I would take him. But we should have went for him last summer.
It annoys me that we're linked with all these players in the Dutch national team, when most of them i'd never heard of - nevermind seen them play. I'd never heard of Buttner until we were on the verge of signing him & he isnt even an adequate LB back-up.
The Dutch league may have a few gems that can be unearthed of course, but we need established players this summer & give the youth within the ranks a chance - not talkin a punt of an average foreign lad with potential - we have United potential already!
Then next summer we can buy whoever Everton replace McCarthy with for twice the amount they paid! Genius!
This is already becoming very worrying.
To be fair, they are the two best slightly realistic options out there.
I see Clasie being mentioned a lot. Is there anything to suggest we are in for him or is it simply because he's Dutch?
Buttner was meant to sing for Southampton/Sunderland before we signed him. When he played, you could tell.
This thread blows my mind but its pretty addictive reading.
Ok if this is true then Woodward has ALOT to answer for.
Lets just get Sir Bobby Robson some new boots. He could still out perform Cleverley.
McCarthy is a terrific player. Would love to sign him.
Someone like McCarthy is who we should've got last year (when our silly targets didn't happen) and saved ourself £15m in the process to put towards another improvement this year.
Poor club management in the last few years here.
You mean you didn't know this already?Ok if this is true then Woodward has ALOT to answer for.
I think you're in the wrong forum man: https://www.redcafe.net/forums/fcuom.32/
Dutch press accuse English newspapers of making things up.
Is McCarthy really a player that's going to turn around our midfield woes? If we are going to sign any players from Everton Barkley surely the only one we should be interested in. We need to be signing players that have world class potential if we want to get back to where we were. We already have too many average players.
If he was brought it with a top class suitable replacement then why not? But on his own, no way.
It's fecking May. The season is only finished a week.
Chill out!
I think you are mentally deficient and stone drunk (as always).
James McCarthy is a great player, I'd love to have him here. Ask any Everton fan, and i'm sure they'l agree. Was in my opinion, their second best player this season after Coleman who was just pure class. If he was Spanish or German, everybody would be loving to hear it. He's one of the most complete midfielders in the premiership, and still has his best years in front of him. 15m + Cleverly please!
I think you're in the wrong forum man: https://www.redcafe.net/forums/fcuom.32/
Who isn't?Is Konoplyanka better than Nani/Young/Valencia/Zaha?