Unreliable. Get Altay in there as soon as he's fit.
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 38
- Clean sheets
- 8
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 1
Was funny when in first half he sent 3/4 balls in the same area - outside for throw in (close to where one of the managers usually is on the touchline) and Arsenal fans cheered 
It doesn't matter. Are you suggesting we retain him as number 1 next year? The performance (even his) was much improved but he continually parries it into a dangerous area. Every single game he does it.
Bayindir, the beacon of reliability.
If the choice was between him and whoever our most promising youth keeper is next year, I'd roll the dice on a youngster honestly.
He's just so, so shaky. You know exactly what you're going to get from him and it's not good. Vitek or Harrison or whoever - I genuinely think they'd do better, even if still not good enough.
Of course it won't happen, but it's just where I'm at with this keeper of ours. Man I was excited for him to come in, watching him in that CL final. Man, would I make a terrible scout.
Bought him because he was a ball playing 'keeper, he's the absolute opposite.
Sell in the summer.
Sell in the summer.
He oozes reliability compared to Onana.
Awful player. So insecure in everything he does. Pushes balls back into play, doesn’t come out for crosses, poor passing.
I disagree. Onana is prone to some serious errors and in my view, should be replaced. However, Bayindir is certainly not that man.
Among our current keepers, he's the only sensible option. What we do in the summer is another matter. Hopefully that involves selling Onana for whatever we can get for him.
I'd be up for selling Onana in the summer. Though I have zero interest in dropping him for Bayindir.
Agree to disagree, especially if we're planning on selling Onana....or if we anticipate a game going to penalties.
Definitely one to replace, can't keep palming balls into danger zones and his passing has not been as advertised.
I’d be up for calling that a very solid match from our keeper
I think he was a rugby player in a previous life, the number of times he kicked the ball into touch.
Onana has saved penalties for us too. He's always been a better keeper than Bayindir.
Agreed. Didn't do a lot wrong. A couple of wayward kicks, but generally, not too bad. Arsenal didn't really create anything clear cut anyway.
How he's parrying that Odegaard shot out, it was a daisy cutter
That’s his style
There's no evidence of this. Bayandir has been more than reliable in limited appearances, especially in terms of box presence and and saving pens. Onana has been consistently erratic and unreliable since he's been here, hence all the negativity towards him in this thread. Its not personal, he's just not exhibited a shred of evidence that he was worth £47.2m or was remotely close to being good enough to start at a club like United.
Really? The you are lost!
He easily could have lost us the game with that terrible save at the end. Terrible distribution. Thw rest he did as you would expect any half decent professional goalie to deal with. His boxing when coming for balls is quite weak btw.
That save at the end? Not bad? Lucky Martinwlli skyed it
Lucky for Martinelli he was offside.
There's plenty of evidence. What has Bayindir ever achieved in his career? Onana performed pretty well this season from August up until maybe December. I'm not disputing that he is unreliable or erratic. I believe he should be sold.
However, the Arsenal FA Cup game, for Bayindir, is doing a lot of heavy lifting. His kicking in that game was appalling. How about the game against Spurs in the League Cup, where he was beaten directly from a corner?
We all want better, but putting your eggs in the Bayindir basket is not the one.
I can't believe in the 94th minute when it was played all the way back to him he just hoofed it straight to the arsenal defense. That was mine bogglingly stupid. I would drop him from the next match just for that nonsense. That was so infuriating
Martinelli was offside, so it's irrelevant. Either way, I'm no Onana fan. Just disagreeing with the idea of dropping him for Bayindir.
Me neither.
All that effort almost chucked in the bin by the same mistake he seems to pull out every other game.
I can't watch another season of him. He'll get his manager sacked.
The issue here isn't that Bayandir should be a permanent Onana replacement, its that Onana is a liability who should't be starting at United when a capable backup evokes more confidence than the starter. The club should quietly usher Onana out this summer just as the likes of Bosnich, Barthez, and Roy Carroll were let go for better options.
Incapable of keeping a clean sheet.
Can we not just play Onana until the summer, then sell him? There's no chance he'll be sold anyway, to be honest. We'd have to take a big hit on the fee and that won't help our PSR situation. Perhaps a loan away, or spending the season as the number two. Just not sure if the budget will stretch that far.
I'm sure he will play all league games and Altay will play EL games (if/when fit).
I don't think Onana will be a PSR consideration given that selling two of Rashford, Garnacho, and Mainoo will has homegrown players, have the biggest impact on PSR relief.
I’d say a keeper is very high on the list. Striker, wb, no.10 and keeper. Surely we can sign four players
Quite possibly.
I'm sure we'll be looking to move Rashford on. I don't see Mainoo sold. Garnacho perhaps, but even then, I'm not sure he will be.
There were genuine concerns he parries shots into the danger zone at Inter too. This is just who he is
I'd like to think we can bring in a keeper. Certain positions can be masked over a little easier, but it’s a huge problem when your keeper is gifting goals to the opposition.
Yeah, the you are lost.
What I wouldn’t give for an average but reliably consistent keeper like Carrol again.
I personally have never seen it with Onana. The priority for any goal keeper is at first to be good a saving shots it's in the position job description. Playing out from the back should never be a priority to sign a keeper in a team that doesn't keep possession succinctly.
I would sell Onana in an instant if a team is interested in his services.
I wouldn’t mind if his distribution was decent, but it’s as woeful as his shot stopping.
The only thing worse than his hands is his feet!