over the last 2 seasons. I feel character development is one of the show's great strengths - Mike going from villain to hero, Skylar being very likeable to begin with and much more sinister later on and even Marie going from an annoyance to quite a likeable one now. Best of all is Hank - a bit of a bumbling idiot at times but I find him one of my favourite characters, despite conflicts with Wakt, something I know will be put to the test in the second half of S5.
Onto S5 now. Anyone else feel like it's really detached from the show? It's like it finished at S4 with "I won." And then we all pleaded for a 5th season, and this is what they came up with. Obviously it's still as good as anything else out there, but it just feels really detached, like they didn't really know how to continue from S4.
It gives absolutely NO info, indeed
I was just a tad disappointed by how Hank came to realize it was all Walt for the cliffhanger between part 1 and part 2 of season 5, I mean the whole show is about it being somewhat believable and subtle, I just don't understand how Walt could've left such a piece of evidence out in the open. Or is there an element I'm missing?
I don't think you're missing anything, I kind of got the impression that it summed up the change in Walt's character really, Gale clearly thought highly of him but he just didn't seem that bothered back, Gale looked up to him and gave him a gift which Walt essentially uses as toilet reading. Equally it wasn't really that big of a thing, it probably would be something you'd kind of forget, it wasn't a big bag of meth, it was a subtle note in a book which not many people would get.
Well I agree that on the face of it, it's 'just' a book and not a bag of meth, but still. It's a book with a note by Gale, whom Walt is fully aware Hank knows about, they even had a conversation about Walt Whitman and the poem. And it's not as if Hank and Marie never come over to their house, and the toilet is the place that they're bound to use, so leaving it there was a huge huge risk. I would've thought it more realistic had Walt come home just after that conversation with Hank and burned the book. Definitely not kept it in the toilet. I mean sure there's a lot that's gone on in Walt's life and it's quite believable that eventually he'd forget, but just after that conversation with Hanks, surely bells would've gone on in his head?
There's every chance that will be dealt with in the future, so unfair to call it a plot hole at the moment.
There's already plenty online about how he did it. Numerous hints were given in the show.
(The poisoning that is)
Just looked up some on Google to see if was missing anything and they had a "panel" at that comi con thing last weekend promoting next series, someone asked a question and the answer was "It was improbable, perhaps, but not impossible. Once he'd got that idea, spinning the gun and looking at that Lily of the Valley plant, I think probably he crushed some of the stuff up, put it in a juice box, got into Brock's school somehow." He admits that it would have been tricky, but that's "his best guess" as to how Walt did it." so I'd guess we won't get it explained as to what happened in the 2nd part!
Oh ok the ricin cigarette is pretty easy, I wondered whether Saul had been directly implicated in delivering the Lilly of the Valley to Brock himself.
Saul did it for Walt. he even says he did it. There's plenty online but in short, Jesse went to Saul's office for something "urgent" (which wasn't very urgent), the big fat bodyguard searched him down and swapped his pack with the ricin. Walt delivered the LotF to Brock in some way (this is the part that hasn't been explained yet).
Here's a good summary:
http://emiliajordan.com/2012/07/31/...ock-and-what-happened-to-the-ricin-cigarette/
It was something they should have explained clearly. If it was indeed Walt then it's a big moment in the series
There's no if's about it, him and Saul had quite a long conversation about it. He most definitely did do it.
Which episode was it? I'll have to look it up
it's actually all really obvious when you look back on it, everything is there for the viewer to see, you just wouldn't think about it until the final scene in season four I guess. The brilliant thing is that when Jessie has the gun to Walt's head, he's actually figured out the whole thing, he says he must have managed to swap the cigarettes somehow and find a way to poison Brock, but Walt manages to convince him that what actually is the truth, isn't.