Alejandro Garnacho (out) | Chelsea make enquiries

Status
Not open for further replies.
Judas said:
I’ll be more sad for the idea and theory of how good he could potentially be, as opposed to the performances we generally see week after week. He’s not been great this season, but he will still be a big loss for this woeful side.
Click to expand...

People are seriously overrating him
 
always_hoping said:
Money can be got elsewhere and the team requires natural left back first and foremost than getting someone in to fit a system that currently struggles against most teams including the worst team in the Premier league as I seen in Old Trafford last Thursday.
Click to expand...

Oh where can we get money from then because from what I can see there aren't other places right now
 
croadyman said:
Oh where can we get money from then because from what I can see there aren't other places right now
Click to expand...
That's where people over transfers with competence comes in. Money quoted will be got for him is poor and will cost a lot more money to bring in a suitable replacement. If he was a Napoli or Chelsea player they would be looking for a lot more money for him knowing he's a player who has reached nowhere near his ceiling.
 
Devil81 said:
Are we going to sell a player of great potential and replace him with players who may or may not improve us. Given our track record of late it wouldn't surprise me in the slightest.

What a mess this club is.
Click to expand...

He can't play no.10.
He can't play no.10.
He can't freakin' play no.10.

You're looking at the player in isolation and not whether he can play in any given role that Amorim requires.

He. Cannot. Play. No.10.

What else matters? If he can't play WB, and he can't play no.10, and he can't play CF, what are you arguing for?
 




Wouldn't be terrible if we can snatch 60m out of them, they'll learn soon enough he's not worth it the same way we learned quickly with Mount
 
Hoof the ball said:
He can't play no.10.
He can't play no.10.
He can't freakin' play no.10.

You're looking at the player in isolation and not whether he can play in any given role that Amorim requires.

He. Cannot. Play. No.10.

What else matters? If he can't play WB, and he can't play no.10, and he can't play CF, what are you arguing for?
Click to expand...
This. People are struggling to get the fact that players who don't suit what the manager wants or needs, have to go.

Keeping players that clearly don't work in a squad is what will leave it to remain jumbled up and imbalanced.
 
Hoof the ball said:
He can't play no.10.
He can't play no.10.
He can't freakin' play no.10.

You're looking at the player in isolation and not whether he can play in any given role that Amorim requires.

He. Cannot. Play. No.10.

What else matters? If he can't play WB, and he can't play no.10, and he can't play CF, what are you arguing for?
Click to expand...

How old are you?

That post was like something a 13 year old would post. Calm yourself down, make your point in sensible manner.

Nobody is arguing with anyone, I'm not sure where you got that from my post.
 
Devil81 said:
How old are you?

That post was like something a 13 year old would post. Calm yourself down, make your point in sensible manner.

Nobody is arguing with anyone, I'm not sure where you got that from my post.
Click to expand...

Because your premise is flawed.

Replacing an ill-suited player who has no practical function within this system with a player, scouted continually, who is a correct profile is absolutely the right choice.

And that's before considerations of "pure profit" and what Garnacho leaving for £59m does for our spending capital moving forward.

Even his so-called potential is debatable. The egregious error is presuming that a player being this good at 20 means that he will be that much better when he's 25., when there's plentiful evidence that quick and early growths can, and do, top out very early in their careers.

Garnacho isn't going to add qualities to his game that make him viable for no. 10 role. He doesn't have that in him. Not the passing, or the vision, or the decision making.
 
I can not believe that we want to sell one of our best talents. That would be too stupid, even for United.
 
Just sell him, he is an old fashion winger that is useless in how we want to play. Try to get maximum transfer, I doubt Garnacho will be world class. He is good but not Ronaldo or Messi good.
 
I can understand selling him if there's a huge offer, which doesn't seem to be forth coming. But selling him to Chelsea would be extremely sour.

If he's sold, I do hope there's loads of add-ons included in any potential sale. Hopefully we have deals lined up to execute as soon as any sale goes through.
 
The way people are reacting to a potential sale, thank God you weren't here when Hughes, Ince, and Kanchelskis were all sold in 1 summer.

United don't sell good player's though. Goodness no.

Maybe someone should also tell Hughes (the first time), McGrath, Whiteside, Cole, Ronaldo, Beckham, RVN, Stam, etc. Sorry boys, you were all crap, because United don't sell good players.
 
would he even play for Chelsea? They haven’t even found a starting place for the last winger we sold them yet
 
Hoof the ball said:
Because your premise is flawed.

Replacing an ill-suited player who has no practical function within this system with a player, scouted continually, who is a correct profile is absolutely the right choice.

And that's before considerations of "pure profit" and what Garnacho leaving for £59m does for our spending capital moving forward.

Even his so-called potential is debatable. The egregious error is presuming that a player being this good at 20 means that he will be that much better when he's 25., when there's plentiful evidence that quick and early growths can, and do, top out very early in their careers.

Garnacho isn't going to add qualities to his game that make him viable for no. 10 role. He doesn't have that in him. Not the passing, or the vision, or the decision making.
Click to expand...

Okay pal, thanks for the reply. If I need to know anything else about football I will look you up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.