The funny thing is, Rooney's two best periods of form arguably came when we werent all that amazing as a team. But what periods they were. The latter half of 2009/10 gave us a last minute semifinal winner against City, a winner in a cup final, four goals in two games against Milan, an away goal in Munich, and that obscene performance away at Arsenal. Then the injury, and the world cup, and the whores and the contract...and then the latter half of 2010/11, with the greatest goal in the history of the PL to win a derby, that howitzer to give us the lead against Chelsea in the league, an away winner at the sodding bridge in a CL quarter final, a winning goal in an FA cup quarter final against Arsenal, a man of the match performance with an away goal and an assist in CL semi final, and the small matter of a brilliant goal against Barcelona, at Wembley, in a European Cup final.
Thats why I think its absurd to say Suarez is now better than Rooney has ever been, because unless he does something special in the remaining few games which really count, Suarez' legendary season will mostly be remembered for him skullfecking Norwich.