Guardian reader's comment:
'Might I make a suggestion about the "eye-test" thing?
I think Cummings knew perfectly well that the excuse would not fly. And I think it was deliberate.
For years, I've been working in and with China, and dealing with the Chinese government. Understanding Chinese government propaganda has always been a key part of that.
This isn't something they do so much any more, but in the 80s and 90s, the Chinese government would lie in a way that was easily spotted and easily caught out. This was deliberate. It was aimed at two things:
First, it can expose disloyal people. People who are not loyal supporters of the status quo may say they don't believe it.
Second, and more importantly, given that people in 80s and 90s China knew it wasn't a great idea to challenge the government, it is a power play. The government is saying, "I am telling you what is true. You might know that it is not true. You might see and hear the opposite. You might know the opposite. This does not matter. We define what is true, not you. We are so powerful that we can say whatever we want, and it becomes the truth."
It's something that I've suspected is part of the White House's strategy for a while.
I think this is why Cummings came up with such transparent nonsense about testing his eyes. In fact, I think it's a significant part of the whole press conference. What he said in the press conference was, essentially, "Hey, media and populace. I do not give a f--- what you think. I am in control, and I'm now going to lie, and you have to accept it. This is my country, and these are my truths."
It was a bit of a gamble in the current environment. It will be interesting to see whether it works out for him. I hope it doesn't. But if he stays in power through this, historians in other countries will look back on this moment and see it as a major step in Cummings taking control. (Historians in Britain will, of course, say whatever Cummings tells them to say, or they will be shot.)
This move will either destroy him or immeasurably strengthen him. I'm hoping for the former, but I fear the latter.'