Whilst I agree with the general thrust of your post there one thing I think you have overlooked, the fact that we have several quality players (who aren't performing, yes) but from whom we would get more from provided we sign the right type of players to complement them. Players like ADM, Mata and Rooney are amongst the most dangerous in the game and with the addition of Depay there is no doubt in my mind that if we upgraded our midfield and right back we would see more output from our forwards e.g just imagine the chances we would have created on our right side if we had someone like Alves instead of AV! Next season Herrera would have settled, in Depay we could be having a more clinical and explosive player than anything we have on the wings, ADM would have rested and returned his confidence and we surely would have signed a midfielder to replace Carrick, and given that, if not for our delayed summer business that cost us dearly in the first three games, we were very close to all our rivals in all the games we played against them I'm sure that if play our cards right we will get close.
Hell, we pushed Bayern very close last season with an inept manager and a broken team.
We need a holding midfielder more than anything else. Vidal is a versatile midfielder, but I don't think he's suited for such role. Granted, he's a tough tackler, a dynamic and aggressive player - something we also need, but if we assume that we'll only be signing one midfielder this summer, then we should get someone to replace Carrick. A player in the mold of Pirlo, Xavi and Xabi Alonso. Verratti would be the perfect choice, in my opinion.
Of course, players like Pirlo and Xavi have always needed someone more defensive and dynamic to orchestrate the play from deep and Vidal could be that player for us, but as a Carrick replacement? I don't think so. I'd say that in a potential 4-3-3 United formation, Vidal would be battling with the likes of Herrera for a starting place.
This is not a discussion thread. Please take the long walls of text elsewhere.
Tweets and short reactions (as in one or two sentences max) only please.