The Mourinho Thread: Should he stay or go? | Sacked

Is Mourinho’s time as United manager up?

  • Yes

    Votes: 2,296 77.1%
  • No

    Votes: 293 9.8%
  • Not yet - needs more time to see if he can turn it around

    Votes: 388 13.0%

  • Total voters
    2,977
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not Jose's fault Palace couldn't score a goal, so we could show character and good game management to come back from behind and win it in the dying seconds...
 
Haven't bothered reading anything in this thread since the game. Let me guess, the usual suspects are still far up his arse?
 
McKola and those FullTime devils are JCL snowflake twats each of them have agendas. Howson is the worst. Wasnt he the one who also tried to con foreign Reds as well? Fat fecking prick
What on Earth is a JCL snowflake?
 
It was clear that this team was going nowhere. And that was the case even at the start of last season when the team was winning.

The signs were there:

1. poor work rate/movement on and off the ball - it's naive to explain it with players' laziness/attitude

2. slow build-up play, no clear patterns in attack - entirely on the manager

3. closely related to 1. and 2. - signing/playing too many very tall players, especially in midfield - the top 5 teams in the league don't have a single giant in midfield, United have 4 (!) - Matic, Pogba, Fellaini, McTominay. Having watched football for decades now, I can't remember a team with 4 midfielders over 190 cm tall. Insane.

On the basis of 3. alone one could have predicted already at the start of last season that this team was going nowehere.

Going by xG stats, 2nd place last season was a fluke. In terms of created and conceded chances, the team should have finished 6th - behind Arsenal (!). We're getting now what we were deserving last season.
This is what many tried telling Mourinho fans that 2nd place was fool's gold and not an accurate representation of the quality of side we were. Maybe it's because I'm into baseball so I'm used to stats pointing out results are about to come crashing back down to earth or rather, normalize. But the stats clearly pointed to 2nd place not being sustainable. We conceded the most chances on goal amongst the top 6 last season and we created the least amount of chances of the top 6 last season. Those two stats screamed unsustainability. Nobody can blame our summer for what was to come because those stats state that if all of us had the same exact side as when the season finished, United would fall below Liverpool, Spurs, etc...
 
Jose literally shouldn't last the weekend but having an equally incompetent Woodward above him means he'll be around for a while yet!

What are the board seeing that makes them Think it will change? As it has been said so many times before in this thread, every other club with any aspirations at all would have sacked him off already. Its ridiculous.
 
I don't think the boad think he can turn it around. I simply think they are shit scared of pulling the trigger because hey don't know what to do after. Furthermore, sacking him now is said to cost £25m+.
 
Not sure how much of the match going culture you know about, but it's always been a United fan rule that you never boo your own. I've seen people get punched in he face in the ground for booing. I even once saw a guy get a large coke poured over his head for booing.
That's extreme.
 
I thought he would be a Cantona like figure for us.. a damaged individual and a damaged club creating something special.

I was very wrong. Sir Bobby was right all along.
Yup, and the cnuts on here who abused Sir Bobby for it, need to hang their fecking heads in shame.
 
Jose literally shouldn't last the weekend but having an equally incompetent Woodward above him means he'll be around for a while yet!

What are the board seeing that makes them Think it will change? As it has been said so many times before in this thread, every other club with any aspirations at all would have sacked him off already. Its ridiculous.

Probably because they are looking through the lens of an Excel Spreadsheet that only shows columns until the end of May.

Mathematical probability of still reaching Champs League qualification - tick

Penalty clause for dismissing Jose early - tick

Still signing deals with obscure combined harvester companies - tick


Real business intelligence would tell them we are destroying assets (player morale) shrinking our market (fans turning off from dire football), destroying our brand (those Chinese noodle companies won't pay top dollar if we keep losing), plus instilling a toxic culture throughout the club that will help keep us down
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveJ
I don't think the boad think he can turn it around. I simply think they are shit scared of pulling the trigger because hey don't know what to do after. Furthermore, sacking him now is said to cost £25m+.

This is where the board are starting to get on my( . Y . )

We're the richest club in England and one of the richest in world. What is £25mil to Utd? Honestly it's a drop in the ocean, a dime a dozen. I can't understand why we're messing about over £25mil.
 
And you are not going to find a lot of people putting everything on Mourinho but he is the one choosing the material and he is also the one unable to make good use of said material. Which is why the first logical step is to change him because he is supposed to be a crucial cog in the entire operation.
Most fans agree with the idea that the board and Woodward should have tweaked the front office and brought someone with a strong technical expertise but it's easy to understand that people that have seen the club sustain 25 years of success with an organization that relied on an omnipotent manager would be wary to move on from it.

