The general consensus right after the first leg was that Rooney had been average, but in the following week it morphed into "he was rubbish" for some unknown reason. First and foremost, he was played out of position. He worked well, but his passing was a bit off. It was not much different to the first half against Norwich, and considering how much better the opposition was in Madrid Id say "average" was an apt description.
RVP was also very average tonight.
I dont understand the "Welbeck was on the wing" entirely either. He was the wider player of the two when we counterattacked but he certainly wasnt stationed wide for most of the match. RVP did a poor job of making himself available for most of the match. He seems a bit immune to criticism right now, especially compared to Rooney.