Woodward has its faults but he is good when it comes to the commercial and financial aspects of managements, he simply needs to delegate a part of his and the manager's roles to a specialist. As long as the board doesn't do that we will be justified to blame them. Regarding Mourinho as long as he fails to improve players individually, improve the team collectively, integrates new players effectively and obtain results that match the expectations, he will be a failure and will deserve to be sacked.

We always need to remember that he took the job of manager, not head coach. It's because of his failure at the former that we(fans) want to turn him into the latter.
Fair points
 
Get rid and start planning for next season. Trying to sign a new manager, a DoF and sell and buy half a squad in a summer window is madness.

But given the boards' inability to plan beyond our next tampon sponsor I have zero faith in the club doing the right thing.

We should have a new manager and DoF under pre-contract already. Anything less is negligence.
 
This is where the board are starting to get on my( . Y . )

We're the richest club in England and one of the richest in world. What is £25mil to Utd? Honestly it's a drop in the ocean, a dime a dozen. I can't understand why we're messing about over £25mil.
If Pochettino was available now and willing to come now, I would think they would pay it.
I too am frustrated he's still here. I think the biggest reason they haven't sacked him is because they don't have an alternative. Not because of how much it would cost to get rid.
That's what I would like to think. It would be an indictment of the club if the only reason he's still here is £25m.
 
I never liked Jose as a Utd manager even when people mentioned his names after SAF’s retirement. But blame him as much as you want but our current squad’s mentality and consistency is nowhere good enough even when compared to the teams we had prior to SAF. Just look at Pogba - and I really love the guy - but where what did he do in Palace game? We don’t have a leader on our team.

Erm Mourinho brought in these players and is then
responsible for them
 
I agree, but «good football» doesn’t soothe a lack of trophies. Good football without the medals is worth nothing to me.
It doesn't soothe a lack of trophies. But it makes the experience a whole lot more entertaining/interesting. If you had prior knowledge of us not winning the league for the next ten years would you stop watching? Personally, for me the quality and entertainment of the football absolutely matters. I watch football, after all, due to my emotional investment and the entertainment factor as well. Otherwise I'd just watch the live score update and be done with it.
 
This is where the board are starting to get on my( . Y . )

We're the richest club in England and one of the richest in world. What is £25mil to Utd? Honestly it's a drop in the ocean, a dime a dozen. I can't understand why we're messing about over £25mil.
Profit before tax last year was £26m. It could basically write off making a profit this year.
 
Last edited:
This is where the board are starting to get on my( . Y . )

We're the richest club in England and one of the richest in world. What is £25mil to Utd? Honestly it's a drop in the ocean, a dime a dozen. I can't understand why we're messing about over £25mil.
£25m is not a dime on the ocean tbf. £25m would be a dime in the ocean for the likes of Apple who have nearly £300 Billion revenue each year. In our case £25m is about 5% of the revenue which is quite a lot.
 
Profit before tax last year was £26m. It could basically write off making a profit this year.

Profit before tax is still profit after costs. Take a look at how much the Glazers take out of their business each year before coming to the opinion that they can't afford to buy any player they want for their team if they'd only be minded to do so.
 
Here ya go chicken https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mourinho-set-to-sign-contract-extension-done.435661/.

I have one post in there and I said “fantastic”. I feel sick :(

At least I’m not one of the many in here that just want to be right on the internet and I could adjust my opinion based on current circumstances rather that blind arrogance.
Thanks. And this thread too https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mou...-for-a-further-year-as-standard.435979/page-2

Think about 95% of the sentiment at that time was positive to extremely positive. Which just goes to show how badly he conned everyone at that time. When in actuality, that contract extension was one of the worst decisions to be taken post Fergie.
 
Yup, and the cnuts on here who abused Sir Bobby for it, need to hang their fecking heads in shame.

They won't do. The people who have literally been begging for Mourinho for years have got a lot to answer for. This club is supposed to mean something and in a quest to get success people were willing to throw this away.

Shame on them.
 
£26m profit doesn't seem a lot for 'the biggest club in the cosmos' or whatever we're calling ourselves this week.

*posts Is Ed Overrated/Underrated/Underpants? thread*
 
Thanks. And this thread too https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mou...-for-a-further-year-as-standard.435979/page-2

Think about 95% of the sentiment at that time was positive to extremely positive. Which just goes to show how badly he conned everyone at that time. When in actuality, that contract extension was one of the worst decisions to be taken post Fergie.

Yup. I mean look, up until this season I fully supported him. I could see the blatant cracks that were starting to appear and the Seville debacle was thoroughly disgusting, all of it. But still, I blindly thought he would have us playing better stuff this season and properly challenging.

I was totally and utterly wrong. I was wrong to have blind faith in him getting us back to the top table and I was wrong to believe that after all the shite last season, he would improve our football. Anyone that still supports him and can be happy with what they are watching week-in-week-out is either deluded or so arrogant that they won’t let reality get in the way of their pro-Mourinho narrative. My bet is most are in the latter camp.
 
Could we not make that money back through sponsorship or player sales?

Surely you realize that you don't find 25m worth of sponsorship that easily and while we can sale players we will have to bring others to replace them, on top of hiring a manager to replace him. Sacking him is simply a loss, there is no way around it, you can make an argument that it's worth it and that in a way it's an investment but that's a stretch.
 
Guardiola was given his contract extension at the end of last season, when he's definitely the most sought after manager in the world. The mind boggles as to why we were in such a hurry to extend the contract of our clown. His heart was never in this job, otherwise he wouldn't have been openly flirting with PSG. That was a huge red flag.
 
Thanks. And this thread too https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mou...-for-a-further-year-as-standard.435979/page-2

Think about 95% of the sentiment at that time was positive to extremely positive. Which just goes to show how badly he conned everyone at that time. When in actuality, that contract extension was one of the worst decisions to be taken post Fergie.

He didn't actually con anyone then. He simply regressed.

In the first half of his 1st season, despite the draws, we actually played some good football, creating a lot of chances. Second half was crap, but could be attributed to fixture congestion due to the EL. Then in the first half of his second season, we were clinical, but our style of play wasn't as good -- there was a clear regression from the eye-catching style of last season. But he was using Martial and Rashford very well, rotating them and helping their game. So we felt it was a matter of time before he achieved the combination of 1st season's style + 2nd season's clinical finishing.

He got the contract, then Sanchez happened, Martial was dropped, injuries hit our squad,our goals dried up in the 2nd half of his second season, though we came 2nd. And now, here we are in his 3rd season, devoid of both style and goal scoring ability. And our defense has regressed.

For all those who claim there was some progress just because we finished 2nd, a closer look at his career graph with us tells us otherwise.
 
Why can't he get the team up for games in the same way klopp or Guardiola does with their teams? I just don't understand how we are constantly being told, by the press, ex players and even Jose himself, that he is a winner and the best.
Where is this manager?
Personally I think his star burnt out years ago.
 
Could we not make that money back through sponsorship or player sales?
Maybe as one off but then players need replacing. I'm not sure our financial picture suggests we can write off £25m+ and the Glazers won't be bothered about it.
 
Thanks. And this thread too https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mou...-for-a-further-year-as-standard.435979/page-2

Think about 95% of the sentiment at that time was positive to extremely positive. Which just goes to show how badly he conned everyone at that time. When in actuality, that contract extension was one of the worst decisions to be taken post Fergie.

Just flicking through and this made me :lol:

I'm awaiting someone to complain saying this only means he'll get a big pay off when he has his traditional meltdown and gets sacked :rolleyes:
 
feck me, people were tagging me in that thread to 'laugh' at me.
Your turn now :)

Yup. I mean look, up until this season I fully supported him. I could see the blatant cracks that were starting to appear and the Seville debacle was thoroughly disgusting, all of it. But still, I blindly thought he would have us playing better stuff this season and properly challenging.

I was totally and utterly wrong. I was wrong to have blind faith in him getting us back to the top table and I was wrong to believe that after all the shite last season, he would improve our football. Anyone that still supports him and can be happy with what they are watching week-in-week-out is either deluded or so arrogant that they won’t let reality get in the way of their pro-Mourinho narrative. My bet is most are in the latter camp.
Fair fecks to you for owning up and also seeing the light, but like you said some won't do the same. This 'illustrious' list includes the likes of Neville to the average internet punter on here.
 
Here ya go chicken https://www.redcafe.net/threads/mourinho-set-to-sign-contract-extension-done.435661/.

I have one post in there and I said “fantastic”. I feel sick :(

At least I’m not one of the many in here that just want to be right on the internet and I could adjust my opinion based on current circumstances rather than blind arrogance.

I wasnt as optimistic, i warned that the sacking would be expensive. To be fair, i think a lot of people got conned by the Sanchez signing, it lifted the mood, myself included. And we were doing well at that time, and then came Sevilla
 
Status
Not open for further replies.